Noel Plum | Trans Athletes: Inclusion VS Fairness? - UK Sports Council's Bold Document @noelplum99 | Uploaded October 2021 | Updated October 2024, 1 week ago.
Recently the UK Sports Council concluded it's funded research into transgender sports policy with a series of documents , headlined by a guidance documents for UK sports governing bodies. It is fair to say that this work appears a step beyond what has taken place elsewhere (World Rugby perhaps excepted)
In this video I review the guidelines, outlining what the Sports Council proposes as well as giving my thoughts (obviously). The video starts with a brief(ish) tl;dr style outline of their recommendations before going into each of the principles (alongside their recommended model) in some more depth.
00:00 Introduction
03:24 The toxic and chilling environment suppressing honest discussion
07:25 The Sports Council's conclusions in brief
09:26 Defining fairness, inclusion and safety
11:49 Principle #1 A commitment to the inclusion of trans people into sport
13:08 Principle #2 The sex binary is a functional division within sport that should be retained
18:42 Principle #3 Including trans people into the male category is both fair and (usually) safe
22:03 Principle #4 Fairness cannot be reconciled with self-identification into the female (ie protected) category
26:11 Principle #5 Evidence suggests testosterone suppression does NOT remove all male advantages
28:23 Principle #6 Case-by-case assessments are impractical and problematic
33:42 Principle #7 Categorisation by sex is lawful (in the UK)
35:38 Principle #9 Each governing bodies must choose what to prioritise at different sporting levels
37:40 The sports council's model: the three possible approaches to be considered
43:26 Finally the "female + open" model appears to be getting serious consideration :-)
48:27 Conclusion and typing up the video
Links
The Sport's Council's documentation in full - equalityinsport.org/resources/index.html
My video from back in March 2019 proposing and championing the "female + open" model - youtube.com/watch?v=DLtm3o704RA
Here is Dr Jon Pike in a paper published in the Journal of the Philosophy of Sport Dec 2020
"Safety, fairness, and inclusion: transgender athletes and the essence of Rugby" more rigorously arguing for the same model - doi.org/10.1080/00948705.2020.1863814
The International Olympic Committees now outdated (by their own admission), yet still current, policy from 2015 stillmed.olympic.org/Documents/Commissions_PDFfiles/Medical_commission/2015-11_ioc_consensus_meeting_on_sex_reassignment_and_hyperandrogenism-en.pdf
Richard Budgett from the IOC clarifies that now fairness is a secondary concern for the IOC -
theguardian.com/sport/2021/sep/20/conflicting-opinions-iocs-transgender-guidelines-delayed-again-until-2022
The UK Equality Act 2010, exclusions for sport
legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/195
To support my work you can do so via Partreon:
patreon.com/noelplum99
Paypal recurring (or single) payments
paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=28BRVRN2DUQL6&source=url
Or get with the cool kids, shrug of that "no coiner" mentality, and use crypto!
erc20/bsc address 0x3259E8546533b61f0B3e930A83F89b74360eb61c
BTC address bc1qnh83wjlcmx7mtt5el2ma5xmxe4nv78r0jv6f65
ADA addr1q8r54fe78e3k6zjyt4ezgwvu48mxfymsefs5njukq3wv54xan0ery4ucdqe695gv0ad8cg8nwr8ru7upmf3e0dm8mdtse2jlsx
DOT 1626kzyqv7dvdRT5CcJJ1bzTghCHRd6A5rrzGuDBwXCdiM4h
Recently the UK Sports Council concluded it's funded research into transgender sports policy with a series of documents , headlined by a guidance documents for UK sports governing bodies. It is fair to say that this work appears a step beyond what has taken place elsewhere (World Rugby perhaps excepted)
In this video I review the guidelines, outlining what the Sports Council proposes as well as giving my thoughts (obviously). The video starts with a brief(ish) tl;dr style outline of their recommendations before going into each of the principles (alongside their recommended model) in some more depth.
00:00 Introduction
03:24 The toxic and chilling environment suppressing honest discussion
07:25 The Sports Council's conclusions in brief
09:26 Defining fairness, inclusion and safety
11:49 Principle #1 A commitment to the inclusion of trans people into sport
13:08 Principle #2 The sex binary is a functional division within sport that should be retained
18:42 Principle #3 Including trans people into the male category is both fair and (usually) safe
22:03 Principle #4 Fairness cannot be reconciled with self-identification into the female (ie protected) category
26:11 Principle #5 Evidence suggests testosterone suppression does NOT remove all male advantages
28:23 Principle #6 Case-by-case assessments are impractical and problematic
33:42 Principle #7 Categorisation by sex is lawful (in the UK)
35:38 Principle #9 Each governing bodies must choose what to prioritise at different sporting levels
37:40 The sports council's model: the three possible approaches to be considered
43:26 Finally the "female + open" model appears to be getting serious consideration :-)
48:27 Conclusion and typing up the video
Links
The Sport's Council's documentation in full - equalityinsport.org/resources/index.html
My video from back in March 2019 proposing and championing the "female + open" model - youtube.com/watch?v=DLtm3o704RA
Here is Dr Jon Pike in a paper published in the Journal of the Philosophy of Sport Dec 2020
"Safety, fairness, and inclusion: transgender athletes and the essence of Rugby" more rigorously arguing for the same model - doi.org/10.1080/00948705.2020.1863814
The International Olympic Committees now outdated (by their own admission), yet still current, policy from 2015 stillmed.olympic.org/Documents/Commissions_PDFfiles/Medical_commission/2015-11_ioc_consensus_meeting_on_sex_reassignment_and_hyperandrogenism-en.pdf
Richard Budgett from the IOC clarifies that now fairness is a secondary concern for the IOC -
theguardian.com/sport/2021/sep/20/conflicting-opinions-iocs-transgender-guidelines-delayed-again-until-2022
The UK Equality Act 2010, exclusions for sport
legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/195
To support my work you can do so via Partreon:
patreon.com/noelplum99
Paypal recurring (or single) payments
paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=28BRVRN2DUQL6&source=url
Or get with the cool kids, shrug of that "no coiner" mentality, and use crypto!
erc20/bsc address 0x3259E8546533b61f0B3e930A83F89b74360eb61c
BTC address bc1qnh83wjlcmx7mtt5el2ma5xmxe4nv78r0jv6f65
ADA addr1q8r54fe78e3k6zjyt4ezgwvu48mxfymsefs5njukq3wv54xan0ery4ucdqe695gv0ad8cg8nwr8ru7upmf3e0dm8mdtse2jlsx
DOT 1626kzyqv7dvdRT5CcJJ1bzTghCHRd6A5rrzGuDBwXCdiM4h
