Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Join the live call-in show every Tuesday at 5:00 p.m. Central. Challenge the spectrum, correct my amateur psychology, defend belief as a choice, or explain why I have framed the entire question incorrectly.
My prior video on this topic can be found here: youtu.be/YjJXs2Ba0dk
Do you choose what you believe?
It sounds like a simple yes-or-no question. It isn’t—and forcing it into a binary may be why believers and skeptics keep talking past each other.
In this episode of Cynical Sermons, I revisit one of my earlier arguments: that belief is not a choice. I still think the central point was correct. You cannot simply decide that you are standing on Mars, that gravity does not exist, or that something you consider obviously false is suddenly true.
But that answer was incomplete.
Belief is not a single position. It exists on a spectrum, and the role that choice plays depends heavily upon where someone currently stands.
I propose seven levels of belief:
0. Outright Denial
You are certain the proposition is false. For most adults, Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy belong here.
1. True Disbelief
You have rejected the claim, but preserve a small degree of epistemic uncertainty. This is where many atheists stand regarding God.
2. Motivated Skeptic
You lean toward disbelief, but personal desires, experiences, fears, or assumptions may be pushing you in that direction.
3. True Neutrality
You genuinely have not formed a conclusion—either because you know very little about the subject or because the evidence seems evenly balanced.
4. Motivated Seeker
You remain uncertain, but emotional, social, or existential pressures are pulling you toward belief.
5. True Belief
You are deeply convinced and may organize your life around the belief, while still recognizing that it has not become undeniable knowledge.
6. Ontological Knowledge
The proposition is no longer experienced as a belief at all. You simply know it in the same way that you know the sun exists or that the ground is beneath you.
Choice does not operate equally across this scale.
At levels zero and six, there is no switch to flip. At levels one and five, people can change, but usually through a slow internal process—not because someone defeated them in a debate or posted the perfect syllogism. In the middle levels, however, choice can play a genuine role. People can select which questions to pursue, which communities to join, which sources to trust, and whether to lean into or resist a developing belief.
This explains why both sides of the argument seem to have real examples supporting them. Christians often think of people in the middle who gradually chose to commit themselves to faith. Skeptics often think of people at the poles who simply cannot force themselves to believe something that appears obviously false.
Both are describing real experiences. They are simply describing different positions on the spectrum.
We also examine:
• Why Christian theology needs unbelief to be voluntary
• How eternal conscious torment depends upon the language of choice
• Why punishing someone for involuntary disbelief would be monstrous
• The similar role “choice” plays in religious arguments about sexuality
• Biblical passages that portray belief as granted, withheld, or manipulated by God
• The danger of treating humans as passive products of their conditioning
• Whether involuntary beliefs eliminate moral responsibility
• Why certainty performs better online than intellectual honesty
• How believers and atheists reveal their actual confidence through their language
• Why arguments rarely move deeply entrenched people
• Where personal agency genuinely enters the belief-forming process
This framework also creates an even greater problem for the doctrine of hell. The people most frequently condemned for unbelief are the people furthest from belief—the very people with the least ability to simply choose differently.
The less voluntary the supposed crime becomes, the more severe the punishment gets.
That is not justice.
Join the live call-in show every Tuesday at 5:00 p.m. Central. Challenge the spectrum, correct my amateur psychology, defend belief as a choice, or explain why I have framed the entire question incorrectly.
My prior video on this topic can be found here: youtu.be/YjJXs2Ba0dk
Do you choose what you believe?
It sounds like a simple yes-or-no question. It isn’t—and forcing it into a binary may be why believers and skeptics keep talking past each other.
In this episode of Cynical Sermons, I revisit one of my earlier arguments: that belief is not a choice. I still think the central point was correct. You cannot simply decide that you are standing on Mars, that gravity does not exist, or that something you consider obviously false is suddenly true.
But that answer was incomplete.
Belief is not a single position. It exists on a spectrum, and the role that choice plays depends heavily upon where someone currently stands.
I propose seven levels of belief:
0. Outright Denial
You are certain the proposition is false. For most adults, Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy belong here.
1. True Disbelief
You have rejected the claim, but preserve a small degree of epistemic uncertainty. This is where many atheists stand regarding God.
2. Motivated Skeptic
You lean toward disbelief, but personal desires, experiences, fears, or assumptions may be pushing you in that direction.
3. True Neutrality
You genuinely have not formed a conclusion—either because you know very little about the subject or because the evidence seems evenly balanced.
4. Motivated Seeker
You remain uncertain, but emotional, social, or existential pressures are pulling you toward belief.
5. True Belief
You are deeply convinced and may organize your life around the belief, while still recognizing that it has not become undeniable knowledge.
6. Ontological Knowledge
The proposition is no longer experienced as a belief at all. You simply know it in the same way that you know the sun exists or that the ground is beneath you.
Choice does not operate equally across this scale.
At levels zero and six, there is no switch to flip. At levels one and five, people can change, but usually through a slow internal process—not because someone defeated them in a debate or posted the perfect syllogism. In the middle levels, however, choice can play a genuine role. People can select which questions to pursue, which communities to join, which sources to trust, and whether to lean into or resist a developing belief.
This explains why both sides of the argument seem to have real examples supporting them. Christians often think of people in the middle who gradually chose to commit themselves to faith. Skeptics often think of people at the poles who simply cannot force themselves to believe something that appears obviously false.
Both are describing real experiences. They are simply describing different positions on the spectrum.
We also examine:
• Why Christian theology needs unbelief to be voluntary
• How eternal conscious torment depends upon the language of choice
• Why punishing someone for involuntary disbelief would be monstrous
• The similar role “choice” plays in religious arguments about sexuality
• Biblical passages that portray belief as granted, withheld, or manipulated by God
• The danger of treating humans as passive products of their conditioning
• Whether involuntary beliefs eliminate moral responsibility
• Why certainty performs better online than intellectual honesty
• How believers and atheists reveal their actual confidence through their language
• Why arguments rarely move deeply entrenched people
• Where personal agency genuinely enters the belief-forming process
This framework also creates an even greater problem for the doctrine of hell. The people most frequently condemned for unbelief are the people furthest from belief—the very people with the least ability to simply choose differently.
The less voluntary the supposed crime becomes, the more severe the punishment gets.
That is not justice.










