Uploaded July 2017 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
The preparations for this experiment started with us finding a line in an old chemistry textbook saying Ti would dissolve quite well in HF. As you probably know, it usually takes high temperatures and long periods until Ti dissolves in anything (check out our TiCl3 video for that). Therefore, we thought we could try this with HF, note the HF has around 40% concentration so around the HCl and the temperature was around 20°C when we did that so at cooler temperatures.
We filled a test tube with 5 ml of HF (40%) and added a small piece of Ti wire. The reaction started immediately quickly producing a purple - pink solution At some point, we added a bit of water. The color changes to green. In the end, you can see two layers, the upper one is the aqueous Ti-complex and the bottom one is insoluble [SiF6](2-).
The question is why does it react with HF better than with HCl? And we can't really find a suitable explanation. The fact that HF attacks glass is probably something different here. It could be because very stable Fluorocomplexes are formed. Elements like Zirconium, Titanium, even Iron are known to form stable Fluoride complexes although usually, Fluoride is a weak ligand. Titanium(III) and (IV) especially in acids also tends to form Titanyl, TiO2 and hydrated oxygen-rich species. So perhaps the equilibrium shifts towards the fluoride here because it resists the back-reaction to some extend and the passive layer is therefore destroyed.
And to be honest we have no clue what is happening in this experiment at all. Even the Gmelin does not really talk a lot about the chemistry between HF and Ti metal. According to other books, the following reaction is very likely:
Much like with HCl, HF dissolves the Ti to form Ti(III). For the chloro-species, there are many isomers much like with Chromium. While the [Ti(H2O)6]Cl3 and also the [Ti(H2O)6]F3 are said to be purple-red their isomer, [Ti(H2O)4Cl2]Cl is green. And we think this is the case for the fluoro complex as well.
The question remains why this happens here and not the other way around? What might happen is that the pure Hexaqua-complex acts as a cationic acid and is deprotanted as the conc. of H(+) from HF is diluted with the addition of water. Then the famous Titanium-Oxy and Hydroxy-species form and perhaps somewhere in this cycle Fluoride can take the positions.
If you find anything about the actual reaction we would be really interested to hear about it.
Also if you ask yourself why we think the colors here are purple and green. We ran this experiment twice before with different concentrations and it would always self-heat to a point where it got out of control producing much more intense colored compounds which were really deep purple and grass green.
The preparations for this experiment started with us finding a line in an old chemistry textbook saying Ti would dissolve quite well in HF. As you probably know, it usually takes high temperatures and long periods until Ti dissolves in anything (check out our TiCl3 video for that). Therefore, we thought we could try this with HF, note the HF has around 40% concentration so around the HCl and the temperature was around 20°C when we did that so at cooler temperatures.
We filled a test tube with 5 ml of HF (40%) and added a small piece of Ti wire. The reaction started immediately quickly producing a purple - pink solution At some point, we added a bit of water. The color changes to green. In the end, you can see two layers, the upper one is the aqueous Ti-complex and the bottom one is insoluble [SiF6](2-).
The question is why does it react with HF better than with HCl? And we can't really find a suitable explanation. The fact that HF attacks glass is probably something different here. It could be because very stable Fluorocomplexes are formed. Elements like Zirconium, Titanium, even Iron are known to form stable Fluoride complexes although usually, Fluoride is a weak ligand. Titanium(III) and (IV) especially in acids also tends to form Titanyl, TiO2 and hydrated oxygen-rich species. So perhaps the equilibrium shifts towards the fluoride here because it resists the back-reaction to some extend and the passive layer is therefore destroyed.
And to be honest we have no clue what is happening in this experiment at all. Even the Gmelin does not really talk a lot about the chemistry between HF and Ti metal. According to other books, the following reaction is very likely:
Much like with HCl, HF dissolves the Ti to form Ti(III). For the chloro-species, there are many isomers much like with Chromium. While the [Ti(H2O)6]Cl3 and also the [Ti(H2O)6]F3 are said to be purple-red their isomer, [Ti(H2O)4Cl2]Cl is green. And we think this is the case for the fluoro complex as well.
The question remains why this happens here and not the other way around? What might happen is that the pure Hexaqua-complex acts as a cationic acid and is deprotanted as the conc. of H(+) from HF is diluted with the addition of water. Then the famous Titanium-Oxy and Hydroxy-species form and perhaps somewhere in this cycle Fluoride can take the positions.
If you find anything about the actual reaction we would be really interested to hear about it.
Also if you ask yourself why we think the colors here are purple and green. We ran this experiment twice before with different concentrations and it would always self-heat to a point where it got out of control producing much more intense colored compounds which were really deep purple and grass green.







![Thermochromism: Tl2[HgI4]
This is the last video where we explore the different Tetraiodomerucrates. The explanation is probably the same as for Cu and Ag here, although it is really hard to see the result. According to literature, it is supposed to turn red in the process of heating it.
It is a bit hard to see but in the beginning the compound was dark yellow and in the end it was red. Thermochromism: Tl2[HgI4]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/aJfFY2iIgxU/mqdefault.jpg)


![Tellurium Chemistry: Two flame colors of Tellurium [hard to see]
If Te compounds are burned the flame color is said to be a mix of green and blue and if the right temperatures are chosen a green flame can be seen in the colder part of the burner while a blue flame shows in the hot parts. It seems to be due to an oxidation taking place. Not only is the Te ionized when heated in a hot flame but also oxidized by the air at the elevated temperature. The green flame is supposed to be the oxidation to Te(IV) while the blue flame is the oxidation to Te(VI).
There is another element in the PSE that changes color depending on the temperature of the flame and that is Thulium...which we unfortunately dont have at the moment. But we will order some, soon and try that.
What you can see here is us holding a bit of Te at the very end of the flame of a burner then moving it closer to the core of the flame. At first the flame really seems to be slightly greenish. The cam doesnt pick it up well but it was way greener than the core flame which is blue. Maybe someone can try this with a better cam again.
Also if you find more information on this reaction we would be happy to get some additional information on this as it was hard to find anything on this phenomenon. Tellurium Chemistry: Two flame colors of Tellurium [hard to see]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/axVQjKBFsbs/mqdefault.jpg)