Uploaded September 2016 | Updated November 2026, 18 hours ago
If you saw our CuCl video we mentioned there that no major reaction happens if a chloride or bromide is added to Copper Sulfate. Some might have seen a minor color change in between and indeed there is a reaction but we didn't want the Cu(I) video to be too confusing so we assumed there that no reaction takes place. For the reduction it does not matter as long as Cu(I) and Cl(-) ions are present the insoluble Cu(I)-Chloride will precipitate. But what if no reducing agent is added ?
As we add Potassium Chloride to a conc. Copper Sulfate solution it turns green. And this is due to the formation of [CuCl4](2-). If you saw our video on Cobalt chemistry we had a similar case there. It is true that a very strong ligand can substitute a weak one but all of these reactions are equilibria. In some cases one side of the equilibrium is favored so we don't see the back reaction. No in aqueous Chloride solution two complexes might form, [Cu(H2O)4](2+) or [CuCl4](2-).
Note: Yes it is an octahedron around Copper but due to Jahn Teller Distortion two axial H2O are further away and [Cu(H2O)4](2+) does exist as ion as well. We use it to have an easier stoichiometry and 1 Chloride will act on 1 Water that way which makes it easier to see.
So the equilibrium is like:
4 Cl(-) + [Cu(H2O)4](2+) to [CuCl4](2-) + 4 H2O
Now let's assume we are on the right side of the equation. In order to to form the blue aqua complex it will have to react with water. Now lets assume we have an excess of Chloride in there which means there is less water in comparison to complex ion and chloride it can't fully go back and thus the equilibrium shifts towards the Chloro-ligand side. We call this Le Chatelier's principle.
Now this compound is not green. In fact it is yellow and the green color comes from mixing with the blue aqua-complex which forms as well. To show this we added some HCl to anhydrous CuSO4 (white) to get a beautiful yellow solution containing the yellow [CuCl4](2-).
If you saw our CuCl video we mentioned there that no major reaction happens if a chloride or bromide is added to Copper Sulfate. Some might have seen a minor color change in between and indeed there is a reaction but we didn't want the Cu(I) video to be too confusing so we assumed there that no reaction takes place. For the reduction it does not matter as long as Cu(I) and Cl(-) ions are present the insoluble Cu(I)-Chloride will precipitate. But what if no reducing agent is added ?
As we add Potassium Chloride to a conc. Copper Sulfate solution it turns green. And this is due to the formation of [CuCl4](2-). If you saw our video on Cobalt chemistry we had a similar case there. It is true that a very strong ligand can substitute a weak one but all of these reactions are equilibria. In some cases one side of the equilibrium is favored so we don't see the back reaction. No in aqueous Chloride solution two complexes might form, [Cu(H2O)4](2+) or [CuCl4](2-).
Note: Yes it is an octahedron around Copper but due to Jahn Teller Distortion two axial H2O are further away and [Cu(H2O)4](2+) does exist as ion as well. We use it to have an easier stoichiometry and 1 Chloride will act on 1 Water that way which makes it easier to see.
So the equilibrium is like:
4 Cl(-) + [Cu(H2O)4](2+) to [CuCl4](2-) + 4 H2O
Now let's assume we are on the right side of the equation. In order to to form the blue aqua complex it will have to react with water. Now lets assume we have an excess of Chloride in there which means there is less water in comparison to complex ion and chloride it can't fully go back and thus the equilibrium shifts towards the Chloro-ligand side. We call this Le Chatelier's principle.
Now this compound is not green. In fact it is yellow and the green color comes from mixing with the blue aqua-complex which forms as well. To show this we added some HCl to anhydrous CuSO4 (white) to get a beautiful yellow solution containing the yellow [CuCl4](2-).
![Iron Chemistry: Ligand Substitution (Thiocyanate-Fluoride)
Iron(III)-Ions (yellow) form the dark red complex Fe(SCN)3 if dropped into a a solution of Ammonium thiocyanate (or any other soluble Thiocyanate salt). This can be used to identify Iron.
Actually this first step is already a ligand substitution from the Hexaqua which is not really present since pure [Fe(H2O)6]3+ which is actually purple is a strong cationic acid comparable to the acid strength of Phosphoric Acid (!) forming in water the famous yellow [Fe(H2O)5(OH)](2+) complex.
If the Hexaqua-complex is assumed in the first step then the red product forming has in solution a composition like
[Fe(SCN)3(H2O)3] .
This compound can be discolored again using Fluoride-Ions. As solid Sodium Fluoride is dropped into the beaker (first floating on top of it) it will discolor everything in its path as it falls towards the bottom forming a colorless
[FeF5(H2O)](2-) complex. Some even say [FeF6](3-) but its probably the first one with another water ligand.
NOTE
The following is a very common explanation on the reaction between Iron-SCN and Fluorides:
An interesting fact is that Cobalt(II)Chloride will form a similar complex with Thiocyanate which is blue. The addition of Fluoride wont discolor it as for example in nature Cobalt-Sulfur-minerals are often found Co-S-Bonds are quite stable, so stable that Fluoride wont displace it. The Fe-S-Bonds are weaker thus forming the colorless Fluoride complex.
Now there is a problem with this statement. And we will cover Thiocyanates in an upcoming video. Many 3d-elements like Fe, Co, ... form Isothiocyanates, not Thiocyanates ! Literature usually does not call them like that but in fact they coordinate via the N-side not the S-Side making them Iso-Thiocyanates. So the red compound formed in this video is actually an Iron-Isothiocyanate.
So the stability of the Co-NCS (Isothiocyanate called NCS now) is higher because of something completely different. I believe it is due to the Hardness of the Iron(III)-cation. Iron(III) has a higher oxidation state and is way smaller than Co(II) making it a harder acid. The HSAB-concept (explained in another video) shows that Hard-Acids and Bases form strong bonds. Fluoride is a really hard Lewis-base so a Fe(III)-F-Bond is stronger than a Co(II)-F bond. That is why the Fe(III)-F-Complex does not appear to be in an equilibrium with the Isothiocyante.
Other arguments use orbital theories to tell whether the S-Side or the N-Side is more likely to form a stronger bond since hardness is somewhat complicated to compare for d-Metals, the d is short for diffuse, so even an Fe(III) is somewhat soft compared to an Al(III).
The last question is, why is the thiocyanate complex that colored and the fluoride one isnt ? Iron(III) has a d5 situation which makes it similar to Mn(II)Chloride which is also colorless in solution.
We have to remind ourselves that these transfers are actual electron movements. We always reduce this to the photon from the light shining on the sample but in fact its a red-ox reaction. The central atom here acts as a Lewis Acid or an electron acceptor, the Ligand needs to possess an electron donor function to carry out a charge transfer transition.
Charge Transfer is nothing limited to colored compounds only. It always happens as soon as you have ligands ! Sometimes the d-d-Transitions are just more intensive or in the visible region and thus stronger than the CT-effects. Still charge transfer happens and becomes important in the second where the d-d-Transition is totally forbidden like spin forbidden.
So for Iron(III)Isothiocyanate and Iron(III)Fluoride the situation is the same. Fe d5 spin forbidden. Color has to come from CT now. But Fluorine is the most electronegative element in the PSE. Of course a fluoride would never donate its electron to the metal making this impossible to happen in a visible region. For Thiocyanate....well SCN doesnt pull electrons the way the halogens do so less energy is required and the stuff absorbs visible light now. Iron Chemistry: Ligand Substitution (Thiocyanate-Fluoride)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Q4OfkdyMLRQ/mqdefault.jpg)




 forms when KCN is added to PdI2 and obviously something happened here.
If we ever get some Hg(CN)2 we might try to do it in a different way or even try to make the polymer but by now lets assume it is a cyanide complex of Pd(II). Palladium Chemistry: Tetracyanopalladate(II)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/SGtimbtRnlQ/mqdefault.jpg)



![Mercury Chemistry: Reacting Hg[CrO4] with KCN
When we looked for more information on the thermal decomposition products of Hg2[CrO4] we found a small note in an old book that it would react with KCN to form Hg(CN)2 and Hg. We already showed this reaction in a previous video. So we got the idea to test the same thing with the Hg[CrO4]. When we tried it we did not get the black Hg(0) as no Hg(I) was present. Instead, it turned all yellow. It took us a few seconds to come up with the idea that perhaps the yellow [CrO4](-) ion could be released again once the Hg(CN)2 forms.
To test it we added some dilute H2SO4 in H2O2 to it to form the characteristic blue CrO(O2)2 complex. To be honest we dont know why it did not form for the Hg(I) reaction. It might be because we worked with smaller amounts of Hg2[CrO4], or the mercury masked it somehow. Mercury Chemistry: Reacting Hg[CrO4] with KCN](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/TJQQr09-caY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Thermochromism: Cu2[HgI4]
The explanation is the same as for the Silver compound.
We made this by reacting CuSO4 with the HgI4]2- solution we made in the previous video. In the first step, excess Iodide reacts with the Cu(II) and reduces it to Cu(I). The Cu(I) then precipitates a red Cu2[HgI4] from the solution. If this is heated a brown-black high-temperature modification forms.
We would like to take the rest of the space here and explain the structural differences again. As mentioned before the HT form is a zinc-blende-type. In solid state chemistry for a cubic packing, there are tetrahedral sites and octahedral sites, and there are 2 x more tetrahedral sites than there are ions, which make up the lattice. As explained, the Iodide builds an fcc, so there are 8 tetrahedral sites. If all those are occupied by counter-ions you get a Fluorite-Type (CaF2). The Fluorite can be thinned a bit to yield different structures like PbO, PtS, ... but also ZnS, the zinc-blende. In zinc blende, only half of the tetrahedral voids are filled. This structure is realized in the high-temperature form of M2[HgI4] as well because every tetrahedral void has a chance to be occupied. For an x-ray analysis, this appears to be cubic and zinc-blende-type then.
For the low-temperature form, the Hg(II) and Cu(I) do not mix but build up layers in one direction. The structure becomes tetragonal and you have to add another lattice in this direction to make a double-lattice. So there is a layer with half of the sites filled by Cu(I) followed by a layer with only 1 out of 4 sites filled with an Hg(II) followed by Cu(I) again.
That small structural change causes a minor decrease in the band gap for the high-temperature form.
According to Fukuda, and we love the books from Fukuda on Coordination chemistry, there is also a reaction which looks like this:
Cu(+) I(-) Hg(2+) to Cu(2+) I(-) Hg(+)
And this equilibrium is thermally settled and also changes the color of the compound, as electrons move from the Copper to the Mercury, the absorption becomes redshifted. One could see this as a Metal-to-Metal-charge Transfer, much like in Prussian Blue for example. Thermochromism: Cu2[HgI4]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpNdQWtbkjw/mqdefault.jpg)