Uploaded November 2025 | Updated September 2026, 6 days ago
The Commodore No. 2 first appeared in Albert Crockett’s Old Waldorf book in 1931. His recipe was equal parts bourbon, crème de cacao, and lemon, plus a dash of grenadine. Simple… but sweet, and the bourbon gets buried and the grenadine is almost undetectable.
SHOP YOU KLARIS ICE MAKER HERE ➡️
craftklaris.com/discount/TOTR10?redirect=/products/klaris-clear-ice-maker
DON'T FORGET THE PROMO CODE FOR YOUR 1O% DISCOUNT ➡️ TOTR10
TRY STEVE THE BARTENDER BITTERS ➡️ https://shop.stevethebartender.com.au/?ref=TOTR10
USE MY CODE TOTR10 FOR 10% OFF
FREE COCKTAIL BIBLE V.2 ➡️ https://totr.ck.page/3308168d16
JOIN OUR PATREON ➡️ patreon.com/totr?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator&utm_content=join_link
Before that, the name “Commodore” showed up in Europe:
– McElhone (1922): whiskey sour + orange bitters
– Craddock (1930): basically the same thing
Meanwhile, Crockett’s “Commodore No. 1” was something else entirely—a rum sour with a little grenadine or raspberry syrup.
So the Waldorf’s No. 2 ends up being its own thing: a bourbon/cacao/lemon cocktail unrelated to the European versions.
The original specs aren’t great, so I reworked it into something still on the sweet side, but balanced and a lot more expressive.
My Commodore No. 2
1.5 oz Bourbon
0.75 oz Crème de cacao
0.75 oz Lemon
0.25 oz Grenadine
Coupe dusted with smoked paprika.
The Commodore No. 2 first appeared in Albert Crockett’s Old Waldorf book in 1931. His recipe was equal parts bourbon, crème de cacao, and lemon, plus a dash of grenadine. Simple… but sweet, and the bourbon gets buried and the grenadine is almost undetectable.
SHOP YOU KLARIS ICE MAKER HERE ➡️
craftklaris.com/discount/TOTR10?redirect=/products/klaris-clear-ice-maker
DON'T FORGET THE PROMO CODE FOR YOUR 1O% DISCOUNT ➡️ TOTR10
TRY STEVE THE BARTENDER BITTERS ➡️ https://shop.stevethebartender.com.au/?ref=TOTR10
USE MY CODE TOTR10 FOR 10% OFF
FREE COCKTAIL BIBLE V.2 ➡️ https://totr.ck.page/3308168d16
JOIN OUR PATREON ➡️ patreon.com/totr?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator&utm_content=join_link
Before that, the name “Commodore” showed up in Europe:
– McElhone (1922): whiskey sour + orange bitters
– Craddock (1930): basically the same thing
Meanwhile, Crockett’s “Commodore No. 1” was something else entirely—a rum sour with a little grenadine or raspberry syrup.
So the Waldorf’s No. 2 ends up being its own thing: a bourbon/cacao/lemon cocktail unrelated to the European versions.
The original specs aren’t great, so I reworked it into something still on the sweet side, but balanced and a lot more expressive.
My Commodore No. 2
1.5 oz Bourbon
0.75 oz Crème de cacao
0.75 oz Lemon
0.25 oz Grenadine
Coupe dusted with smoked paprika.










