15 Atheist Slogans Alex O’Connor Says We Should Stop Using @Skepticus.Channel
15 Atheist Slogans Alex O’Connor Says We Should Stop Using  @Skepticus.Channel
Uploaded February 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Join this channel to get access to perks:
youtube.com/channel/UCQaz7qLD-NmPF0f5LCDBmkw/join

@CosmicSkeptic
youtube.com/watch?v=BodhtPZxHHg

Breakdowns & Beatdowns is back — and today we’re reacting to a fresh video from Alex O'Connor featuring Joe Schmid titled:

“Atheist slogans you should stop using.”

You know I had to click that. 😏

Usually we hear this kind of list from Christian apologists telling atheists to “retire” certain talking points. But this time it’s coming from two atheist philosophers. So… are they right? Are there actually slogans we should drop?

In this episode, I break down and react to their takes on:

“Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”

“There is no evidence for God”

“Who created God?”

“You just believe in one less god than I do”

“Science flies you to the moon, religion flies you into buildings”

“Claims aren’t evidence”

“You can’t prove a negative”

“Theism is unfalsifiable”

“Evolution disproves God”

And more…

We get into some serious epistemology here — what counts as evidence, what doesn’t, how testimony works, and why rhetorical zingers sometimes collapse under philosophical scrutiny.

But we also go deeper.

I talk about:

Why “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” is still solid — but why it breaks down rhetorically when believers already think they have extraordinary evidence.

Why shouting “there’s no evidence for God” is often pointless when believers see evidence in everything.

Why “who created God?” exposes special pleading — but usually doesn’t faze theists at all.

Why the geography argument about religion is stronger than people realize — and why it’s really about indoctrination, not sand in Saudi Arabia.

Why “science flies you to the moon…” is more of a spicy meme than a serious argument.

Why “claims aren’t evidence” is technically false — but still directionally useful if framed properly.

Why “you can’t prove a negative” is lazy and philosophically embarrassing.

Why evolution doesn’t disprove God — but does create massive problems for certain versions of God.

And why Ricky Gervais’ “burn all the books” thought experiment is not about disproving religion — it’s about distinguishing empirical discovery from storytelling.

We even dip briefly into:

Falsifiability

The unfalsifiable God proposition

Animal suffering and evolutionary brutality

Divine revelation vs cultural inheritance

And the weirdest metaphysical detour I’ve heard in a while: “hyper-time.” (Yes. Really.)

This isn’t a dunk session. I respect Alex and Joe. They bring rigor that’s often missing in internet atheism. But I also think they miss the mark in a few places — especially where real-world psychology and religious ethnocentrism come into play.

If you’re an atheist who wants sharper arguments, or a believer who wants to understand how skeptics actually think, this one’s worth your time.

As always — huge thanks to my channel members. You guys keep this ship afloat and help shape where Skepticus goes next.

Until next time…

Lo, I say unto you: stay skeptical.
15 Atheist Slogans Alex O’Connor Says We Should Stop Using“Atheism Can’t Answer This Question”… Really?YOU DON’T GET TO PICK YOUR MIRACLESThey Reject the Diagnosis Because They Hate the CureThe Song of Moses Reveals 3 Toxic Truths About Yahweh (Deuteronomy 28-34)How Many Times Do We Have to Debunk Creationism?Pastor Tries to Make Homophobia Sound BeautifulWhen Religious Beliefs Impact Government LawsGod’s Silence Has an Obvious Explanation (They Hate It)Christian Troll Thinks Math Is SubjectiveChristians Can’t Explain This 1 Double Standard on Law and OrderLIVE CALL IN: More Christian Silliness (2026-08-04)
Skepticus |

15 Atheist Slogans Alex O’Connor Says We Should Stop Using

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER