Skepticus
Belief Is Not A Choice - The Morally Bankrupt Bargain Of Faith
updated
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Welcome back to *Breakdowns & Beatdowns* on Skepticus, where we examine Christian apologetics, questionable arguments, and the uncomfortable facts that apologists would rather you overlook.
In this episode, I'm reacting to biblical scholar *Dan McClellan's latest response to Wes Huff's plagiarism controversy*—and adding my own thoughts about why Huff's explanations raise more questions than they answer.
After previously examining Huff's response to the allegations and Christian apologist Mike Winger's surprisingly critical commentary, we're turning to McClellan's detailed explanation of why he made the accusations public, why he questions Huff's credibility, and why this controversy goes far beyond a few missing citations.
*Here's what we're digging into:*
- *Questioning the Accuser:* Why does Wes Huff want to discuss Dan McClellan's motivations instead of concentrating on the evidence of plagiarism?
- *The Art of "Dirty Deleting":* McClellan describes a history of Huff removing content rather than publicly acknowledging errors. Is deleting videos, website content, and social media posts really the way to handle an academic controversy?
- *The Stolen Infographics:* McClellan highlights allegations that Huff took other organizations' intellectual property, made minor cosmetic changes, added his own watermark, and removed comments identifying the original creators.
- *The "Rough Draft" Excuse:* Huff argues that the papers uploaded to Academia.edu were unfinished drafts. But why were they publicly accessible as polished PDFs, complete with bibliographies, course information, and other indications of finished academic work?
- *Publishing Is Publishing:* Why posting a paper publicly on Academia.edu still constitutes self-publication, even when the work hasn't appeared in a peer-reviewed journal.
- *More Than Missing Citations:* McClellan argues that substantial portions of Huff's academic work were derived from other scholars, including Brian J. Wright. If the central arguments, evidence, and bibliography come from someone else's research, can the problem really be dismissed as sloppy attribution?
- *A Formal University Complaint:* McClellan reveals that he submitted a formal complaint to Huff's academic institution. Could this controversy have consequences beyond YouTube?
- *The Academic Credibility Problem:* What happens when someone builds a public apologetics career around scholarly credentials, only to face serious questions about the academic work behind those credentials?
One of the most important points in this entire controversy is that *the motives of the person exposing plagiarism do not determine whether plagiarism occurred.* You can dislike Dan McClellan, disagree with his theological perspectives, or question his intentions. None of that makes the evidence disappear.
And the question of whether Huff's papers were submitted for academic credit is separate from whether he publicly presented other people's work as his own.
But perhaps the most devastating moment comes near the end of McClellan's response, when he suggests that if Huff ever wants to be taken seriously as a biblical scholar, he may need to return to square one and pursue academic scholarship the right way.
That's an extraordinary assessment from someone who actually works in the field.
*This isn't simply about Christian apologetics versus atheism. It's about intellectual honesty, academic integrity, accountability, and the responsibility that comes with presenting yourself as an expert.*
Watch the video, examine the evidence, and decide for yourself whether Wes Huff's explanations hold up.
*What do YOU think?* Is this simply a case of sloppy academic work from years ago, or does it reveal a much more serious problem with Huff's scholarly credibility? And should someone who publicly presents himself as an academic be held to a higher standard?
Let me know in the comments!
---
📺 *Join Skepticus LIVE every Tuesday at 5:00 PM Central!*
Our weekly call-in show is open to everyone—atheists, Christians, skeptics, apologists, and anyone willing to have an honest conversation. Bring your arguments, objections, and questions!
*Related videos and resources:*
Dan McClellan's follow-up response: youtube.com/watch?v=klYRIRuA2ZU
My original reaction to Wes Huff's response: youtube.com/watch?v=FqDEYd5rYjc
My reaction to Mike Winger's commentary: youtube.com/watch?v=dJ38mIUIfvY
Sheng Tsai / Mindful Living's analysis: youtube.com/watch?v=widEwLAYB00
The Wes Huff plagiarism controversy continues to unfold, and this time we're hearing from someone who isn't an atheist, a skeptic, or a critic of Christianity. We're hearing from *Mike Winger*, a prominent Christian apologist who openly acknowledges his friendship with Wes Huff—and who is now publicly questioning Huff's honesty, transparency, and handling of the plagiarism allegations.
Welcome back to *Breakdowns & Beatdowns* on Skepticus, where we examine Christian apologetics, questionable arguments, and the uncomfortable facts that apologists would rather you overlook.
In this episode, I'm reacting to Mike Winger's surprisingly candid response to the growing Wes Huff controversy. While many Christian content creators have rushed to defend Huff, dismiss the accusations, or attack biblical scholar Dan McClellan for exposing the problems, Winger is taking a very different approach.
He's acknowledging that the allegations are serious, that Huff's initial response was misleading, and that Christians who blindly defend their favorite apologists without examining the evidence are damaging their own credibility.
And here's the surprising part: *I actually agree with Mike Winger on quite a few things.*
We're digging into:
- *Mike Winger Breaks Ranks:* Why a prominent Christian apologist publicly warned fellow believers to stop defending Wes Huff before examining the evidence.
- *A Friend Admits There's a Problem:* Winger's acknowledgment that the plagiarism concerns are substantial—and that Huff's initial explanation wasn't accurate.
- *Dan McClellan Gets Vindicated:* How the biblical scholar who exposed the plagiarism allegations earned a reluctant acknowledgment from one of his theological critics.
- *The Christian Apologetics Echo Chamber:* Why so many believers seem more concerned with protecting their favorite apologist than discovering what's actually true.
- *Plagiarism Isn't Just a Missing Citation:* Why academic plagiarism is a serious violation of scholarly integrity, not the minor technicality some defenders want to portray.
- *Accountability to Whom?* Why oversight from church elders and apologetics organizations may not be sufficient when the allegations concern academic scholarship.
- *Forgiveness Without Repentance?* Why Christians invoking grace and forgiveness should first ask whether Wes Huff has publicly acknowledged the extent of his wrongdoing.
- *When Tribal Loyalty Replaces Truth:* How defending someone simply because they're on your theological team can undermine the very beliefs you're trying to protect.
- *Credit Where Credit Is Due:* Why I'm willing to acknowledge Mike Winger's integrity in this controversy despite our substantial disagreements about Christianity.
After spending roughly 40 years as a Christian, I've seen firsthand how religious communities sometimes rally around questionable claims simply because those claims appear to support their faith.
But defending bad evidence doesn't strengthen your position. It weakens it.
And defending academic misconduct because the person accused happens to share your religion doesn't demonstrate Christian morality. It demonstrates tribal loyalty.
*Here's my central question: If truth matters as much as Christian apologists claim it does, why is it so difficult for some of them to acknowledge wrongdoing within their own ranks?*
To Mike Winger's credit, he appears willing to confront that uncomfortable question—even when doing so puts him at odds with fellow Christians and someone he considers a friend.
That doesn't mean I agree with his theology. It doesn't mean I'm suddenly a fan of Christian apologetics. But it does mean I can recognize integrity when I see it.
Because ultimately, *you don't have to agree with someone's religious beliefs to appreciate their commitment to honesty.*
Watch the breakdown, examine the evidence, and decide for yourself.
*What do you think?* Is Mike Winger demonstrating the kind of accountability Christians should expect from their leaders? Has Wes Huff adequately addressed the allegations? And should forgiveness come before a full acknowledgment of wrongdoing?
Let me know in the comments.
Subscribe to *Skepticus* for more Breakdowns & Beatdowns, Cynical Sermons, God-Free Bible Study, and skeptical examinations of religious claims.
*Referenced videos:*
Mike Winger's response: youtube.com/watch?v=_oDotgbGbF0
Dan McClellan's plagiarism analysis: youtube.com/watch?v=klYRIRuA2ZU
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
That's not taking responsibility. That's damage control.
Welcome back to Breakdowns & Beatdowns on Skepticus, where we examine Christian apologetics, questionable arguments, and the uncomfortable facts that apologists would rather you overlook.
In this episode, I'm breaking down Christian apologist Wes Huff's video "Addressing the Accusations," his response to biblical scholar Dan McClellan, who recently highlighted allegations of plagiarism involving academic work Huff uploaded to Academia.edu in 2016.
Rather than simply acknowledging the problem and moving forward, Huff spends much of his response emphasizing how young he was, how poorly written his old papers were, how the documents were merely drafts, and how Academia.edu isn't a peer-reviewed journal.
But here's the question: What does any of that have to do with whether plagiarism occurred?
We're digging into:
- The "I Was Young" Defense: Why being 24 years old a decade ago doesn't automatically excuse failures of academic integrity.
- Bad Writing vs. Plagiarism: Why sloppy scholarship and using someone else's work without proper attribution are two very different problems.
- The "It Was Just a Draft" Excuse: Does plagiarism somehow stop being plagiarism when a document hasn't been formally published?
- The Academia.edu Defense: Why uploading questionable work to a public academic platform still raises legitimate concerns.
- Brian J. Wright's Forgiveness: Why the original author's gracious response doesn't necessarily resolve the larger issue of academic responsibility.
- Questioning Dan McClellan's Motives: Why attacking the motivations of the person exposing a problem doesn't answer the underlying allegations.
- The Non-Apology Apology: How Huff repeatedly claims to take ownership while offering explanations that appear designed to minimize accountability.
- A Broader Pattern? Additional allegations highlighted by skeptical creator Sheng Tsai and what they might mean for Huff's academic credibility.
This isn't about whether Wes Huff should be "canceled." It's about whether someone who builds a public reputation around biblical scholarship should be held accountable to the basic standards of academic integrity.
And more importantly, what does it say about Christian apologetics when defending the apologist seems more important than addressing the evidence?
Watch the breakdown and decide for yourself.
REFERENCED VIDEOS & SOURCES
Dan McClellan's original analysis: youtube.com/watch?v=bbxN1NXmGtI
Wes Huff — "Addressing the Accusations": *SINCE I RECORDED THIS VIDEO, WES HAS REMOVED HIS ORIGINAL FAUX APOLOGY VIDEO*
Sheng Tsai's additional posts:
youtube.com/post/UgkxfrqyvZaF-RPJGYFuqnfilbJY9Ap9ja-V?si=IV_rULVQmzOOAcma
youtube.com/post/Ugkx0YxdJXRgluVekcPruSPPgit_hHUMZBH0?si=ypgKKV4BD3mYeEXI
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Think I'm being unfair to Wes Huff? Think his explanation actually addresses the allegations? Come tell me why!
Join the Skepticus live call-in show every Tuesday at 5:00 PM Central, where believers and skeptics are welcome to challenge arguments and defend their positions.
Subscribe to Skepticus for more Breakdowns & Beatdowns, Cynical Sermons, God-Free Bible Study, and unapologetically skeptical examinations of Christianity.
Until next time, stay skeptical.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Welcome back to **God-Free Bible Study**, where we read the Bible without apologetic gymnastics, divine excuses, or rose-colored glasses.
We've officially finished **2 Samuel**, marking our **10th completed book of the Bible!** And as has become tradition, we're celebrating with a recap of some of the most troubling, absurd, contradictory, and downright embarrassing things we discovered along the way.
In this episode, I'm walking through **23 uncomfortable facts about 2 Samuel** that raise some serious questions about biblical morality, historical reliability, and the supposedly perfect justice of Yahweh.
**Among the highlights:**
- **How Did Saul Die?** The Bible gives us two different accounts, and they don't agree.
- **David and Jonathan:** Why does David say Jonathan's love surpassed the love of women?
- **God's Deadly Magic Box:** Uzzah touches the Ark of the Covenant and Yahweh immediately kills him.
- **David's Horrific Punishments:** David commits adultery and orchestrates a murder. God responds by killing an innocent baby and declaring that David's concubines will be publicly violated.
- **A Family of Monsters:** Amnon assaults his half-sister Tamar, Absalom rebels against his father, and David repeatedly refuses to hold his sons accountable.
- **Seven Executions to End a Famine:** God punishes Israel for something the long-dead King Saul did, and apparently seven executions are enough to make him happy again.
- **Who REALLY Killed Goliath?** Was it David, as 1 Samuel claims, or Elhanan, as 2 Samuel tells us?
- **David's Mighty Men:** Legendary warriors, impossibly convenient combat scenes, and a man celebrated for killing a lion trapped in a pit.
- **God Commands a Census—Then Punishes It:** Yahweh orders David to count the people, condemns him for doing it, and subsequently kills 70,000 Israelites.
And that's not even all 23.
Throughout this series, we've examined these stories in their biblical context, read the actual passages, and considered the explanations offered by Christian apologists. But when you step away from the assumption that the Bible *must* be true, *must* be consistent, and *must* portray a perfectly just God, the problems become extraordinarily difficult to ignore.
**The question isn't whether Christians can invent explanations for these stories. The question is whether those explanations are actually convincing.**
If you want to examine the source material for yourself, check out the complete **God-Free Bible Study** playlist, where we've already worked through every chapter of 2 Samuel.
And if you think I've gotten something wrong, come tell me!
**Join my livestream every Tuesday at 5:00 PM Central**, where you're welcome to challenge my arguments, ask questions, or simply hang out with the community.
If you enjoy skeptical Bible study, biblical criticism, religious deconstruction, and examining Christianity without the usual theological special pleading, subscribe to **Skepticus** and join the conversation.
**Stay skeptical.**
After spending 40 years as a Christian, I finally started asking questions I'd never seriously considered while I was a believer. Why did God need to sacrifice his own son to forgive humanity? How can Jesus be fully God and fully human? Why did an omnipotent deity wait thousands of years to provide salvation—and then leave it to a handful of ordinary people to spread the word?
The more I examined the theology surrounding Jesus, the more absurd it became.
In this episode of **Cynical Sermons**, I'm laying out **32 reasons why I believe the Christian conception of Jesus simply doesn't make sense.** Not because I hate Jesus. Not because I'm trying to offend Christians. But because the logic, morality, and historical claims surrounding Christianity's central figure fall apart under scrutiny.
We're digging into:
- **The Hypostatic Union:** Can Jesus logically be fully God and fully man?
- **The Trinity:** Three persons, one God, and a theological explanation that seems to create more problems than it solves.
- **The Virgin Birth:** Isaiah 7:14, the Septuagint, and the origins of Jesus's famous birth narrative.
- **Failed Prophecies:** Did Jesus actually fulfill the Hebrew scriptures—or even his own predictions?
- **The Problem of Human Sacrifice:** Why would a loving God require an innocent person to be executed?
- **Forgiveness vs. Atonement:** Why couldn't an omnipotent God simply forgive humanity?
- **The Great Commission:** Why entrust the most important message in human history to an incredibly inefficient human communication network?
- **The Resurrection:** What evidence actually supports Christianity's defining miracle?
- **The Teachings of Jesus:** Slavery, thought crimes, eternal punishment, family loyalty, and the disturbing implications of certain Gospel passages.
- **The Missing Years:** Why do we know virtually nothing about the first 30 years of God's supposed incarnation?
- **The Jesus Mythos:** How much of the story is genuinely unique among ancient religious traditions?
And that's just part of the list.
Here's the thing: I'm not arguing that every teaching attributed to Jesus is terrible. Some of them offer genuinely valuable moral lessons. But **good advice from an ancient preacher is a very different thing from evidence that the preacher was the omnipotent creator of the universe.**
When I finally separated myself from Christianity, I began recognizing contradictions and moral problems that had been hiding in plain sight for decades.
This video is about those realizations.
**Christians, I genuinely want to hear your answers.** If you think I've misunderstood Jesus, the Trinity, salvation, or the crucifixion, tell me where my reasoning goes wrong.
And if you're a skeptic, atheist, agnostic, or questioning believer, let me know which of these 32 arguments you find most compelling.
🔥 JOIN THE LIVE DISCUSSION!
I livestream every Tuesday at **5:00 PM Central** on Skepticus. It's a call-in show, and believers and nonbelievers alike are welcome to challenge arguments, ask questions, and join the conversation.
👍 Like the video if you enjoy unapologetic religious criticism.
💬 Comment with your strongest argument for—or against—the divinity of Jesus.
🔔 Subscribe to Skepticus for more biblical criticism, skeptical analysis, and conversations about religion without the apologetic gymnastics.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
In this episode of Breakdowns & Beatdowns, I react to a video from ETC Apologetics defending Paul’s famous claim in 1 Corinthians 15 that Jesus appeared to more than 500 people after the resurrection.
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=WQNpg5pkOcQ
The apologetic argument is familiar: first-century society was largely oral, literacy rates were low, writing was expensive, ancient documents rarely survived, Christian writings were sometimes deliberately destroyed, and Paul supposedly gave his readers an opportunity to verify the witnesses for themselves.
But none of that answers the central problem:
Where are the 500 eyewitness testimonies?
Paul claiming that hundreds of other people witnessed an event does not magically give us hundreds of independent witnesses. It gives us Paul’s claim about hundreds of witnesses.
That distinction matters.
If I tell you I saw Sasquatch—and then tell you 500 other people saw him too—you don’t suddenly have 501 eyewitness testimonies. You still have mine unless those other witnesses can actually be identified, questioned, or independently attested.
We dig into:
• Paul’s “500 witnesses” claim in 1 Corinthians 15
• Oral tradition and exaggerated claims about ancient memory
• Low literacy rates in the first century
• Why “they probably didn’t write it down” doesn’t create evidence
• The destruction and loss of ancient documents
• Whether Paul’s claim was realistically verifiable
• Hearsay versus independent eyewitness testimony
• The claim that Paul had “no motive to lie”
• The early-creed argument associated with 1 Corinthians 15
• Why the absence of these testimonies does NOT disprove Christianity—but does limit what evidence Christians can legitimately claim to possess
The point isn’t that the missing 500 witnesses somehow disproves the resurrection.
The point is much simpler:
You don’t get to count testimony you don’t actually have.
If one person says 500 other people saw something, you have one documented claim—not 500 independent eyewitness accounts.
Welcome back to God-Free Bible Study, where we read the Bible without the apologetic gymnastics, divine excuses, or rose-colored glasses.
In this episode, we're finishing 2 Samuel chapters 22–24, and the book saves one of its most outrageous stories for last.
First, David sings an elaborate song praising God for rewarding his righteousness, apparently forgetting about the murders, betrayals, and other questionable behavior we've spent the entire book reading about.
Then we meet David's legendary mighty men: warriors who supposedly kill hundreds of enemies single-handedly, a man defending a field of lentils, and three soldiers who risk their lives to retrieve water from Bethlehem—only for David to pour it on the ground.
But the real spectacle comes in chapter 24.
God becomes angry with Israel for reasons the text never explains. He incites David to conduct a census, and David does exactly that. Then David is informed that he has committed a terrible sin.
His punishment? A choice between famine, military defeat, or pestilence. David leaves himself in God's hands, and 70,000 people die.
How is obeying God's command a sin? Why are ordinary Israelites punished for it? And how does any of this demonstrate perfect divine justice?
In this episode, we explore:
2 Samuel 22: David's self-congratulatory song of righteousness
2 Samuel 23: David's last words and the treatment of the "godless"
David's mighty warriors and their spectacularly improbable exploits
Three men risking their lives for water David refuses to drink
The strange literary arrangement of David's supposed final words
2 Samuel 24: God commanding David to conduct a census
David being punished for following God's instructions
The deaths of 70,000 Israelites
The moral problem of collective punishment
God's anger, mercy, and the apparent absence of proportional justice
After 24 chapters of political intrigue, bloodshed, betrayal, divine favoritism, and extraordinary brutality, we're finally finished with 2 Samuel.
And what a way to end.
Next up: our complete review of 2 Samuel, followed by 1 Kings.
If you enjoy skeptical Bible study, biblical criticism, religious deconstruction, and examining what the Bible actually says rather than what apologists claim it says, subscribe to Skepticus.
Join our live conversations every Tuesday at 5 PM Central, and consider becoming a channel member to support the show and help shape future content.
Stay skeptical.
We are breaking down 2 Samuel 22-24 to see what David's final chapters reveal about biblical history and kingly mythology.
In this episode, we examine the transition from David's song of thanksgiving to the controversial census that brings divine punishment upon Israel. While traditional Sunday school lessons often frame David as a flawless ruler, these final chapters offer a much more complicated look at his reign, his mighty men, and the shifting power dynamics within the kingdom.
We analyze the text without the usual apologetic spin, focusing on the historical context and the narrative choices made by the authors. Whether it is the logic behind the census or the celebration of David's warriors, we look at how these stories construct the legacy of Israel's most famous monarch. This is a critical look at the biblical narrative for anyone interested in the reality behind the religious legend.
Join me for our live call-in streams every Tuesday at 5:00 PM Central. Disagree with something I've said? Come tell me why!
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
In this episode of Breakdowns & Beatdowns, I react to a video from Dr. Joel Duff, a Christian scientist and longtime critic of young-earth creationism, who has reached a point of genuine frustration with the misinformation coming from organizations like the Institute for Creation Research.
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=jNiF9DABHD0
The immediate issue involves dinosaurs.
An ICR geologist attempts to explain why we don’t find evidence of dinosaurs living alongside humans after Noah’s Flood—and casually suggests that animals dying after the Flood simply wouldn’t become fossils.
There are some problems with that.
But what interested me even more than the fossilization claim was Joel Duff’s reaction to it.
How many times can you correct the same errors?
How many times can you respond when organizations with enormous audiences repeat claims that have already been addressed again and again?
And does any of it actually accomplish anything?
We dig into:
• Young-earth creationism and the Institute for Creation Research
• Dinosaurs supposedly surviving Noah’s Flood
• Why fossilization does not require a global catastrophe
• Creationist claims that contradict other creationist claims
• The responsibility that comes with presenting yourself as a scientific authority
• Why intelligent and highly educated people can still defend demonstrably bad ideas
• Brandolini’s Law and the exhausting asymmetry of debunking misinformation
• Why reaction videos can feel like yelling into the void
• Whether repeatedly correcting creationist misinformation actually matters
• Why the real audience for debunking may not be the people making the claims
• How skeptical content can reach people who are questioning what they were taught
Dr. Duff and I disagree on one fairly significant subject: he’s a Christian and I’m an atheist.
But that’s part of what makes this conversation interesting.
You don’t have to agree about God, Jesus, miracles, or theology to agree that scientific claims should be supported by evidence—and that people presenting themselves as experts have a responsibility to get the facts right.
Creationist organizations probably aren’t going to watch a debunking video and suddenly retract decades of claims.
That isn’t necessarily the point.
Someone else is watching.
And sometimes putting accurate information into the world—even when it feels repetitive, frustrating, and completely Sisyphean—is reason enough to keep going.
**Didn't David already kill Goliath?**
Welcome back to **God-Free Bible Study**, where we read the Bible without the apologetic gymnastics, divine excuses, or rose-colored glasses.
In this episode, we're tackling **2 Samuel chapters 19–21**, and the story of King David is getting increasingly bizarre.
After Absalom's failed rebellion, David returns to power—but his kingdom is anything but united. His loyal commander Joab gets replaced by a former enemy, another rebellion erupts almost immediately, and the political maneuvering gets downright murderous.
Then things get considerably worse.
According to the biblical narrative, God inflicts a three-year famine on Israel because of something the already-dead King Saul did to the Gibeonites. The proposed solution? Hand over seven of Saul's descendants to be impaled.
And after the executions and burials, God finally responds to the people's prayers.
**This is supposed to be divine justice?**
And just when you think we've reached peak biblical absurdity, we discover that 2 Samuel credits someone named Elhanan with killing Goliath.
Yes, THAT Goliath. The one David supposedly killed with a slingshot back in 1 Samuel.
**In this episode:**
- David mourns Absalom while Joab calls him out.
- The political rivalry between Judah and Israel.
- David replaces his loyal commander with the former rebel commander Amasa.
- Shimei, Mephibosheth, and David's carefully cultivated reputation for mercy.
- Another rebellion breaks out under Sheba.
- David confines his ten concubines for the rest of their lives after their sexual abuse during Absalom's rebellion.
- Joab brutally murders Amasa and reclaims command.
- A wise woman saves her city by arranging to have a rebel's head thrown over the wall.
- God supposedly punishes an entire population with famine for Saul's actions.
- Seven of Saul's descendants are executed to settle the Gibeonites' grievance.
- Rizpah guards the bodies of the dead.
- **2 Samuel 21:19 vs. 1 Samuel 17: Who actually killed Goliath?**
- Biblical giants, legendary heroes, and the building of David's mythology.
Throughout these chapters, we'll examine how biblical storytelling transforms complicated, often horrifying political events into the legend of Israel's greatest king—and how frequently the supposedly perfect morality of Yahweh looks anything but perfect.
Was David really the heroic, divinely favored king of Sunday school lessons? Is this history, political propaganda, mythology, or some combination of all three?
Grab your Bible, pour yourself something enjoyable, and let's find out.
**Become a Skepticus member!** Members get early access to selected content and opportunities to help shape the direction of the channel.
And join me for our live call-in streams every **Tuesday at 5:00 PM Central**. Disagree with something I've said? Come tell me why!
As always, stay skeptical.
#GodFreeBibleStudy #Skepticus #BibleStudy #2Samuel #BibleContradictions #Atheism #BiblicalCriticism
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
In this episode of Breakdowns & Beatdowns, I react to a video from Jesus and Whatnot claiming to offer an argument powerful enough to “convince your friends that God is real.”
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=u4Il4x1fUcA
The argument starts with act and potency, moves through causal chains and motion, invokes Thomas Aquinas and the unmoved mover, and eventually arrives at a being that is supposedly all-knowing, all-powerful, all-good, and all-loving.
But there’s a problem.
Even if we grant that things exist in causal relationships, why should we assume reality itself must behave like a train, a chandelier, or a chain with a first link? Why assume time and causation operate as a simple linear progression all the way down to the foundations of spacetime?
And even if we somehow establish a “first cause,” how exactly do we get from that to the God of classical theism?
We dig into:
• Act and potency
• Aquinas’ unmoved mover
• Causal chains and infinite regress
• Whether every chain actually needs a first member
• The problem with treating spacetime like ordinary Newtonian time
• Whether this argument is really another version of God of the gaps
• The leap from “first cause” to omniscience, omnipotence, goodness, and love
• The uncomfortable implications of claiming God possesses every “valuable” attribute without limit
• Why a reasonable philosophical argument is very different from a proof
I’ve said many times that belief in God is not inherently irrational, and neither is discussing arguments like Aquinas’ Five Ways.
What I reject is the enormous leap from “here is one philosophical model of causation” to “therefore God definitively exists.”
Sometimes the most intellectually responsible answer to the deepest questions about existence, causation, time, and the universe is simply:
We don’t know yet.
And “we don’t know” does not mean “therefore, God.”
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Again.
In this episode of Breakdowns & Beatdowns, I react to a video from Truth B Told breathlessly promoting the latest investigation of the famous boat-shaped formation near Mount Ararat in Turkey—a site that has been connected to Noah’s Ark claims for decades.
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=-E4RYMg-x2o
This time, researchers have begun core drilling, and the hype machine is already in overdrive. We’re told this could rewrite university textbooks, overturn what we know about human history, and even “dismantle Darwinism.”
There’s just one problem:
None of that has actually happened.
The site isn’t a newly discovered ark. It’s a long-known geological formation that has been investigated repeatedly, and the current drilling has not magically produced evidence of an ancient wooden vessel.
We dig into:
• The recycled claims surrounding the alleged Noah’s Ark site
• Ron Wyatt and the long history of Ark “discoveries”
• Why a boat-shaped geological formation isn’t automatically a boat
• The claim that finding the Ark would somehow disprove evolution
• Why “Darwinism has already been debunked” is a spectacular misunderstanding of modern biology
• Lauren Witzky, the expedition’s marketing and fundraising operation, and the credibility questions surrounding the project
• Why extraordinary archaeological claims need actual evidence—not press releases
• Flood myths in Genesis, Gilgamesh, Atrahasis, and the ancient Near East
• The problems with treating shared flood mythology as proof of a global flood
• The Nephilim, the “sons of God,” and just how ambiguous Genesis 6 actually is
• Why creationist models quietly require incredibly rapid evolutionary diversification after the Flood
• And why recycled pseudo-scientific claims like this matter far beyond one Christian YouTube video
I don’t have a problem with researchers drilling at the site. Investigate it. Take samples. Collect the data. Publish the results.
If credible evidence appears, follow the evidence.
But “we’re going to investigate” is not the same thing as “we found Noah’s Ark.”
And it definitely isn’t the same thing as dismantling evolutionary biology.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Joe Schmid is back—this time with Matt Fradd of Pints With Aquinas—to answer seven arguments for atheism.
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=rJDW7MiC57s
And apparently the answer to almost all of them is: *maybe.*
Maybe suffering creates greater goods. Maybe divine hiddenness gives Christians the opportunity to evangelize. Maybe religious diversity serves some larger purpose. Maybe animals participate in the eschaton. Maybe God exists outside of time in exactly the way necessary to preserve human freedom.
In this episode of *Breakdowns & Beatdowns*, I react to Joe’s responses to the problem of evil, divine hiddenness, religious diversity, the alleged incoherence of God’s attributes, Occam’s Razor, fine-tuning, the apparent indifference of the universe, and more.
What fascinates me isn't simply that Joe is now Catholic. It’s how dramatically his standards of reasoning appear to have changed. The same skeptical thinker who once examined theological claims with extraordinary care now repeatedly seems willing to construct speculative possibilities, invoke Catholic miracle claims, and treat those possibilities as sufficient answers to some of the hardest objections to theism.
We’ll talk about:
• The problem of evil and animal suffering
• “God’s ways are higher” as an explanation
• Divine hiddenness
• Religious diversity and geography
• Fine-tuning and the anthropic principle
• Miracles, Fatima, Guadalupe, Padre Pio, and Eucharistic miracles
• Omnipotence, timelessness, foreknowledge, and free will
• Occam’s Razor and the “argument from stuff”
• Whether apologetics has become an exercise in making the story fit the conclusion
Joe is obviously an intelligent guy. That’s precisely why I find these arguments so fascinating—and so frustrating.
Watch the original conversation for yourself, hear Joe’s arguments in context, and decide whether these responses actually answer the objections…or merely demonstrate how much you can explain once **“maybe God has a reason”** becomes an acceptable answer.
And remember: **stay skeptical.**
#Atheism #Christianity #Catholicism #JoeSchmid #PintsWithAquinas #Apologetics #Skepticus #ProblemOfEvil #DivineHiddenness #Religion
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
A conversation about the Trinity somehow turns into one of the most disturbing defenses of biblical morality I’ve heard on a livestream.
In this episode of Livestream Lowlights, I talk with a Christian caller named Scott about biblical contradictions, justice, consequences, and whether God’s actions can ever actually be condemned as immoral.
The discussion eventually lands on 2 Samuel 12, where Nathan tells David that, as punishment for David’s adultery with Bathsheba and the killing of Uriah, God will take David’s wives and give them to another man who will have sex with them publicly.
So I ask a pretty simple question:
Is it just to punish innocent women for the crimes of their husband?
At first, Scott insists that what happens to David’s wives is merely a “consequence,” not justice. But as the conversation continues, that distinction becomes increasingly difficult to maintain. Eventually, he acknowledges that their treatment was the punishment God sent against David—and still insists that God remains the hero of the story.
From there, things somehow get even stranger.
I ask whether there is anything the Bible could depict God doing that would cause him to stop calling God the hero.
His answer speaks for itself.
This is what happens when morality becomes subordinate to divine authority: instead of judging God’s actions by a moral standard, the standard becomes whatever God happens to do.
And once you make that move, what exactly is left of morality?
Welcome to Livestream Lowlights.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
What happens when “God can do whatever he wants” becomes your entire moral system?
In this episode of Livestream Lowlights, a Christian caller and I get into a long discussion about some of the Bible’s most disturbing stories—and eventually arrive at a remarkably simple question:
If God commands an atrocity, does that make the atrocity moral?
We start with the slaughter of the Amalekites, where Saul is commanded to wipe out men, women, children, infants, and animals. From there, we move to the story of David and Bathsheba—and the punishment supposedly imposed for David’s actions: the death of his infant son and the public sexual violation of his concubines.
The caller repeatedly admits that these things would be horrifying if humans did them.
But if God did them?
Then, apparently, they were justified.
And that creates a much bigger problem.
If your moral system says anything becomes good the moment you believe God commanded it, then morality no longer protects you from atrocities. The only remaining question is whether you can convince yourself that God gave the order.
That is precisely the problem with divine command theory.
We also get into Jesus and the Trinity, whether Christians can separate Jesus from Yahweh’s actions in the Hebrew Bible, how believers decide which alleged commands actually come from God, and why “I would know the difference” isn’t nearly as reassuring as someone might think.
Sometimes the best critique of a worldview is simply asking someone to follow it all the way to the end.
Welcome to Livestream Lowlights.
youtube.com/@TavoSanAbri
Call in here:
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Christians love three words when an uncomfortable Bible verse comes up:
“Out of context.”
But what does context actually mean—and does it really rescue the passages Christian apologists claim it does?
In this episode of Cynical Sermons, I take apart one of the most overused defenses in Christian apologetics: the idea that skeptics only find problems in the Bible because we aren't reading it with enough historical, cultural, theological, linguistic, or literary “context.”
Real context matters. But simply shouting the word doesn't constitute an argument.
We look at what genuine textual context requires, why knowing Hebrew or Greek isn't necessary for basic comprehension of an English Bible, and why reading later New Testament theology back into much older Hebrew texts isn't the same thing as interpreting those texts in their original context.
Then we get to the irony:
Christianity itself may be responsible for some of the most spectacular examples of taking scripture out of context.
The centerpiece is Isaiah 7:14, the famous passage Christians associate with the virgin birth of Jesus. Read Isaiah 7 on its own terms, however, and the passage is addressing King Ahaz during an immediate eighth-century BCE political and military crisis. The sign concerns events expected to unfold within the childhood of a child born in that setting—not seven centuries later.
We also examine:
• What “context” actually means
• Why “you need the original Hebrew” is often applied selectively
• The difference between textual context and later theological interpretation
• Why different biblical genres require different amounts of surrounding material
• Isaiah 7:14 and the Hebrew word almah
• Matthew's use of the Greek Septuagint
• Hosea 11:1 and “Out of Egypt I called my son”
• Psalm 22 and Christian crucifixion interpretations
• Why fulfilled-prophecy arguments frequently depend on removing passages from their original settings
If you're going to accuse someone of taking scripture out of context, there's one question you should be prepared to answer:
What is the missing context, specifically—and how does it change the meaning of the passage?
If you can't answer that, “context” isn't an argument.
It's a magic word.
Welcome to another episode of Cynical Sermons.
Stay skeptical.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Sheng Tsai (Mindful Living)
youtube.com/@Sheng-Tsai
His original post:
youtube.com/post/UgkxmlTWCmQj2cQo8vcLAMdFpYOKTpOlCztr
If miracles are possible, then which miracles aren’t?
That question creates a serious problem for Christian apologetics.
In this episode of Cynical Sermons, I examine a common defense of the resurrection: skeptics supposedly give miracles an unfairly low probability because we begin by assuming naturalism. If God exists, the argument goes, then raising Jesus from the dead is no longer impossible—and the resurrection can therefore be considered as a genuine historical explanation.
Fine.
Let’s open the supernatural door.
But once that door is open, Christians don’t get to decide that Jesus is the only thing allowed to walk through it.
If supernatural agents can intervene in history, then the resurrection is not suddenly competing only against hallucinations, fraud, legendary development, mistaken identity, or other natural explanations. It is also competing against every conceivable supernatural alternative.
Maybe Satan stole Jesus’s body and engineered false appearances.
Maybe a deceiving spirit altered the disciples’ perceptions.
Maybe another god performed the miracle.
Maybe some unknown supernatural entity staged the entire event for purposes humans cannot understand.
Do I believe any of those things happened?
No.
That’s exactly the point.
They are unsupported supernatural hypotheses—and once supernatural intervention itself becomes an acceptable explanatory category, there is no principled reason to admit the Christian version while dismissing every competing miracle as ridiculous.
Christian apologists frequently want naturalism suspended just long enough to allow their preferred miracle into the conversation. Then they immediately restore ordinary assumptions about reality when evaluating everything else.
Mass hallucinations? Those don’t happen.
Legends developing quickly? Highly unlikely.
People knowingly dying for falsehoods? Human beings don’t behave that way.
Notice what happened: ordinary natural regularities suddenly matter again.
The rules of nature are treated as reliable everywhere except the exact location where the Christian miracle needs them suspended.
That isn’t a consistent epistemology. It’s a hole cut in the fence precisely large enough for one preferred conclusion.
We explore:
• Why allowing miracles does not automatically make the resurrection probable
• The difference between “possible” and “best explanation”
• How Bayesian arguments can smuggle theological assumptions into their priors
• Why supernatural explanations cannot be restricted to Christianity
• The “Satan stole the body” counter-hypothesis
• Demons, spirits, other gods, and mind-altering supernatural agents
• Why Mormon, Hindu, Islamic, and other miracle claims enter through the same door
• The inconsistency of using naturalistic standards against competing religions
• Why “God found me a parking spot” uses the same reasoning as karma, crystals, and horoscopes
• Religious healing claims versus alternative-medicine claims
• Near-death experiences across conflicting religious traditions
• Why feelings of certainty are not reliable truth detectors
• The problem with appealing to the Holy Spirit as independent confirmation
• Why subjective religious experiences reliably confirm mutually incompatible beliefs
• The difference between historical evidence and supernatural conclusions
None of this proves Christianity false.
The narrower argument is that invoking the supernatural to rescue a miracle from an otherwise extremely low probability cannot be contained.
Once you say supernatural intervention is a legitimate explanation, you have opened an explanatory category that includes every competing supernatural claim as well.
You don’t get a supernatural VIP lane reserved for Jesus.
There is, however, another way to argue for Christianity—one that I’m perfectly willing to engage with.
Use manuscripts.
Use archaeology.
Use external attestation.
Use textual criticism.
Use historical methodology.
Compare Christianity with Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Mormonism, and every other competing tradition using standards that all of us can examine together.
Historical evidence might establish that early Christians sincerely believed something extraordinary happened. It might tell us when those beliefs appeared, how they developed, and how well our surviving texts preserve them.
But history cannot simply jump from “people believed something extraordinary happened” to “therefore a supernatural resurrection literally occurred.”
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
David’s family crisis becomes a civil war as Absalom returns from exile, steals the loyalty of Israel, seizes his father’s throne, publicly violates David’s concubines, and eventually dies while hanging helplessly from a tree.
In this episode of God-Free Bible Study, we continue through 2 Samuel chapters 14–18—and the house of David somehow becomes even more dysfunctional.
After killing Amnon for raping Tamar, Absalom remains banished from Jerusalem. Joab hires a “wise woman” to manipulate David with a fabricated story, convincing him to allow Absalom’s return. But even after coming home, Absalom is kept away from the king—until he gets Joab’s attention by setting his field on fire.
Once reconciled with David, Absalom begins a remarkably public campaign to undermine him. He stations himself near the city gate, intercepts people seeking justice, tells them the king has failed them, and promises that everything would be better if only he were in charge. According to the story, he does this for four years without David learning about it.
Absalom then declares himself king, forcing David to abandon Jerusalem. David leaves ten concubines behind to maintain the palace—and those women become victims of the punishment Yahweh previously announced for David’s crimes.
At the advice of Ahithophel, Absalom publicly has sex with his father’s concubines on the palace roof. The Bible presents this as the fulfillment of God’s judgment against David for taking Bathsheba and murdering Uriah. Once again, innocent women are subjected to sexual violence as punishment for something a man did.
We also examine:
• Joab’s elaborate scheme to bring Absalom home
• Absalom’s extraordinary beauty and famously heavy hair
• The surprisingly effective negotiation tactic of arson
• Absalom’s four-year campaign against his father
• David fleeing Jerusalem while leaving ten concubines behind
• Shimei chasing David, throwing stones and shouting curses
• David’s spies infiltrating Absalom’s court
• Ahithophel’s advice and unexplained suicide
• Yet another enormous and historically questionable casualty count
• A forest that supposedly kills more soldiers than the battle
• Absalom becoming trapped in a tree by his head
• Joab ignoring David’s orders and killing Absalom
• The Bible’s confused relay race between two messengers
• David mourning the son whose army he had just defeated
The text expects us to believe that Absalom openly undermined David for years without anyone telling the king, that his most trusted advisers switched loyalties with almost no suspicion, that 20,000 men died in another conveniently enormous battle, and that Absalom was finally defeated because his head happened to become lodged in an oak tree while his mule continued without him.
Behind the absurd storytelling, however, is something much darker: women are treated as property, sexual violence becomes a tool of political humiliation, and Yahweh’s promised “justice” is inflicted upon people who had no part in David’s crimes.
David is supposedly the man after God’s own heart. His household is now defined by rape, murder, revenge, betrayal, political propaganda, civil war, and a divine punishment carried out against innocent women.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
Ken Ham's original message of hate: youtube.com/watch?v=No7JRNxulCg
Ken Ham declared that “a gay marriage is not a valid marriage.” After receiving more than 7,000 Facebook comments, he made a video complaining about the anger, mockery, and personal attacks directed toward him.
Apparently, the real problem isn’t the prominent Christian fundamentalist publicly declaring thousands of loving families invalid. The problem is that people weren’t polite enough when they responded.
In this episode of Breakdowns & Beatdowns, I examine Ken Ham’s claim that the Christian God created marriage, exclusively defined it as the lifelong union of one man and one woman, and gave Christians the authority to reject every marriage that fails to satisfy their interpretation of Genesis.
There are several problems with that argument.
First, marriage existed long before the biblical texts were written. Ancient Mesopotamian law codes, marriage contracts, religious traditions, and family regulations addressed marriage, divorce, inheritance, adultery, bride prices, second wives, and other marital arrangements centuries before the earliest plausible dates for Genesis.
We examine examples including:
• The Code of Ur-Nammu
• The Laws of Lipit-Ishtar
• The Laws of Eshnunna
• The Code of Hammurabi
• Old Assyrian marriage contracts
• Hittite and Middle Assyrian laws
• The Vedic wedding tradition
• Egyptian marital customs
• Sumerian sacred-marriage traditions
Referencing an institution does not mean that your religion invented or owns it. The Bible mentions monarchies, law codes, animal sacrifice, circumcision, and prophecy—but none of those originated with Yahweh either.
Then there is Genesis 2:24, the single sentence conservative Christians repeatedly present as God’s comprehensive definition of marriage:
A man leaves his parents, clings to his wife, and the two become one flesh.
The passage never says “lifelong.” It never says “exclusive.” It never explicitly mandates monogamy, declares this the only permissible marital arrangement, or even attempts to provide a complete legal definition of marriage. Ken has to insert those conclusions into the passage because they are not actually written there.
The wider Bible makes his argument even harder to defend.
Biblical marriage includes arranged unions, polygamy, concubines, levirate marriage, captured women taken as wives, enslaved women forced into relationships, and husbands impregnating servants. Abraham, Jacob, David, Solomon, and other celebrated biblical figures clearly fail Ken’s supposedly eternal “one man, one woman” standard.
Ken doesn’t follow the Bible’s definition of marriage. He selectively extracts the parts that support his modern conservative identity politics and ignores everything else.
We also examine:
• Whether Yahweh can honestly be credited with inventing marriage
• Why Genesis 2:24 is not a complete definition
• Jesus referring to male and female without defining every valid marriage
• The many marital arrangements permitted or commanded in the Bible
• Ken’s attempt to separate a marriage’s validity from its legality
• Why civil authorities—not religious apologists—determine legal validity
• The difference between declaring something immoral and declaring it invalid
• Christians provoking outrage and then claiming persecution
• Why ridicule does not automatically invalidate the criticism behind it
• Ken condemning personal attacks after publicly attacking entire families
• The assumption that everyone must recognize his God’s authority
• Why Yahweh’s alleged commands carry no authority for nonbelievers
• The hypocrisy of demanding “gentleness and respect” from the people you insulted
Ken complains that people mocked him, his Creation Museum, the Ark Encounter, the Bible, and God. But he began the conversation by publicly dismissing real marriages, committed relationships, and loving families as invalid.
You do not get to throw a grenade into someone else’s home and then complain that their response lacked Christian gentleness.
This matters because Ken Ham is not merely an irrelevant relative yelling from his porch. He is an influential fundamentalist figure whose organization reaches a large audience, promotes young-earth creationism, contributes to Christian-nationalist politics, and helps normalize hostility toward LGBTQ+ people and their families.
He delivers the message softly, but the message is still hateful.
David is supposed to be a man after God’s own heart. In these chapters, he conquers nations, mutilates animals, takes another man’s wife, arranges that man’s death, and then watches as Yahweh punishes innocent women and a newborn child for David’s crimes.
In this episode of God-Free Bible Study, we continue through 2 Samuel chapters 8–13—and the story of King David becomes considerably darker.
David begins by expanding his kingdom through war, mass killing, forced servitude, tribute, and the hamstringing of captured horses. The Bible repeatedly credits Yahweh for giving David victory wherever he goes, while presenting enormous and historically questionable casualty numbers as fact.
David then shows kindness to Jonathan’s surviving son, Mephibosheth, restoring Saul’s property to him and giving him a permanent place at the royal table. Is this sincere compassion for Jonathan’s family—or another politically useful demonstration of David’s generosity toward the former royal house?
After a war sparked by the public humiliation of David’s messengers, we arrive at one of the Bible’s most infamous stories: David and Bathsheba.
David sees Bathsheba bathing, summons her to the palace, sleeps with her despite the enormous power imbalance between them, and impregnates her. When his attempts to trick her husband Uriah fail, David secretly orders Joab to place Uriah in the most dangerous part of the battle and abandon him there.
David takes Uriah’s wife after Uriah is killed—but Yahweh’s response is somehow even more morally disturbing.
Through the prophet Nathan, God announces that David’s wives will be publicly violated and that Bathsheba’s newborn child will die as punishment for David’s actions. David admits his sin and is immediately forgiven. The innocent child, however, becomes sick and dies after seven days.
We also examine:
• David’s wars of conquest and mass executions
• The deliberate hamstringing of captured horses
• David’s questionable “kindness” to Mephibosheth
• The humiliation of David’s messengers
• The power imbalance between David and Bathsheba
• David’s calculated murder of Uriah
• Nathan’s parable of the stolen lamb
• Yahweh punishing innocent people for David’s crimes
• The death of Bathsheba’s infant son
• The birth of Solomon
• Amnon’s obsession with his half-sister Tamar
• Tamar’s rape and abandonment
• David’s refusal to punish his firstborn son
• Absalom’s revenge killing of Amnon
• A royal family that mourns the rapist while largely ignoring his victim
Christians often respond that these passages are descriptive rather than prescriptive—that the Bible is merely recording the behavior of flawed human beings. But that defense becomes difficult when Yahweh personally chooses the punishments, forgives David, kills an innocent baby, and threatens sexual violence against women who had nothing to do with David’s crimes.
This is not justice. It is collective punishment, abuse, misogyny, and cruelty presented as the judgment of a supposedly perfectly moral God.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel
My prior video on this topic can be found here: youtu.be/YjJXs2Ba0dk
Do you choose what you believe?
It sounds like a simple yes-or-no question. It isn’t—and forcing it into a binary may be why believers and skeptics keep talking past each other.
In this episode of Cynical Sermons, I revisit one of my earlier arguments: that belief is not a choice. I still think the central point was correct. You cannot simply decide that you are standing on Mars, that gravity does not exist, or that something you consider obviously false is suddenly true.
But that answer was incomplete.
Belief is not a single position. It exists on a spectrum, and the role that choice plays depends heavily upon where someone currently stands.
I propose seven levels of belief:
0. Outright Denial
You are certain the proposition is false. For most adults, Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy belong here.
1. True Disbelief
You have rejected the claim, but preserve a small degree of epistemic uncertainty. This is where many atheists stand regarding God.
2. Motivated Skeptic
You lean toward disbelief, but personal desires, experiences, fears, or assumptions may be pushing you in that direction.
3. True Neutrality
You genuinely have not formed a conclusion—either because you know very little about the subject or because the evidence seems evenly balanced.
4. Motivated Seeker
You remain uncertain, but emotional, social, or existential pressures are pulling you toward belief.
5. True Belief
You are deeply convinced and may organize your life around the belief, while still recognizing that it has not become undeniable knowledge.
6. Ontological Knowledge
The proposition is no longer experienced as a belief at all. You simply know it in the same way that you know the sun exists or that the ground is beneath you.
Choice does not operate equally across this scale.
At levels zero and six, there is no switch to flip. At levels one and five, people can change, but usually through a slow internal process—not because someone defeated them in a debate or posted the perfect syllogism. In the middle levels, however, choice can play a genuine role. People can select which questions to pursue, which communities to join, which sources to trust, and whether to lean into or resist a developing belief.
This explains why both sides of the argument seem to have real examples supporting them. Christians often think of people in the middle who gradually chose to commit themselves to faith. Skeptics often think of people at the poles who simply cannot force themselves to believe something that appears obviously false.
Both are describing real experiences. They are simply describing different positions on the spectrum.
We also examine:
• Why Christian theology needs unbelief to be voluntary
• How eternal conscious torment depends upon the language of choice
• Why punishing someone for involuntary disbelief would be monstrous
• The similar role “choice” plays in religious arguments about sexuality
• Biblical passages that portray belief as granted, withheld, or manipulated by God
• The danger of treating humans as passive products of their conditioning
• Whether involuntary beliefs eliminate moral responsibility
• Why certainty performs better online than intellectual honesty
• How believers and atheists reveal their actual confidence through their language
• Why arguments rarely move deeply entrenched people
• Where personal agency genuinely enters the belief-forming process
This framework also creates an even greater problem for the doctrine of hell. The people most frequently condemned for unbelief are the people furthest from belief—the very people with the least ability to simply choose differently.
The less voluntary the supposed crime becomes, the more severe the punishment gets.
That is not justice.
tiny.cc/skepticus
Read the companion site:
skepticus.info
Join the Discord:
discord.com/invite/ZhP3G6XjzC
Follow on TikTok:
tiktok.com/@skepticus.channel


