Uploaded March 2021 | Updated September 2026, 1 week ago
Sandburg writes: "For more than a century ago we have this little piece of songcraft. It is a brief outcry given slight melody rather than a song. We are reminded of the more gentle reproach in the title of John Gunther’s book, “Death, Be Not Proud.”
"We hain't all got the same cross—oh, no! Thar's no two jes like no more than our eyes or noses The same pattern wouldn't fit us all, but thar's nary real child of God but has his cross made a purpose fer him and no other. And let him love it as God's kiss, not endurin’ it a-whinin’, and grudgin’ an’ draggin’ it ‘long in the dust. Let him bear it proudly as a soldier carries his gun, and tenderly, as the lover holds the rosebud given bay his sweetheart.
"The Lord will say, 'Whar's your cross stranger?' And when you show him the battered old thing he'll answer, 'All right,' and turn to an angel and say, “Angel, give this brother or sister a crown.” And, brethren, the heavier, the crookeder, the uglier the cross, just so much brighter’ll be the crown. Perhaps ’twas a thorny cross, tearin’ your flesh, and spotted with blood. Well, every blood drop will turn to a costly jewel in your splendid crown, and will shine like the sun when you dance in silver slippers above. So you see you must endure it to the end. You can’t get shed of it for a steep hill or a deep river. You’d a heap better never touched it if you don endure clear to the end." (from "REMEMBRANCE ROCK," Carl Sandburg (p. 869)
Sandburg writes: "For more than a century ago we have this little piece of songcraft. It is a brief outcry given slight melody rather than a song. We are reminded of the more gentle reproach in the title of John Gunther’s book, “Death, Be Not Proud.”
"We hain't all got the same cross—oh, no! Thar's no two jes like no more than our eyes or noses The same pattern wouldn't fit us all, but thar's nary real child of God but has his cross made a purpose fer him and no other. And let him love it as God's kiss, not endurin’ it a-whinin’, and grudgin’ an’ draggin’ it ‘long in the dust. Let him bear it proudly as a soldier carries his gun, and tenderly, as the lover holds the rosebud given bay his sweetheart.
"The Lord will say, 'Whar's your cross stranger?' And when you show him the battered old thing he'll answer, 'All right,' and turn to an angel and say, “Angel, give this brother or sister a crown.” And, brethren, the heavier, the crookeder, the uglier the cross, just so much brighter’ll be the crown. Perhaps ’twas a thorny cross, tearin’ your flesh, and spotted with blood. Well, every blood drop will turn to a costly jewel in your splendid crown, and will shine like the sun when you dance in silver slippers above. So you see you must endure it to the end. You can’t get shed of it for a steep hill or a deep river. You’d a heap better never touched it if you don endure clear to the end." (from "REMEMBRANCE ROCK," Carl Sandburg (p. 869)





![Little Turtle Dove
NOTES: Hes Gone Away from Carl Sandburgs 1927 The American Songbag.
Sandburg begins his first chapter DRAMAS AND PORTRAITS with the song Hes Gone Away. In studying the roots of Sandburgs selection, several songs show up as closely related.
According to The Traditional Ballad Index, This song (which includes the variation represented in Carl Sandburgs 1927 American Songbag), is officially a catch-all. Other song titles in this category are The True Lovers Farewell, Red Rosy Bush, and Turtle Dove.
Little Turtle Dove, listed in this category was collected by Bascom Lamar Lunsford [who lived just a stones throw from my home] in his 1929 30 and 1 Folk Songs from the Southern Mountains.
Others collected this song as well, including famed British song-catcher Cecil Sharp who collected nine variants in the Appalachian Mountains from 1916-1918.
Perhaps because of Biblical references (especially verse 2:12 from the Song of Songs: The flowers appear on the earth, the time of singing has come, and the voice of the turtledove is heard in our land.)... its mournful voice, and the fact that it forms strong pair bonds, European turtle doves have become emblems of devoted love.
There are tentacles going back to the British Isles, but this will be elaborated upon at a later date. Little Turtle Dove](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/HxkpYk-bLz4/mqdefault.jpg)




