Uploaded May 2017 | Updated November 2026, 18 hours ago
Borates have an interesting property, the burn with a green flame. Now you could hold a bit of borax in a flame but the sodium would probably emit too much yellow light. Another way is to burn the compound Trimethyl borate. Methanol, Borax, and H2SO4 (a few drops) are mixed and ignited. The acid reacts with the Borax to form boric acid which is esterified by Methanol under acid catalysis forming the gas Trimethyl borate. This burns with a green flame and you can also burn it in a flask. If you burn the Methanol itself, however, it will always contain some boron and turn green while it burns much longer.
Now the question is why is the flame green? And to be honest it is really hard to find anything on that topic. Starting from Thallium (and we will show this collection once we get a Gallium salt) Thallium burns with a green flame. This is a transition between the 7²S(1/2) and the 6²P(3/2). Next Indium shows a blue flame which derives from a similar jump between 6²S(1/2) and 5²P(1/2) or (3/2).
For Gallium, you can still observe a blue flame which derives again from the jump between 5²S(1/2) and the two 4²P's.
Also from Thallium to Gallium the energy gap between the two spin-orbit states P(1/2) and (3/2) becomes smaller Tl (~160 nm), In (~40 nm) and Ga (~15 nm) so the two characteristic emission lines also move closer to each other.
If you ever held an Aluminium salt into a flame you know there isn't any visible emission anymore. So from Thallium back to Aluminium, the emitted wavelength becomes more and more blueshifted.
But why is Boron green?
The answer is what we see here is not an atomic emission but a molecular emission! A group researched the green flame of boron compounds and found a BO2-molecular excitation.
In our Diborane video, you can see a similar green flame. Whenever this BO2-emission is observed it is called a "fluctuation band" of Boron.
You might ask yourself what "BO2" could be. And the first ideas about the existence of said molecule actually come from this green emission. What happens is the boric acid H3BO3 forms at higher temperatures chains of Metaboric acid, a polymer where each Boron unit can be reduced to an "HBO2". Now, in theory, a OH(-) can react with HBO2 to form H2O and BO2 which might happen in hot flames. "Boron-Acids" all tend to form water when heated to hot temperatures and BO2 would be the first molecule which can't do that anymore. Also, many other possible compositions didn't show the same green emission band as this "BO2" which is why today it is a widely accepted explanation. It was also found by mass spectrometry at some point.
Borates have an interesting property, the burn with a green flame. Now you could hold a bit of borax in a flame but the sodium would probably emit too much yellow light. Another way is to burn the compound Trimethyl borate. Methanol, Borax, and H2SO4 (a few drops) are mixed and ignited. The acid reacts with the Borax to form boric acid which is esterified by Methanol under acid catalysis forming the gas Trimethyl borate. This burns with a green flame and you can also burn it in a flask. If you burn the Methanol itself, however, it will always contain some boron and turn green while it burns much longer.
Now the question is why is the flame green? And to be honest it is really hard to find anything on that topic. Starting from Thallium (and we will show this collection once we get a Gallium salt) Thallium burns with a green flame. This is a transition between the 7²S(1/2) and the 6²P(3/2). Next Indium shows a blue flame which derives from a similar jump between 6²S(1/2) and 5²P(1/2) or (3/2).
For Gallium, you can still observe a blue flame which derives again from the jump between 5²S(1/2) and the two 4²P's.
Also from Thallium to Gallium the energy gap between the two spin-orbit states P(1/2) and (3/2) becomes smaller Tl (~160 nm), In (~40 nm) and Ga (~15 nm) so the two characteristic emission lines also move closer to each other.
If you ever held an Aluminium salt into a flame you know there isn't any visible emission anymore. So from Thallium back to Aluminium, the emitted wavelength becomes more and more blueshifted.
But why is Boron green?
The answer is what we see here is not an atomic emission but a molecular emission! A group researched the green flame of boron compounds and found a BO2-molecular excitation.
In our Diborane video, you can see a similar green flame. Whenever this BO2-emission is observed it is called a "fluctuation band" of Boron.
You might ask yourself what "BO2" could be. And the first ideas about the existence of said molecule actually come from this green emission. What happens is the boric acid H3BO3 forms at higher temperatures chains of Metaboric acid, a polymer where each Boron unit can be reduced to an "HBO2". Now, in theory, a OH(-) can react with HBO2 to form H2O and BO2 which might happen in hot flames. "Boron-Acids" all tend to form water when heated to hot temperatures and BO2 would be the first molecule which can't do that anymore. Also, many other possible compositions didn't show the same green emission band as this "BO2" which is why today it is a widely accepted explanation. It was also found by mass spectrometry at some point.


 forms when KCN is added to PdI2 and obviously something happened here.
If we ever get some Hg(CN)2 we might try to do it in a different way or even try to make the polymer but by now lets assume it is a cyanide complex of Pd(II). Palladium Chemistry: Tetracyanopalladate(II)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/SGtimbtRnlQ/mqdefault.jpg)



![Mercury Chemistry: Reacting Hg[CrO4] with KCN
When we looked for more information on the thermal decomposition products of Hg2[CrO4] we found a small note in an old book that it would react with KCN to form Hg(CN)2 and Hg. We already showed this reaction in a previous video. So we got the idea to test the same thing with the Hg[CrO4]. When we tried it we did not get the black Hg(0) as no Hg(I) was present. Instead, it turned all yellow. It took us a few seconds to come up with the idea that perhaps the yellow [CrO4](-) ion could be released again once the Hg(CN)2 forms.
To test it we added some dilute H2SO4 in H2O2 to it to form the characteristic blue CrO(O2)2 complex. To be honest we dont know why it did not form for the Hg(I) reaction. It might be because we worked with smaller amounts of Hg2[CrO4], or the mercury masked it somehow. Mercury Chemistry: Reacting Hg[CrO4] with KCN](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/TJQQr09-caY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Thermochromism: Cu2[HgI4]
The explanation is the same as for the Silver compound.
We made this by reacting CuSO4 with the HgI4]2- solution we made in the previous video. In the first step, excess Iodide reacts with the Cu(II) and reduces it to Cu(I). The Cu(I) then precipitates a red Cu2[HgI4] from the solution. If this is heated a brown-black high-temperature modification forms.
We would like to take the rest of the space here and explain the structural differences again. As mentioned before the HT form is a zinc-blende-type. In solid state chemistry for a cubic packing, there are tetrahedral sites and octahedral sites, and there are 2 x more tetrahedral sites than there are ions, which make up the lattice. As explained, the Iodide builds an fcc, so there are 8 tetrahedral sites. If all those are occupied by counter-ions you get a Fluorite-Type (CaF2). The Fluorite can be thinned a bit to yield different structures like PbO, PtS, ... but also ZnS, the zinc-blende. In zinc blende, only half of the tetrahedral voids are filled. This structure is realized in the high-temperature form of M2[HgI4] as well because every tetrahedral void has a chance to be occupied. For an x-ray analysis, this appears to be cubic and zinc-blende-type then.
For the low-temperature form, the Hg(II) and Cu(I) do not mix but build up layers in one direction. The structure becomes tetragonal and you have to add another lattice in this direction to make a double-lattice. So there is a layer with half of the sites filled by Cu(I) followed by a layer with only 1 out of 4 sites filled with an Hg(II) followed by Cu(I) again.
That small structural change causes a minor decrease in the band gap for the high-temperature form.
According to Fukuda, and we love the books from Fukuda on Coordination chemistry, there is also a reaction which looks like this:
Cu(+) I(-) Hg(2+) to Cu(2+) I(-) Hg(+)
And this equilibrium is thermally settled and also changes the color of the compound, as electrons move from the Copper to the Mercury, the absorption becomes redshifted. One could see this as a Metal-to-Metal-charge Transfer, much like in Prussian Blue for example. Thermochromism: Cu2[HgI4]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpNdQWtbkjw/mqdefault.jpg)


