That’s Why I’m Always Suspicious Of People Who Tell Me It’s All Just In Your Own Consciousness. @TheMeditatingPhilosopher
That’s Why I’m Always Suspicious Of People Who Tell Me It’s All Just In Your Own Consciousness.  @TheMeditatingPhilosopher
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
How much solitude does a person need to grow, and how much connection do we need to flourish? In this Q&A, John Vervaeke takes a question about finding the right balance between isolation and contact, and answers by drawing on a long intellectual lineage.

John begins with the triangle of Jung, Tillich, and Buber. Jung emphasizes individuation, Buber emphasizes participation, and their famous debate left both sides with legitimate criticisms. Behind them stands Tillich, who argued that human beings are constantly pulled between these two poles.

John’s answer comes from Plato. Cultivating internal justice, getting the parts of the psyche to cooperate, and participating as deeply as possible in the real patterns of reality may pull us in different directions, but they are not independent. Neglect the inner work and internal conflict distorts how we see the world, leading to projection and reciprocal narrowing. Neglect the outer work and we fall prey to egocentrism, my-side bias, and confirmation bias, which a purely internal project can’t correct.

The solution is to cycle between the two. John argues that the Neoplatonists mastered this through dialectic, a meta-psychotechnology that aligns the vertical (within oneself and across levels of reality) with the horizontal (genuine dialogue with another person who represents otherness). Together they produce anagoge, a mutual reinforcement of individuation and participation.

John then connects this to the emerging dialogical groups he studies through participant observation, and proposes the Neoplatonic balance as a justified metric for evaluating how well these groups afford real flourishing.

ABOUT JOHN VERVAEKE

John Vervaeke is a cognitive scientist and professor at the University of Toronto, known for his lecture series Awakening from the Meaning Crisis and his work on relevance realization, wisdom, consciousness, and the cognitive science of spirituality.

His research explores how human beings cultivate meaning, insight, wisdom, and transformative relationships with reality.

WATCH THE FULL Q&A

The entire Q&A video can be found here:
youtu.be/QJGhI07ANgY

KEYWORDS

#JohnVervaeke #CarlJung #MartinBuber #Neoplatonism #Philosophy #HumanFlourishing #Psychology #Individuation #Dialectic #Wisdom #CognitiveScience #Solitude

Thanks!
That’s Why I’m Always Suspicious Of People Who Tell Me It’s All Just In Your Own Consciousness.Beside After Socrates #5: On Episode 9 - Layman Pascal & Bruce Alderman | B4M #42After Socrates Ecology of Practices : Imaginal Engagement & Enaction | Episode 1Embodiment - Polyvagal Theory & Simple Exercises on Freeze, Fight, Flight, & Fun | Roger JacksonPeaceful Centering Body Scan Meditation | Guided Meditation Practice with Dr. Rick RepettiAfter Socrates Ecology of Practices : Being with You I Notice | Episode 10Processes, Imagination, and Our Lives - Dr. Matt Segall | B4M #41I, Me, Inner Congress & Consciousness:: Imaginal Insights #5 w/ John Vervaeke & Paul VanderklayAll Meditation Practice Notes :: PDF :: John Vervaekes Meditation CourseHow can Technology Impact Education Positively?::  One Question with John Vervaeke  (Q&A Rewind)A New Unified Theory of Psychology Handbook | Dr. Gregg Henriques | B4M #25Beside After Socrates #12: On Episode 20-22 - Layman Pascal & Bruce Alderman | B4M #49
The Meditating Philosopher |

"That’s Why I’m Always Suspicious Of People Who Tell Me 'It’s All Just In Your Own Consciousness'."

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER