EU Citizenship After Commission v Malta: Liberalism v Solidarity? @UCLLaws
EU Citizenship After Commission v Malta: Liberalism v Solidarity?  @UCLLaws
Uploaded June 2025 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
On Wednesday 4 June 2025 a panel of leading experts came together at UCL Faculty of Laws (Bentham House) to debate the EU citizenship law after the groundbreaking CJEU judgment of European Commission v Malta.

About the discussion
The recent judgment of the Court of Justice of the EU in Commission v Malta has generated plenty of controversy. The Court held that Malta’s investor citizenship scheme, which granted Maltese nationality in exchange for investment, was contrary to EU law - ruling that it was incompatible with the 'special relationship of solidarity and good faith' between Member States and their nationals that should form the basis of EU citizenship. The Court's reasoning has been attacked for overextending the scope of EU law - and for requiring an overly 'thick' and potentially exclusionary bond to exist between citizens and a state. Others have defended the Court's approach, precisely because of the importance it places on such bonds of 'solidarity'. A panel of leading experts will discuss these issues in depth.

The Speakers:
- Dr Lior Erez, University of Oxford
- Dr Sarah Ganty, UCLouvain/Yale
- Dr Oliver Gerstenberg, UCL Faculty of Laws
- Prof Dimitry Kochenov, Central European University
- Dr Madeleine Sumption, University of Oxford

Chair: Dr Claudia Sternberg (UCL European Institute)
EU Citizenship After Commission v Malta: Liberalism v Solidarity?Patent Law – Fit for an (emotional) AI age?: CIIs, Training ANNs and other storiesThe Culpable Wrongness Constraint Has Teeth in PracticeTrade Marks and the Green EconomyUCL Virtual Open Session 2026 - Studying LLB Law at UCLAncient Greek law as a lens on legal theory: of promulgation & purposeThe Fragile Power of Political Nations: Adam Smith’s FederativeUCL200 at UCL LawsThe ‘Inconspicuous Impact’ of Feminist Pressure Through LawCommon Law Conceptions of Democracy in the United KingdomSOTUS event: Safeguarding Knowledge: When Memory Becomes PoliticalState Silence Across International Law: Meaning, Context and Developments
UCL Laws |

EU Citizenship After Commission v Malta: Liberalism v Solidarity?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER