The Witch of Endor Actually Worked?! (1 Samuel 26-28) @Skepticus.Channel
The Witch of Endor Actually Worked?! (1 Samuel 26-28)  @Skepticus.Channel
Uploaded June 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Join the livestream every Tuesday starting at 5PM CST!

šŸ”„ God-Free Bible Study is back, and this week we've got duplicate stories, war crimes, occult necromancy, and a king so desperate for answers that he literally consults a witch.

In this episode we cover:

šŸ“– 1 Samuel 26–28

including:

šŸ‘‰ David spares Saul's life... again
šŸ‘‰ David becomes a Philistine warlord
šŸ‘‰ David lies to his hosts while massacring entire villages
šŸ‘‰ Saul visits the infamous Witch of Endor
šŸ‘‰ Samuel apparently gets dragged back from the dead
šŸ‘‰ and Yahweh continues ghosting Saul at exactly the wrong time

It's a weird one.

Even by First Samuel standards.

šŸ“– Video Description

What up YouTube? It's your boy, Adam of NOLA.

Today we're continuing our journey through First Samuel, covering chapters 26 through 28.

And honestly?

The first thing that jumps out is that it feels like we've already read part of this story.

Because...

we kind of have.

šŸ—”ļø David Spares Saul... Again?

In Chapter 26, Saul once again goes hunting for David.

David once again gains the upper hand.

David once again has an opportunity to kill Saul.

David once again refuses.

David once again proves he could have killed Saul.

And Saul once again apologizes.

If that sounds familiar...

that's because it's remarkably similar to the story we just covered a few chapters ago.

So what's going on here?

Are we watching the same events repeat?

Or are we seeing two versions of the same legend preserved side by side?

šŸ“š The Bible's Duplicate Story Problem

This isn't the first time we've encountered duplicate traditions.

We've already seen:

šŸ‘‰ multiple creation accounts

šŸ‘‰ repeated wilderness narratives

šŸ‘‰ overlapping legal traditions

šŸ‘‰ recurring versions of major events

The Hebrew Bible often preserves competing traditions rather than choosing between them.

That's fascinating from a historical perspective.

But it becomes awkward when people insist every detail must be read as a perfectly harmonized historical narrative.

āš”ļø David the Warlord

Chapter 27 introduces one of the stranger episodes in David's story.

David seeks refuge among the Philistines.

The Philistines.

The people we're constantly told are Israel's enemies.

Then things get ugly.

David launches raids against neighboring populations.

The text explicitly states that he leaves:

šŸ‘‰ neither man nor woman alive

And why?

Because dead people can't report what he actually did.

Then he lies about who he attacked.

This isn't exactly the sanitized Sunday-school version of David.

šŸ‘‘ A Man After God's Own Heart?

One of the recurring themes of First Samuel is the contrast between Saul and David.

But episodes like this raise uncomfortable questions.

Because while Saul often gets portrayed as the villain...

David spends this chapter:

āœ”ļø raiding settlements

āœ”ļø killing entire populations

āœ”ļø deceiving his allies

āœ”ļø covering his tracks

It's not exactly the behavior most people associate with a moral hero.

šŸ§™ The Witch of Endor

Then we arrive at one of the most famous stories in the entire book.

Saul is desperate.

God isn't answering.

The prophets aren't helping.

The dreams have stopped.

The sacred divination tools aren't producing answers.

So what does Saul do?

šŸ‘‰ He consults a medium.

And according to the story...

it works.

šŸ‘» Samuel Returns From the Dead

The medium summons Samuel.

Samuel appears.

Samuel complains about being disturbed.

Samuel predicts Saul's defeat.

And Saul completely falls apart.

This creates a fascinating tension inside the text.

Because throughout the Bible we're repeatedly told that occult practices are forbidden.

Yet this story appears to depict a successful act of necromancy.

Not a fake one.

Not a failed one.

A successful one.

šŸ”„ No Hell Yet

Another detail many modern Christians overlook:

When Samuel appears, he's described as coming up from below.

Not down from heaven.

Not out of paradise.

Up from the underworld.

That's because at this stage of biblical development we're dealing with Sheol, not the later Christian concept of hell.

The eternal torture version of hell that many Christians preach today is nowhere to be found here.

šŸŽÆ Bottom Line

These chapters give us:

šŸ“– duplicate traditions

āš”ļø political intrigue

🩸 brutal warfare

šŸ§™ necromancy

šŸ‘» ghosts

šŸ‘‘ royal paranoia

and plenty of reasons to question the simplistic versions of these stories we often hear in church.

As always, we're reading the text itself and asking what it actually says—not what later theology wishes it said.

šŸ’¬ Do you think 1 Samuel 26 and 24 are duplicate versions of the same story?

And what do you make of the Witch of Endor?

Was Samuel really summoned from the dead?

Drop your thoughts in the comments.

šŸ”„ Join us every Tuesday at 5 PM Central for live call-ins, debates, Bible discussions, and general skepticism.

Believers are especially encouraged to call in.
The Witch of Endor Actually Worked?! (1 Samuel 26-28)#atheism #livestream #catholicism #debate #religion #christianityWhy Wont Christians Stop Lying About The Sermon On The Mount???The Psychology of Rejecting ExpertsLIVE CALL IN: Creationist Fairytales (2026-10-20)The Book of Ruth… Why Is This Even in the Bible?Can You Cook An Atheist? (LIVE! - 2026-05-05)LIVE CALL IN: Exposing More Christian Ignorance (2026-10-27)15 Atheist Slogans Alex O’Connor Says We Should Stop Usingā€œAtheism Can’t Answer This Questionā€ā€¦ Really?YOU DON’T GET TO PICK YOUR MIRACLESThey Reject the Diagnosis Because They Hate the Cure
Skepticus |

The Witch of Endor Actually Worked?! (1 Samuel 26-28)

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER