Uploaded April 2026 | Updated September 2026, 1 week ago
Episode 3: After finally identifying the victim as Karen Ramsey, our story turns to the life she left behind. Reporter Phillip Pantuso uncovers clues in old records, a deleted obituary, and the memories of those who knew her. Neighbors at the quiet suburban condo complex where she lived describe a tangled web of affairs, volatile relationships and a marriage that may not have been what it seemed. As that past comes into focus, unsettling questions emerge about what was really happening behind closed doors in the months before Karen disappeared.
00:00 Previously on Long Buried
01:48 The quest for answers
04:20 The obituary clue
06:42 Life after Karen
08:08 "It didn't feel good": A witness account
09:28 Tracking the paper trail
11:56 Breakthrough at Holly Stream Court
14:01 Finding the neighbors
15:00 Meeting Jeanie
17:32: Sponsor: The Girl in the Pond
19:14 Life at Holly Stream
22:23 The first red flags
23:41 A real "Peyton Place"
25:07 "I can't see you anymore"
29:12 The interrogation
30:01 Next time: Who was Karen?
Episode 3: After finally identifying the victim as Karen Ramsey, our story turns to the life she left behind. Reporter Phillip Pantuso uncovers clues in old records, a deleted obituary, and the memories of those who knew her. Neighbors at the quiet suburban condo complex where she lived describe a tangled web of affairs, volatile relationships and a marriage that may not have been what it seemed. As that past comes into focus, unsettling questions emerge about what was really happening behind closed doors in the months before Karen disappeared.
00:00 Previously on Long Buried
01:48 The quest for answers
04:20 The obituary clue
06:42 Life after Karen
08:08 "It didn't feel good": A witness account
09:28 Tracking the paper trail
11:56 Breakthrough at Holly Stream Court
14:01 Finding the neighbors
15:00 Meeting Jeanie
17:32: Sponsor: The Girl in the Pond
19:14 Life at Holly Stream
22:23 The first red flags
23:41 A real "Peyton Place"
25:07 "I can't see you anymore"
29:12 The interrogation
30:01 Next time: Who was Karen?
