Uploaded May 2017 | Updated November 2026, 7 hours ago
We tried a lot of methods before to somehow show Mn(III) which is green, purple, red, depending on the situation but mostly associated with a red color for the [Mn(H2O)6](3-) complex. Neither were we able to make it from a mixed oxide, from the Dioxide nor through other routes.
One suggestion was to react Potassium Bromate, Mn(II) and H2SO4 which is what we did here. It produces a lot of Bromnie vapour. The Aluminium plates are still covered with rests of Iodides which is why the surface immediatly turns dark when the Bromine forms.
After we added some water it looked dark red for a second before turning orange. Warm temperatures and dilution are said to cause the formation of Mn(IV) and this is probably the product at the end of the video but inbetween, although the cam didn't fully pick it up, we are sure to have seen a red hue.
I guess this is up to you. Perhaps you know a better way. We only wanted to talk a bit about Mn(III) now:
So Mn(III) isn't very stable and will undergo fast disproportionation to Mn(II) and Mn(IV). The reaction is accelerated by water, so dilution, because it can act on the water as oxidizing agent, so one might construct 2 redox reactions:
2 Mn(III) + 6 H2O to Mn(II) + MnO2 + 4 H3O(+)
and
2 Mn(III) + 3 H2O to 2 Mn(II) + 2 H3O(+) + 0.5 O2
According to the principle of Le Chatelier and the fact that we use an excess of oxidizer (Bromate/H2SO4) it becomes clear why the Mn(III) is stable until we add water.
As said depending on the situation one might observe different colors. If together with Phosphates or Borates Mn(III) turns purple, which is what you do if you test samples with Borax for example. The hexaqua complex is deep red. This is due to a d4 configuration im comparison to the Mn(II) d5. So the transition is not spin forbidden anymore and it becomes all colorful.
Whenever we talk about d4 configuations in octahedra we also have to remember the famous Jahn-Teller effect. Usually people always think about Copper and d9 systems when they talk about Jahn-Teller distortions but d4 has the same effect which might add a bit to the intensity of the compound.
Usually all octahedral Mn(III) complexes are in a high-spin configuration. There is one famous exception and we already showed you this, the yellow [Mn(CN)6](3-). Using ligands like these it is possible to stabilize the Mn(III) quite long. Since we published the video we kept that yellow sample in a vial where the lid usually is not as airtight so it had plenty of oxygen to react with but still does not show any formation of MnO2 or any color change at all.
There are other ligands like EDTA which also stabilize the oxidation state quite well.
We tried a lot of methods before to somehow show Mn(III) which is green, purple, red, depending on the situation but mostly associated with a red color for the [Mn(H2O)6](3-) complex. Neither were we able to make it from a mixed oxide, from the Dioxide nor through other routes.
One suggestion was to react Potassium Bromate, Mn(II) and H2SO4 which is what we did here. It produces a lot of Bromnie vapour. The Aluminium plates are still covered with rests of Iodides which is why the surface immediatly turns dark when the Bromine forms.
After we added some water it looked dark red for a second before turning orange. Warm temperatures and dilution are said to cause the formation of Mn(IV) and this is probably the product at the end of the video but inbetween, although the cam didn't fully pick it up, we are sure to have seen a red hue.
I guess this is up to you. Perhaps you know a better way. We only wanted to talk a bit about Mn(III) now:
So Mn(III) isn't very stable and will undergo fast disproportionation to Mn(II) and Mn(IV). The reaction is accelerated by water, so dilution, because it can act on the water as oxidizing agent, so one might construct 2 redox reactions:
2 Mn(III) + 6 H2O to Mn(II) + MnO2 + 4 H3O(+)
and
2 Mn(III) + 3 H2O to 2 Mn(II) + 2 H3O(+) + 0.5 O2
According to the principle of Le Chatelier and the fact that we use an excess of oxidizer (Bromate/H2SO4) it becomes clear why the Mn(III) is stable until we add water.
As said depending on the situation one might observe different colors. If together with Phosphates or Borates Mn(III) turns purple, which is what you do if you test samples with Borax for example. The hexaqua complex is deep red. This is due to a d4 configuration im comparison to the Mn(II) d5. So the transition is not spin forbidden anymore and it becomes all colorful.
Whenever we talk about d4 configuations in octahedra we also have to remember the famous Jahn-Teller effect. Usually people always think about Copper and d9 systems when they talk about Jahn-Teller distortions but d4 has the same effect which might add a bit to the intensity of the compound.
Usually all octahedral Mn(III) complexes are in a high-spin configuration. There is one famous exception and we already showed you this, the yellow [Mn(CN)6](3-). Using ligands like these it is possible to stabilize the Mn(III) quite long. Since we published the video we kept that yellow sample in a vial where the lid usually is not as airtight so it had plenty of oxygen to react with but still does not show any formation of MnO2 or any color change at all.
There are other ligands like EDTA which also stabilize the oxidation state quite well.
 complex.
This experiment shows how the Ag - I bond is way stronger than the Ag - Cl bond. Again HSAB concept can be applied.
Silver is positively charged but quite big. Therefore it is considered to be a soft acid. A soft acid and soft base form a strong bond. For Chloride and Iodide, the Iodide is bigger with the same charge so softer than the Chloride, making a Ag - I bond more stabile than a Ag - Cl bond. This is why Ammonia cant substitute it. Silver Chemistry: Silveriodide and Ammonia (?)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ehzyvmf-Jwg/mqdefault.jpg)

![Thermochromism: Silver(I)Iodide
We already showed you how HgI2 is thermochromic. But HgI2 is nothing you may be able to obtain, so we show you an interesting alternative, this time using AgI, which can be easily prepared from any soluble silver salt and an Iodide.
That AgI is thermochromic, too is something you rarely hear about, but as you can see it can be reversibly heated, much like HgI2, and also the mechanism somehow reminds us of how the Iodomercurates behaved.
AgI forms a Wurtzite lattice. M2[HgI4] had a zinc-blende lattice. The two are basically the same, the Wurzite is just the hexagonal form of the cubic zinc-blende, which means, that it has a different stacking. Again only 50% of the tetrahedral sites are occupied by Ag(+). Once the temperature is raised the Ag(+) becomes more and agile and occupies different sites, which causes a red-shift in the Ligand-to-Metal Charge-Transfer. In this process, the conductivity also increases.
Now we will not further focus on that here, Silver is something special when its about moving Ag(+)-Ions in lattices. So called Frenkel defects in Silver compounds often contribute to a high conductivity once silver salts are used. The reason why Silver is so mobile here is that Silver can come quite close to itself. This is called Argentophilia, Silver likes itself so much, that short Ag-Ag distances are no problem, so once you give the silver the possibility to move it will occupy new sites, which also shifts the color.
What we show here is only using about 250°C. We also tried heating it with a bunsen burner and at some point it would even turn dark red. Thermochromism: Silver(I)Iodide](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hbXQSdtNJ_0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Mercury Chemistry: Mercury(I)chromate
In this video, well be making Mercury(I)chromate Hg2[CrO4]. It forms quite readily when K2[CrO4] and Hg2Cl2 are heated in solution. In the end, you can see the brown color of the product. Mercury Chemistry: Mercury(I)chromate](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hfwg9DFXA40/mqdefault.jpg)
 we showed in another video. If the ligand stabilizes the lower oxidation state better and is soluble after complexation some aqueous Cu(I) chemistry is possible. Same goes for low Cu(I) conc.
On the other hand there are a lot of insoluble stable copper(I) compounds like the Oxide or the Sulfide as well as all the halogenides and pseudohalogenides. Copper(I)Oxide is the thing you see when you look at copper metal. If you polish copper metal really well you will be able to see coppers true color. If left at the air it will oxidize again forming a thin layer of red Cu(I)Oxide. This is compound is also seen as product of the famous Fehling Reaction which turns red due to the formation of Cu(I)Oxide.
This is where most books and texts end on the chemistry of Cu(I) but as we have some space here we would like to share some extra information since the reaction in the video doesnt require a lot of information (we had a lot of redox-chemistry already).
Another way to make Cu(I) which will be shown in a future video is the synproportionation at elevated temperatures of Cu(0) and Cu(II). If this is carried out in HCl a soluble complex forms:
H[CuCl2] where Cu(I) is linear coordinated. (Copper(I) has a lot of linear, trigonal and tetrahedral coordinations while Copper(II) almost always has octahedra ).
If water is added HCl and CuCl form. CuCl can be dissolved in HCl again forming H[CuCl2] but also in Ammonia to form [Cu(NH3)2]Cl or if more Ammonia is added also [Cu(NH3)4]Cl where copper(I) is now tetrahedrally coordinated.
This last compound has some interesting applications as it absorbs Carbonmonoxide and could theoretically be used as a CO filter. [Cu(NH3)4]Cl will react with water and CO to form
[Cu(CO)(H2O)2Cl](-). If instead of CO O2 is used so the compound left to oxidize on air it will turn blue under the formation [Cu(NH3)4](2-) which we featured in another video already. Copper Chemistry: Copper(I) Chloride](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hn5dEzs8s58/mqdefault.jpg)


For a full explanation see the video on [CuCl4](2-).
As an excess of Potassium Bromide is added to a copper sulfate solution the red [CuBr4](2-) is formed. Copper Chemistry: [CuBr4](2-)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/iIAy9dr_V6A/mqdefault.jpg)



![Thallium Chemistry: Ferrocyanide and Chromate in comparison
A yellow (hard to see on camera) Potassium Ferrocyanide solution (left) and a very dilute yellow Potassium Chromate solution (right) are prepared. Some drops of a Thallium(I) Nitrate solution are added to both of them.
Although both compounds are yellow for Potassium and the other Alkali metals (Thallium(I) can under certain circumstances be treated as an alkali metal-ion) the Ferrocyanide one is white.
We discovered this effect when we tried to prepare a bunch of Thallium compounds. It appears that many Ferrocyanides especially with d-Metals as counterions show completely different colors.
We are still not sure how exactly the counterion takes part in the coloration of complexes and will discuss this in a further video on Ferrocyanides. One idea is, as we visualized some structure data for Tl4[Fe(CN)6] that the Tl has trigonal prismatic and octahedral coordination (N-coordinated by the Cyanides backside).
So this has either to do with the Lewis-Acidity (electrophilic) of the counterion, pulling some of the ligands electron density away from the coordinated metal (Fe) thereby lowering the ligand field splitting and causing a red-shift.
Or for d-Metals as counterions (we checked their crystal structure as well) there are octahedra (N-coordinated) around the counterions as well. So we might have a second ligand field splitting here causing a mix of two colors.
We will try to find out more about the actual mechanism of this (hopefully) soon.
Still we found this effect quite interesting, as Thallium compounds usually are not colored (much like Alkali Metals or Silver) and the color here comes from the Chromate and Ferrocyanide that the products although the complex part has the same color end up in different colors. Thallium Chemistry: Ferrocyanide and Chromate in comparison](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jQVU1c7zH34/mqdefault.jpg)