How (not) to Argue Against Meritocracy @UCLLaws
How (not) to Argue Against Meritocracy  @UCLLaws
Uploaded May 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
A talk in the John Austin Seminar Series

Speaker: Lars Vinx, Professor of Jurisprudence (Cambridge)
Chair: George Letsas, Professor of Philosophy of Law (UCL Laws)

About the Seminar:

The ideal of meritocracy has recently come under considerable pressure in political theory. Critics of meritocracy like Michael Sandel and Daniel Markovits argue not merely that existing societies fail to live up to meritocratic standards. Like the sociologist Michael Young, who coined the term ‘meritocracy’ in the late 1950’s, Markovits and Sandel claim that a society that perfectly realizes the ideal of meritocracy would be a deeply unjust dystopia.

This paper argues that the ideal of meritocracy, however, can be understood in different ways. It distinguishes the different strands of meritocratic thinking and evaluates them separately so as to build a concept of meritocracy that is not vulnerable to the critical challenges which have been levelled against the meritocratic ideal.
How (not) to Argue Against MeritocracyNo Mediation Privilege as yet. Why not?Reframing Complete Abortion Decriminalisation as a Public Law Question: A Transnational InquiryCan Human Rights and International Law Prevail?LAWS0296: Economic Analysis of Law: Corporations and MarketsAccessibility and the Limits of UK Equality Law: Time for a UK Accessibility Act?Reforming Article 102 TFEU: A European Social Contract Approach?Law and the Political Economy of Climate AdaptationThe Public ConstitutionThe Future of the ECHR - In Europe and UK‘Can Law Stop Criminals Misusing AI?’ – UCL Master of Laws (LLM) online open eventTrust, Judicial Independence and Judicial Power
UCL Laws |

How (not) to Argue Against Meritocracy

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER