YOU DON’T GET TO PICK YOUR MIRACLES @Skepticus.Channel
YOU DON’T GET TO PICK YOUR MIRACLES  @Skepticus.Channel
Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Join the live call-in show every Tuesday at 5:00 p.m. Central. If I’ve missed something, misunderstood the apologetic, or if you think there really is a principled way to admit the resurrection while excluding competing supernatural explanations, call in and make the case.

Sheng Tsai (Mindful Living)
youtube.com/@Sheng-Tsai

His original post:
youtube.com/post/UgkxmlTWCmQj2cQo8vcLAMdFpYOKTpOlCztr

If miracles are possible, then which miracles aren’t?

That question creates a serious problem for Christian apologetics.

In this episode of Cynical Sermons, I examine a common defense of the resurrection: skeptics supposedly give miracles an unfairly low probability because we begin by assuming naturalism. If God exists, the argument goes, then raising Jesus from the dead is no longer impossible—and the resurrection can therefore be considered as a genuine historical explanation.

Fine.

Let’s open the supernatural door.

But once that door is open, Christians don’t get to decide that Jesus is the only thing allowed to walk through it.

If supernatural agents can intervene in history, then the resurrection is not suddenly competing only against hallucinations, fraud, legendary development, mistaken identity, or other natural explanations. It is also competing against every conceivable supernatural alternative.

Maybe Satan stole Jesus’s body and engineered false appearances.

Maybe a deceiving spirit altered the disciples’ perceptions.

Maybe another god performed the miracle.

Maybe some unknown supernatural entity staged the entire event for purposes humans cannot understand.

Do I believe any of those things happened?

No.

That’s exactly the point.

They are unsupported supernatural hypotheses—and once supernatural intervention itself becomes an acceptable explanatory category, there is no principled reason to admit the Christian version while dismissing every competing miracle as ridiculous.

Christian apologists frequently want naturalism suspended just long enough to allow their preferred miracle into the conversation. Then they immediately restore ordinary assumptions about reality when evaluating everything else.

Mass hallucinations? Those don’t happen.

Legends developing quickly? Highly unlikely.

People knowingly dying for falsehoods? Human beings don’t behave that way.

Notice what happened: ordinary natural regularities suddenly matter again.

The rules of nature are treated as reliable everywhere except the exact location where the Christian miracle needs them suspended.

That isn’t a consistent epistemology. It’s a hole cut in the fence precisely large enough for one preferred conclusion.

We explore:

• Why allowing miracles does not automatically make the resurrection probable
• The difference between “possible” and “best explanation”
• How Bayesian arguments can smuggle theological assumptions into their priors
• Why supernatural explanations cannot be restricted to Christianity
• The “Satan stole the body” counter-hypothesis
• Demons, spirits, other gods, and mind-altering supernatural agents
• Why Mormon, Hindu, Islamic, and other miracle claims enter through the same door
• The inconsistency of using naturalistic standards against competing religions
• Why “God found me a parking spot” uses the same reasoning as karma, crystals, and horoscopes
• Religious healing claims versus alternative-medicine claims
• Near-death experiences across conflicting religious traditions
• Why feelings of certainty are not reliable truth detectors
• The problem with appealing to the Holy Spirit as independent confirmation
• Why subjective religious experiences reliably confirm mutually incompatible beliefs
• The difference between historical evidence and supernatural conclusions

None of this proves Christianity false.

The narrower argument is that invoking the supernatural to rescue a miracle from an otherwise extremely low probability cannot be contained.

Once you say supernatural intervention is a legitimate explanation, you have opened an explanatory category that includes every competing supernatural claim as well.

You don’t get a supernatural VIP lane reserved for Jesus.

There is, however, another way to argue for Christianity—one that I’m perfectly willing to engage with.

Use manuscripts.

Use archaeology.

Use external attestation.

Use textual criticism.

Use historical methodology.

Compare Christianity with Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Mormonism, and every other competing tradition using standards that all of us can examine together.

Historical evidence might establish that early Christians sincerely believed something extraordinary happened. It might tell us when those beliefs appeared, how they developed, and how well our surviving texts preserve them.

But history cannot simply jump from “people believed something extraordinary happened” to “therefore a supernatural resurrection literally occurred.”
YOU DON’T GET TO PICK YOUR MIRACLESThey Reject the Diagnosis Because They Hate the CureThe Song of Moses Reveals 3 Toxic Truths About Yahweh (Deuteronomy 28-34)How Many Times Do We Have to Debunk Creationism?Pastor Tries to Make Homophobia Sound BeautifulWhen Religious Beliefs Impact Government LawsGod’s Silence Has an Obvious Explanation (They Hate It)Christian Troll Thinks Math Is SubjectiveChristians Can’t Explain This 1 Double Standard on Law and OrderLIVE CALL IN: More Christian Silliness (2026-08-04)Save An Atheist - LIVE! (2026-06-23)Can You Save My Soul?
Skepticus |

YOU DON’T GET TO PICK YOUR MIRACLES

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER