Iron Chemistry: Ligand Substitution (Thiocyanate-Fluoride) @colorfulchemistry2569
Iron Chemistry: Ligand Substitution (Thiocyanate-Fluoride)  @colorfulchemistry2569
Uploaded September 2016 | Updated November 2026, 18 hours ago
Iron(III)-Ions (yellow) form the dark red complex Fe(SCN)3 if dropped into a a solution of Ammonium thiocyanate (or any other soluble Thiocyanate salt). This can be used to identify Iron.

Actually this first step is already a ligand substitution from the "Hexaqua" which is not really present since pure [Fe(H2O)6]3+ which is actually purple is a strong cationic acid comparable to the acid strength of Phosphoric Acid (!) forming in water the famous yellow [Fe(H2O)5(OH)](2+) complex.

If the Hexaqua-complex is assumed in the first step then the red product forming has in solution a composition like
"[Fe(SCN)3(H2O)3]" .

This compound can be discolored again using Fluoride-Ions. As solid Sodium Fluoride is dropped into the beaker (first floating on top of it) it will discolor everything in it's path as it falls towards the bottom forming a colorless
"[FeF5(H2O)](2-)" complex. Some even say "[FeF6](3-)" but it's probably the first one with another water ligand".

-----------------------------------------------NOTE------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The following is a very common explanation on the reaction between Iron-SCN and Fluorides:

An interesting fact is that Cobalt(II)Chloride will form a similar complex with Thiocyanate which is blue. The addition of Fluoride won't discolor it as for example in nature Cobalt-Sulfur-minerals are often found "Co-S-Bonds" are quite stable, so stable that Fluoride won't displace it. The "Fe-S-Bonds" are weaker thus forming the colorless Fluoride complex.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now there is a problem with this statement. And we will cover Thiocyanates in an upcoming video. Many 3d-elements like Fe, Co, ... form Isothiocyanates, not Thiocyanates ! Literature usually does not call them like that but in fact they coordinate via the N-side not the S-Side making them Iso-Thiocyanates. So the red compound formed in this video is actually an Iron-Isothiocyanate.
So the stability of the Co-NCS (Isothiocyanate called NCS now) is higher because of something completely different. I believe it is due to the "Hardness" of the Iron(III)-cation. Iron(III) has a higher oxidation state and is way smaller than Co(II) making it a harder acid. The HSAB-concept (explained in another video) shows that Hard-Acids and Bases form strong bonds. Fluoride is a really hard Lewis-base so a Fe(III)-F-Bond is stronger than a Co(II)-F bond. That is why the Fe(III)-F-Complex does not appear to be in an equilibrium with the Isothiocyante.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Other arguments use orbital theories to tell whether the S-Side or the N-Side is more likely to form a stronger bond since "hardness" is somewhat complicated to compare for d-Metals, the "d" is short for diffuse, so even an Fe(III) is somewhat soft compared to an Al(III).

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The last question is, why is the thiocyanate complex that colored and the fluoride one isn't ? Iron(III) has a d5 situation which makes it similar to Mn(II)Chloride which is also colorless in solution.

We have to remind ourselves that these transfers are actual electron movements. We always reduce this to the photon from the light shining on the sample but in fact it's a red-ox reaction. The central atom here acts as a Lewis Acid or an electron acceptor, the Ligand needs to possess an electron donor function to carry out a charge transfer transition.

Charge Transfer is nothing limited to colored compounds only. It always happens as soon as you have ligands ! Sometimes the d-d-Transitions are just more intensive or in the visible region and thus stronger than the CT-effects. Still charge transfer happens and becomes important in the second where the d-d-Transition is totally forbidden like spin forbidden.

So for Iron(III)Isothiocyanate and Iron(III)Fluoride the situation is the same. Fe d5 spin forbidden. Color has to come from CT now. But Fluorine is the most electronegative element in the PSE. Of course a fluoride would never donate its electron to the metal making this impossible to happen in a visible region. For Thiocyanate....well SCN doesn't pull electrons the way the halogens do so less energy is required and the stuff absorbs visible light now.
Iron Chemistry: Ligand Substitution (Thiocyanate-Fluoride)Phosphorus Chemistry: Thermally cracking red Phosphorus and white Phosphorus combustion on airBoron Chemistry: Trimethylborate (read explanation)Mercury Chemistry: HgO yellowPalladium Chemistry:  Bis(Dimethylglyoximato-Palladium(II))Palladium Chemistry: Tetracyanopalladate(II)Copper Chemistry: Copper(I) BromideArsenic Chemistry: As(III) oxidation by IodineCopper Chemistry: Cu(I)-Iodide (Redox)Mercury Chemistry: Reacting Hg[CrO4] with KCNThermochromism: Cu2[HgI4]Arsenic Chemistry: Making an As mirror from AsH3
Colorful Chemistry |

Iron Chemistry: Ligand Substitution (Thiocyanate-Fluoride)

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER