Bridging Between Naturalism and Christianity with John Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2019-08-17 | In our second discussion, John and I attempt to figure out the bridges between his position and Christianity. We do so both ontologically and existentially.Previous discussion: youtube.com/watch?v=XccFYuTGskcVideo wrap-up of the first discussion: youtube.com/watch?v=z35umuP1rXk
After the Meaning Crisis — Metaphysics Course Announcement J.P. Marceau 2023-10-13 | During the past few months, I’ve been writing a book and assembling a course to provide a thorough introduction to the metaphysics that have emerged in the symbolic world over the last few years. In particular, I want to cover the best of what came out of the discussions I had with Jonathan, John and Paul around non-reductive naturalism, levels of being, and the Incarnation. If you liked my articles/conversations but didn’t quite get it, I’m hoping that this course would fix that.I’m thinking about 6 sessions of roughly 2 hours. Cost around 160$. Sometime on Thursdays. We would probably start early November.Now, before opening and publicizing the course, what I’d like to do here is gauge interest, so please, let me know in the comments if you’d be interested. Also, please let me know what kind of time slot would work best for you (including your timezone please). I’m pretty flexible and I’m guessing that evenings would be best for most people, but I don’t have a great idea of the different timezones people are in.
Aquinas & Neoplatonism — With Gaven Kerr J.P. Marceau 2022-12-18 | Gaven Kerr answers some of my questions about how Aquinas might solve some of the problems facing his neoplatonic predecessors.Check out Gaven's work:amazon.com/s?i=stripbooks&rh=p_27%3AGaven+Kerrhttps://sppu.ie/staff/dr-gaven-kerr-ba-mphil-phdtwitter.com/kerrgaven?lang=enMy previous conversation about Aquinas and neoplatonism with John Vervaeke: youtu.be/lx9JEwRvRWI
The Symbolism of Work: Ep. 3 — With Ryan Barton J.P. Marceau 2022-12-16 | I continue my explorations into the symbolism of work with Ryan Barton, who's been thinking about about work and meaning for much longer than I have!Ryan's appearance on John's channel: youtube.com/watch?v=JHpcEFweejACheck out Ryan's work:ryanbarton.com/aboutlinkedin.com/in/ryanbarton-mstech
The Symbolism of Work: Ep. 2 — With Patrick Duffley J.P. Marceau 2022-11-27 | My friend Patrick and I discuss how to apply symbolism concretely, especially to work. We follow up on my previous conversations with Derek and Jonathan.Scott Hanh's book we refer to is titled Ordinary Work, Extraordinary Grace: amazon.com/Ordinary-Work-Extraordinary-Grace-Spiritual/dp/0385519249Previous conversations:youtube.com/watch?v=6DI-kCYVbfYthesymbolicworld.com/articles/is-work-symbolic-jonathan-jp
The Symbolism of Work: Ep. 1 — With Derek Fiedler J.P. Marceau 2022-11-19 | Derek and I try to figure out how to better apply symbolism to our lives, in particular to our work.Let me know what you think about this, it could be useful for the rest of the series.Derek's channel: youtube.com/c/DerekJFiedler
Aquinas & Neoplatonism Part I w/ John Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2022-10-22 | In this mind bender of a conversation, John Vervaeke and I discuss a book by W. Norris Clarke on Aquinas. We try to drill down on the problem of emanation, and especially on whether Aquinas can answer better than Plotinus did.It wasn't easy, so we'll have to do a follow up 😅Clarke's book: amazon.com/One-Many-Contemporary-Thomistic-Metaphysics/dp/0268037078John's channel: youtube.com/user/johnvervaeke
Love, Panpsychism and Neoplatonism w/ John Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2022-06-14 | Back with John Vervaeke to discuss panpsychism and neoplatonism! I outline an argument I recently made to go beyond panpsychism into neoplatonism, and John asks great clarification questions, as always. Conversation ensues!John's channel: youtube.com/user/johnvervaekeOriginal video of the argument: youtu.be/6YM9MHxLjrU
Panpsychism and Neoplatonism: Re-Enchantment for Mathematicians and Physicists J.P. Marceau 2022-05-29 | Text version with references: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/panpsychism-and-neoplatonism-re-enchantment-for-mathematicians-and-physicists
Nassim Talebs Empirical Symbolism J.P. Marceau 2022-04-21 | Text version with references: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/nassim-talebs-empirical-symbolim
Through Adam: Creation and Return J.P. Marceau 2022-03-01 | How does Adam's naming of the animals participate in creation? I try to answer by reviewing two articles by D.C. Schindler.Text version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/creation-and-returnSchindler's articles:communio-icr.com/files/43.2_DCS.pdfcommunio-icr.com/files/46.1_DCS_HQ.pdf
René Girard and Dis-Enchanted Christianity—w/ Daniel Townhead J.P. Marceau 2022-02-26 | Daniel's article: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/introducing-rene-girard-to-the-symbolic-world-and-placing-him-within-itDaniel's channel: youtube.com/channel/UCRpau4-D7CYRo-Dcn8kym6gVideos where I bring up Schindler and Ulrich: Mainly: youtube.com/watch?v=E07nCHYXjWE Plus two discussions: youtube.com/watch?v=sINcVKVwkjE youtube.com/watch?v=aCEe3GDGQVY
Plant Symbolism & Theosis w/ Kenneth Florence J.P. Marceau 2022-02-06 | Please check out Kenneth's article: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/the-meaning-of-plants
The Transcendence of Form Over Matter: Commenting on 2 Articles by D.C. Schindler w/ Patrick Duffley J.P. Marceau 2022-01-30 | My friend Patrick Duffley and I discuss the following articles by D.C. Schindler.Participation: https://www.anselm.edu/sites/default/files/Documents/Institute%20of%20SA%20Studies/4.5.3.2g_31Schindler.pdfGender & the transcendence of form: communio-icr.com/files/43.2_DCS.pdf
Miracles 3: Christian Naturalism? Just One More Layer?! w/ Vanderklay and Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2021-09-08 | Paul, John and I circumambulate around teleology and Easter, to see how close naturalism and Christianity can get to one another.Here's the Easter article we reference throughout: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/evil-enlightenment-and-easterPrevious articles and discussions:Round 1: - thesymbolicworld.com/articles/investigating-miracles-with-lewis-and-vervaeke - youtube.com/watch?v=sPLreFRV_FsRound 2: - thesymbolicworld.com/articles/possibility-intelligibility-and-the-incarnation - youtube.com/watch?v=XGoil4zuQPcRound 3:- thesymbolicworld.com/articles/evil-enlightenment-and-easterJohn's channel: youtube.com/user/johnvervaekePaul's channel: youtube.com/c/PaulVanderKlay
The Symbolism of Contraception & NFP J.P. Marceau 2021-08-28 | Text version with references: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/the-symbolism-of-contraception-and-natural-family-planning
Grounding Your Intellect With Peterson and Augustine J.P. Marceau 2021-06-17 | Jean-Philippe MarceauText version (with references): thesymbolicworld.com/articles/grounding-your-intellect-with-peterson-and-augustine
Evil, Enlightenment, and Easter J.P. Marceau 2021-05-02 | Happy Easter! Christ is Risen! Not one dead remains in the grave, and all tears are washed away.Text version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/evil-enlightenment-and-easter
Miracles Ep. 2: Incarnation & Enlightenment w/ Vanderklay & Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2021-04-15 | Please enjoy this conversation with the wonderful Paul Vanderklay and John Vervaeke where we bridge between naturalist enlightenment and the Christian Incarnation.First convo: youtube.com/watch?v=GCeHJtdQ0fgArticles referenced: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/possibility-intelligibility-and-the-incarnation and thesymbolicworld.com/articles/prayer-time-and-causalityPaul's channel: youtube.com/channel/UCGsDIP_K6J6VSTqlq-9IPlgJohn's channel: youtube.com/channel/UCpqDUjTsof-kTNpnyWper_Q
Possibility, Intelligibility, and the Incarnation J.P. Marceau 2021-04-01 | text version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/possibility-intelligibility-and-the-incarnation
Prayer, Time and Causality J.P. Marceau 2021-02-19 | Jean-Philippe MarceauText version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/prayer-time-and-causality
Guénon and the Solidification of the World J.P. Marceau 2020-12-29 | Text version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/guenon-and-the-solidification-of-the-world
Miracles - Responding to Objections J.P. Marceau 2020-11-28 | Text version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/miracles-responding-to-objections
The Metaphysics of Miracles with Lewis and Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2020-10-26 | Text version (with references): thesymbolicworld.com/articles/investigating-miracles-with-lewis-and-vervaeke
Perception is Symbolic J.P. Marceau 2020-08-28 | Jean-Philippe MarceauText version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/bible/perception-is-symbolicReferences:Bible, Luke’s Gospel, 24:13-32American Optometric Association. Infant Vision: Birth to 24 Months of Age. aoa.org/patients-and-public/good-vision-throughout-life/childrens-vision/infant-vision-birth-to-24-months-of-age Noë, Alva. Out of Our Heads, at 47 and following. Hill and Wang, 2009. amazon.ca/dp/B003D0B83M/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1Kendrick, Mandy. Tasting the Light. Scientific American, 2009, August. scientificamerican.com/article/device-lets-blind-see-with-tonguesBach-y-Rita and Neuroplasticity, YouTube, 2012, December youtube.com/watch?v=7s1VAVcM8s8Fonagy, Peter and Target, Mary. Attachment and Reflective Function: Their Role in Self-Organization, Development and Psychology, 1997. partiallyexaminedlife.com/wp-content/uploads/Fonagy-Attachment-and-reflective-function-Their-role-in-self-organization.pdfHaidt, Jonathan and Joseph, Craig. The Moral Mind: How 5 Sets of Innate Moral Intuitions Duide the Development of Many Culture-Apecific Cirtues, and Perhaps Even Modules. In P. Carruthers, S. Laurence, & S. Stich (Eds.), The innate mind (Vol. 3, pp. 367–391). 2006, December. http://bingweb.binghamton.edu/~evos/pdffiles/EvoS%20spring%2007%20pdfs/Haidt/Haidt2.pdfPageau, Jonathan. “Jordan Peterson and the Stories We Live In”, YouTube, 2020, July. youtube.com/watch?v=pTsRnW6baO0Marceau, Jean-Philippe. “Joyful Suffering in Christ – How the Cross Brings Cosmic Meaning to Our Afflictions”, The Symbolic World Blog, 2020, June. youtube.com/watch?v=74q0T9W9r2c&t=2sMarceau, Jean-Philippe. “Rediscovering Forms”, The Symbolic World Blog, April, 2020. youtube.com/watch?v=V0XZRvSFBag&t=2s
Are Stories Real? With Derek Fiedler J.P. Marceau 2020-07-29 | Derek's article: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/the-symbolism-of-storyDerek's channel:youtube.com/channel/UCmGgB15kYrLYcOm9MLGvA8AMy article on suffering: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/bible/joyful-suffering-in-christ-how-the-cross-brings-cosmic-meaning-to-our-afflictions
The Symbolism of Cell Tower Arson (The Symbolic World Blog) J.P. Marceau 2020-06-09 | Text version: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/the-symbolism-of-cell-tower-arsonPrevious post; Rediscovering Forms: youtube.com/watch?v=V0XZRvSFBag
The Symbolism of the Active and the Contemplative with Jacob Russell J.P. Marceau 2020-06-02 | Jacob Russell and I discuss John and Peter, Mary and Martha, East and West, the Inner and the Outer, Heaven and Earth.
Rediscovering Forms J.P. Marceau 2020-04-29 | Blog post: thesymbolicworld.com/articles/rediscovering-formsCheck out the blog: thesymbolicworld.com/articles
St-Maximus on Scripture as a Person J.P. Marceau 2020-03-14 | Video on Heaven and Earth in Christian Panpsychism: youtube.com/watch?v=i9ggv0ZBjPoBook: amazon.com/Ecclesiastical-Mystagogy-Theological-Confessor-Patristics/dp/0881416479
Intro to Process Panpsychism J.P. Marceau 2020-03-01 | Dry run for a presentation I'll give in a few weeks on process panpsychism.To learn more (besides watching more of my videos :p) I'd recommend Milic Capek's book "Bergson and Modern Physics: A Reinterpretation and Reevaluation".
On the Personhood of the One with John Vervaeke and Mary Kochan J.P. Marceau 2020-02-02 | In this second group discussion with John Vervaeke (youtube.com/user/johnvervaeke/featured) and Mary Kochan (youtube.com/channel/UC2leFZRD0ZlQDQxpR2Zd8oA), we discuss relevance realization in the Ground of Being. On other words; personalism in the One.Our previous discussion: youtube.com/watch?v=znNqRYSKB7kI hope you find it useful,JP
Eriugena & the Deep Continuity of Relevance Realization J.P. Marceau 2020-01-25 | My first video on Eriugena: youtu.be/0u3PDmZQ_Cw.I explore the idea of a continuity of relevance realization in the chain of Being, from probability fields to the Inexhaustible, using Eriugena's doctrine of creation.
Eriugenas Symbolic Reading of the Days of Creation J.P. Marceau 2020-01-15 | If you wanna learn more about Eriugena, I recommend Sergei Shushkov's Ph.D. Thesis (http://theses.gla.ac.uk/7070/1/2015SushkovPhd.pdf). Especially pages 217 and onwards where he directly talks about God's rest.
In Opponent Processing with Mary Kochan and John Verveake J.P. Marceau 2019-12-10 | 1:33 pride, arrogance, & certainty11:27 grounding the human quest on metaphysics or science23:44 is the AI community scientistic?25:40 the inevitability of AI36:26 the interplay of engineering and human self-understanding. Idolatry?54:40 scaling, or what about the bozos at the bus stop?1:01:40 the phenomenological difference of religious commitmentleads to a discussion on 1:16:00 a discussion on the miraculous and existential risks1:23:45 the surprising existential viability of apostolic christianity, and opponent processing in this corner of the internet, especially at 1:31:211:35:47 opponent processing in the old testament1:43:25 the personalism of the ground of being1:48:25 the break of the analogy between us and the ground of being1:52:35 defining Being1:55:05 relationality in Being?1:57:00 the question of "person"Mary's channel: youtube.com/channel/UC2leFZRD0ZlQDQxpR2Zd8oAJohn's channel: youtube.com/user/johnvervaeke
Heaven and Earth in Christian Panpsychism J.P. Marceau 2019-11-29 | I attempt to map some ideas from the Pageau brothers and René Girard onto Christian panpsychism.Matthieu's book is titled "The Language of Creation"Jonathan's channel: youtube.com/user/pageaujonathanI renomment René Girard's book "I See Satan Fall Like Lightning"And of course, I strongly recommend St-Paul's letters, especially Ephesians :)
Trying to Answer John Vervaeke with Mary Kochan J.P. Marceau 2019-11-22 | Mary Kochan and I come back on several issues raised in my last discussion with John Vervaeke.Mary's channel: youtube.com/channel/UC2leFZRD0ZlQDQxpR2Zd8oAMy last conversation with John: youtube.com/watch?v=DWg8-VxnOog
Wrestling with Hard Metaphysical Issues with John Vervaeke, Ep. 3 J.P. Marceau 2019-10-30 | John and I keep exploring the ontologies of naturalism and Christianity.Don't miss the last 25 minutes, as John makes what is by far the best anti-theist argument I have ever heard (50:30). I believe I will both enjoy and find beneficial wrestling with it in the coming weeks or months.Suggestions and criticisms are very welcome. Hope that was useful, and thanks for listening.
Knitting the Natural and Supernatural Back Together J.P. Marceau 2019-08-03 | As Vervaeke points out, the meaning crisis in the west was augured in by Aquinas' distinction between the natural/reason and supernatural/faith. In this video, I attempt to bridge the gap by calling on Aquinas himself, Bergson, and David Bentley Hart.In later videos I will take much more time to elaborate on David Bentley Hart's work.
Taking Metaphysical and Existential Risks with Vervaeke and Bergson J.P. Marceau 2019-08-03 | Both Vervaeke's and Bergson's ontologies are viable. Bergson is however willing to take more risks, and gets more in return. This is true ontologically and also existentially.As far as the meaning crisis goes, Vervaeke's position can actually facilitate holding Bergson's by giving it a viable fallback, which, after all, still points towards the cultivation of virtue and wisdom. Thus, the very real existential risk of accepting Bergson's non naturalism can be strongly mitigated.
Panpsychism and the Meaning Crisis w/ John Vervaeke J.P. Marceau 2019-07-20 | John and I follow up on my conversation with Paul Vanderklay (youtube.com/watch?v=M6QmOWI2Ysw) with an in-depth discussion on panpsychism and the meaning crisis.
The Combination Problem for Panpsychism, the Bergsonian Solution, and the Price to Pay J.P. Marceau 2019-07-14 | PanpsychismCombination ProblemEvolution of ConsciousnessPhilip GoffSpatial Solution to the Phenomenal Bonding ProblemBergsonCondensation and FragmentationNaturalism
Panpsychism and Why Its Coming Back J.P. Marceau 2019-07-14 | PanpsychismElegance: fills the ontological void of physicsAvoid causal closure argumentAvoids magical emergenceMeaning crisis: panpsychism puts us back in the fabric of the world, and gives us our agency back
