Uploaded August 2026 | Updated September 2026, 3 weeks ago
The defense has delivered its final argument to jurors in the Linsday Clancy case, arguing her mental illness — not a calculated plan — explains what happened at the time of the deaths of her three children.
During a closing argument lasting just over 50 minutes, defense attorney Kevin Reddington told jurors Clancy was suffering from postpartum psychosis and a mental disease or defect at the time, repeatedly pushing back against the prosecution's portrayal of her actions as calculated. Reddington argued she had desperately sought help as her mental health deteriorated, asking jurors, “My God! What does she have to do? She was reaching out for help and she was not getting it.” He told jurors to blame what he described as “the damn medicine” and “lousy medical care,” pointing to defense experts who testified they believed Clancy was psychotic at the time. The presentation also addressed evidence prosecutors say demonstrated planning — including Clancy sending her husband on errands before the deaths — which Reddington argued could instead be viewed as a mother attempting to care for her children, and questioned why some prosecution experts did not interview Clancy until years afterward, contrasting that with defense witnesses who interacted with her in the days and months immediately after.
Clancy appeared emotional throughout portions of the closing, at one point wiping her eyes with a tissue, as Reddington closed with the central argument of the defense case: “This young lady is not guilty of the killing of her young children because she was suffering from a disease and defect.” After more than five weeks of testimony, the case is now in its final stage as jurors prepare to determine whether Clancy should be held criminally responsible.
_______________
ABOUT
Criminally Obsessed is first on the scene, uniting fellow armchair detectives in their quest to crack the case.
FOLLOW
Instagram: instagram.com/criminallyobsessed
Facebook: facebook.com/CrmnllyObsessed
TikTok: tiktok.com/@crmnallyobsessed
X: twitter.com/crmnllyobsessed
SUBSCRIBE
youtube.com/@CriminallyObsessed?sub_confirmation=1
MERCH STORE
criminallyobsessed.promoshopestores.com
The defense has delivered its final argument to jurors in the Linsday Clancy case, arguing her mental illness — not a calculated plan — explains what happened at the time of the deaths of her three children.
During a closing argument lasting just over 50 minutes, defense attorney Kevin Reddington told jurors Clancy was suffering from postpartum psychosis and a mental disease or defect at the time, repeatedly pushing back against the prosecution's portrayal of her actions as calculated. Reddington argued she had desperately sought help as her mental health deteriorated, asking jurors, “My God! What does she have to do? She was reaching out for help and she was not getting it.” He told jurors to blame what he described as “the damn medicine” and “lousy medical care,” pointing to defense experts who testified they believed Clancy was psychotic at the time. The presentation also addressed evidence prosecutors say demonstrated planning — including Clancy sending her husband on errands before the deaths — which Reddington argued could instead be viewed as a mother attempting to care for her children, and questioned why some prosecution experts did not interview Clancy until years afterward, contrasting that with defense witnesses who interacted with her in the days and months immediately after.
Clancy appeared emotional throughout portions of the closing, at one point wiping her eyes with a tissue, as Reddington closed with the central argument of the defense case: “This young lady is not guilty of the killing of her young children because she was suffering from a disease and defect.” After more than five weeks of testimony, the case is now in its final stage as jurors prepare to determine whether Clancy should be held criminally responsible.
_______________
ABOUT
Criminally Obsessed is first on the scene, uniting fellow armchair detectives in their quest to crack the case.
FOLLOW
Instagram: instagram.com/criminallyobsessed
Facebook: facebook.com/CrmnllyObsessed
TikTok: tiktok.com/@crmnallyobsessed
X: twitter.com/crmnllyobsessed
SUBSCRIBE
youtube.com/@CriminallyObsessed?sub_confirmation=1
MERCH STORE
criminallyobsessed.promoshopestores.com
