Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 11 hours ago
Who is responsible for a Technician making money: the shop or the Technician?
On this Veterans Day edition of Service Drive Revolution LIVE, Chris, Hogi and Adam sit down with Manny of Manny Mechanics, a dealership Technician with 26 years in the trade and an outspoken defender of flat-rate pay. Manny explains why he tells young Technicians they control their own income, how he sets up his stall to flag more hours, and why the Service Advisor is the Technician's real customer.
The team also shares recent client results, including an 11-location heavy truck dealer group whose net profit rose 224% with all 11 departments profitable, and walks through the process behind them: a strategy session, interviews with everyone in service and parts, a boot camp in Los Angeles and a plan to hire Technicians.
Plus viewer questions: which expenses run too high, and what to do when the check-engine light comes back two days after a repair.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Flat Rate Rewards Effort: Manny says that as long as the work is there, a Technician controls their own income. His daily goal is 20 flagged hours.
- Start With Your Stall: Keep it clean, know where your tools are and work from one cart. Every extra step costs money.
- The Advisor Is Your Customer: A Technician who gives the Advisor clear information and a thorough inspection makes the sale possible.
- Capacity Comes First: Advisor training alone will not turn a department around. The shop needs enough Technicians to do the work.
- You Cannot Cut Your Way to Profit: Watch expenses, but discounting, shop efficiency and unproductive wages matter more.
- Own the Comeback: If the light returns within two days or 30 miles, do not charge the customer for another diagnosis.
- Use AI to Explain Codes: Manny asks ChatGPT to describe trouble codes and draft a template the Advisor can use with the customer.
- Keep Learning: Cars change every model year, so Manny studies wiring diagrams at home.
FAQ
Q: Who is responsible for a Technician making money?
A: Manny says the Technician is. On flat rate, a Technician who stays organized and keeps learning can make as much as they are willing to work for.
Q: Is flat-rate pay good for Technicians?
A: Manny says yes. He calls it a pay system where you control your own destiny, and says it takes five to ten years to hone your skills.
Q: How can a flat-rate Technician flag more hours?
A: Focus on your own stall. Keep it clean, keep every tool in one cart, cut wasted steps and study new systems on your own time.
Q: What should a shop do when the check-engine light comes back after a repair?
A: Treat it as the shop's responsibility. As a quality check, Manny suggests having a porter drive the car 40 miles with two key cycles.
Q: Can a Service Department grow profit by cutting expenses?
A: The team says they have never scaled a store's profit that way. They look first at discounting, shop efficiency and unproductive wages.
Q: Why doesn't Advisor training alone fix a Service Department?
A: Without Technician capacity the work cannot get done, so Advisors stop selling to protect CSI.
Q: What results did the dealerships in this episode see?
A: A Hyundai store went from 20% to 35% net-to-gross in one month. A Ford store went from negative 65% to positive 43.65% over six months after adding six Technicians. A Kia store went from 20% to 41%.
0:00 Welcome to SDR LIVE on Veterans Day
0:11 Guest: Manny Mechanics
2:12 How Manny Grew on Social Media
3:15 What a Dealership Means to a Community
4:46 How Manny Got Into the Trade
6:13 Service Drive Revolution's Growth
7:34 Why Technicians Leave Dealerships
8:58 How We Get Results in Service Departments
10:17 Recent Client Results
16:14 Why Advisor Training Alone Fails
17:01 The Strategy Session
19:11 Interviewing Everyone in Service and Parts
21:46 The Plan and the Boot Camp
22:46 Hiring Technicians
26:14 Which Expenses Run Too High?
28:25 When the Check-Engine Light Comes Back
30:02 Using ChatGPT to Explain Codes
30:48 Why a Thorough Inspection Matters
34:09 The Advisor Is the Technician's Customer
36:13 Hourly vs. Flat Rate
37:41 Advice for Young Technicians
40:08 Where the Passion Went
42:17 Trade School vs. College Debt
Follow our guest, Manny Mechanics, on Instagram:
instagram.com/mannymechanics
SDR Live Academy Online Training For Huge Results:
chriscollinsinc.com/op/sdr-live-weekly
Book your Profit Gap Analysis Now:
calendly.com/byron-webster/30min
Best-selling books on making Fixed Ops a money printer:
chriscollinsinc.com/shop
Got a question?
Call us at 1-833-3-ASK-SDR
Want to work with the best?
chriscollinsinc.com/careers
Grab Chris' Leadership Book I AM LEADER:
iamleader.com
Who is responsible for a Technician making money: the shop or the Technician?
On this Veterans Day edition of Service Drive Revolution LIVE, Chris, Hogi and Adam sit down with Manny of Manny Mechanics, a dealership Technician with 26 years in the trade and an outspoken defender of flat-rate pay. Manny explains why he tells young Technicians they control their own income, how he sets up his stall to flag more hours, and why the Service Advisor is the Technician's real customer.
The team also shares recent client results, including an 11-location heavy truck dealer group whose net profit rose 224% with all 11 departments profitable, and walks through the process behind them: a strategy session, interviews with everyone in service and parts, a boot camp in Los Angeles and a plan to hire Technicians.
Plus viewer questions: which expenses run too high, and what to do when the check-engine light comes back two days after a repair.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Flat Rate Rewards Effort: Manny says that as long as the work is there, a Technician controls their own income. His daily goal is 20 flagged hours.
- Start With Your Stall: Keep it clean, know where your tools are and work from one cart. Every extra step costs money.
- The Advisor Is Your Customer: A Technician who gives the Advisor clear information and a thorough inspection makes the sale possible.
- Capacity Comes First: Advisor training alone will not turn a department around. The shop needs enough Technicians to do the work.
- You Cannot Cut Your Way to Profit: Watch expenses, but discounting, shop efficiency and unproductive wages matter more.
- Own the Comeback: If the light returns within two days or 30 miles, do not charge the customer for another diagnosis.
- Use AI to Explain Codes: Manny asks ChatGPT to describe trouble codes and draft a template the Advisor can use with the customer.
- Keep Learning: Cars change every model year, so Manny studies wiring diagrams at home.
FAQ
Q: Who is responsible for a Technician making money?
A: Manny says the Technician is. On flat rate, a Technician who stays organized and keeps learning can make as much as they are willing to work for.
Q: Is flat-rate pay good for Technicians?
A: Manny says yes. He calls it a pay system where you control your own destiny, and says it takes five to ten years to hone your skills.
Q: How can a flat-rate Technician flag more hours?
A: Focus on your own stall. Keep it clean, keep every tool in one cart, cut wasted steps and study new systems on your own time.
Q: What should a shop do when the check-engine light comes back after a repair?
A: Treat it as the shop's responsibility. As a quality check, Manny suggests having a porter drive the car 40 miles with two key cycles.
Q: Can a Service Department grow profit by cutting expenses?
A: The team says they have never scaled a store's profit that way. They look first at discounting, shop efficiency and unproductive wages.
Q: Why doesn't Advisor training alone fix a Service Department?
A: Without Technician capacity the work cannot get done, so Advisors stop selling to protect CSI.
Q: What results did the dealerships in this episode see?
A: A Hyundai store went from 20% to 35% net-to-gross in one month. A Ford store went from negative 65% to positive 43.65% over six months after adding six Technicians. A Kia store went from 20% to 41%.
0:00 Welcome to SDR LIVE on Veterans Day
0:11 Guest: Manny Mechanics
2:12 How Manny Grew on Social Media
3:15 What a Dealership Means to a Community
4:46 How Manny Got Into the Trade
6:13 Service Drive Revolution's Growth
7:34 Why Technicians Leave Dealerships
8:58 How We Get Results in Service Departments
10:17 Recent Client Results
16:14 Why Advisor Training Alone Fails
17:01 The Strategy Session
19:11 Interviewing Everyone in Service and Parts
21:46 The Plan and the Boot Camp
22:46 Hiring Technicians
26:14 Which Expenses Run Too High?
28:25 When the Check-Engine Light Comes Back
30:02 Using ChatGPT to Explain Codes
30:48 Why a Thorough Inspection Matters
34:09 The Advisor Is the Technician's Customer
36:13 Hourly vs. Flat Rate
37:41 Advice for Young Technicians
40:08 Where the Passion Went
42:17 Trade School vs. College Debt
Follow our guest, Manny Mechanics, on Instagram:
instagram.com/mannymechanics
SDR Live Academy Online Training For Huge Results:
chriscollinsinc.com/op/sdr-live-weekly
Book your Profit Gap Analysis Now:
calendly.com/byron-webster/30min
Best-selling books on making Fixed Ops a money printer:
chriscollinsinc.com/shop
Got a question?
Call us at 1-833-3-ASK-SDR
Want to work with the best?
chriscollinsinc.com/careers
Grab Chris' Leadership Book I AM LEADER:
iamleader.com










