Uploaded November 2024 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
Topos Institute Colloquium, 14th of November 2024.
———
The Applicability Problem is the problem of explaining why mathematics is applicable to the empirical sciences. This problem is revived and reformulated by the physicist Eugene Wigner under the striking title "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences". In this influential work, Wigner argues that the applicability of mathematics is a miracle, "a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve". Responses to this problem range from metaphysical claims about the mathematical structure of the universe to epistemic claims about the nature of human cognition, as well as formalist views that characterize mathematics as a type of game.
In my view, to find an explanation for this relationship, we must first understand the explanandum itself. More fundamental than the why-question (why is mathematics applicable in the natural sciences) is the how-question (how is mathematics applicable in the natural sciences). By examining how mathematics has been used across different eras and fields within the natural sciences, we can begin to understand the relationship between mathematics and the sciences. More importantly, this exploration allows us to address questions regarding the nature of mathematics as it is used and practiced. By distinguishing pseudo-problems from the genuine problems of applicability, we open new paths for philosophical reflections on the nature of mathematics and the sciences.
Topos Institute Colloquium, 14th of November 2024.
———
The Applicability Problem is the problem of explaining why mathematics is applicable to the empirical sciences. This problem is revived and reformulated by the physicist Eugene Wigner under the striking title "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences". In this influential work, Wigner argues that the applicability of mathematics is a miracle, "a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve". Responses to this problem range from metaphysical claims about the mathematical structure of the universe to epistemic claims about the nature of human cognition, as well as formalist views that characterize mathematics as a type of game.
In my view, to find an explanation for this relationship, we must first understand the explanandum itself. More fundamental than the why-question (why is mathematics applicable in the natural sciences) is the how-question (how is mathematics applicable in the natural sciences). By examining how mathematics has been used across different eras and fields within the natural sciences, we can begin to understand the relationship between mathematics and the sciences. More importantly, this exploration allows us to address questions regarding the nature of mathematics as it is used and practiced. By distinguishing pseudo-problems from the genuine problems of applicability, we open new paths for philosophical reflections on the nature of mathematics and the sciences.

![[TopOx] Jakub Opršal: Homotopy theory in the complexity of homomorphism problems
27th of November 2025. Slides available at https://topos.institute/events/topox/
I will talk about an emerging connection between homotopy theory and computational complexity of discrete problems. I will outline a theorem stating that contractibility is necessary for tractability (assumin P ≠ NP) in the realm of finite-template constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs).
There are many ways the CSP can be formulated. One of them is as a homomorphism problem: given two relational structures A and B, decide whether there is a homomorphism from A to B. We usually study a restricted version of this problem where B is fixed, e.g., if B is the k-clique graph K_k, the problem is the same as k-colouring of a given graph A. If B is finite (and of finite signature), such a problem is called finite-template. Famously, finite-template CSPs exhibit a P vs NP-complete dichotomy as proved independently by Bulatov and Zhuk in 2017.
The main theorem of the talk states a sufficient condition for NP-completeness in terms of the topology of ‘solution spaces’ and provides both all necessary hardness for the Bulatov–Zhuk dichotomy and also a new proof of an earlier Hell–Nešetřil dichotomy of graph homomorphism problems. [TopOx] Jakub Opršal: Homotopy theory in the complexity of homomorphism problems](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/fU2pZbrE2aA/mqdefault.jpg)

![[Oxford Seminar] Khyathi Komalan | Adult Brainrot: Mandela Effect, Misinformation & Conspiracies
Oxford Seminar, 25th of September 2025
Abstract: The internet is a strange place — one moment youre
convinced the Starbucks logo never had a star on top, the next youre
knee-deep in a rumor that spreads everywhere at once, and before long
youre staring at a series of pictures that prove the moon landing
was fake. These phenomena may look like pure nonsense, but they also
show how perception, memory, and belief are shaped by our
experiences, the hidden biases behind what we perceive, and the
difficulty of stitching multiple pieces of information, sometimes
conflicting, into a coherent story that fits the most into ones
worldview.
In this talk I introduce adult brainrot as a categorical framework
for these inconsistencies. I will show how categorical models of
quantum processes can capture order-sensitive memory and
indistinguishable sources of misinformation, and how categorical
notions of centers help explain why people’s theories sometimes fail
to form a consistent picture of reality. The aim is to argue that
quantum categorical structures offer a natural mathematical framework
for modeling the inconsistencies and oddities of human perception and
belief. [Oxford Seminar] Khyathi Komalan | Adult Brainrot: Mandela Effect, Misinformation & Conspiracies](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/gk0jJtjNQGI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2-torial] Quantum information theory, Part 4: Quantum bird watching (continued)
2-torial, May 20 2026
You can find accompanying notes and other information on this video at https://topos.institute/work/lectures/2-torials/2026-05-20_hosgood_quantum/
Tutor: Tim Hosgood
Tutee: Jason Brown
The elements of quantum information theory are not so complicated: some linear algebra over the complex numbers and a bit of classical probability theory. But it doesnt take long before you run into some intriguing problems that showcase how established experimental results contradict our classical intuition. In this 2-torial we will learn the very basics of quantum theory, see how a Mach–Zehnder interferometer gives a real-world implementation of a classically impossible construction and suggests that we should go all in on complex numbers, and finally how this all applies to the world of theoretical bird watching via the Quantum Zeno effect. [2-torial] Quantum information theory, Part 4: Quantum bird watching (continued)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/gl2Ni8ksGsc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Oxford Seminar] José Siqueira | Double functorial representation of indexed monoidal structures
Oxford Seminar, 12th of June 2025
The data of a logical doctrine acts in two directions: that of the *substitution* operation, and that of *quantification*. Double Category Theory provides the tools to capture these two actions and their relationship concomitantly: in a double category of spans, re-indexing and acting on predicates can be packaged as tight and loose arrows respectively, and in there tight arrows always have conjoints. By mapping these conjoints into a double category of quintets, we obtain adjunctions internal to a 2-category. Moreover, by using the notion of adequate triple, the indexing category need only have certain pullbacks.
Adding a monoidal structure to the fibers (and the double pseudofunctor) allows us to capture both the Beck-Chevalley and Frobenius conditions. We will concern ourselves with the monoidal analogues of regular hyperdoctrines and similar structures (where the objects of predicates are not necessarily posets, but rather live in some 2-category), and show how they are equivalent to (lax symmetric monoidal) double pseudofunctors between spans and quintet double categories. [Oxford Seminar] José Siqueira | Double functorial representation of indexed monoidal structures](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/glQUcRImOkw/mqdefault.jpg)


![[Berkeley Seminar] Khyathi Komalan (Topos Institute) | Organising Compositionality in Mechanics
Title: Organising Compositionality in Classical Mechanics
Abstract: Consider a scenario where we give two people each two springs and ask them to build something with them. There is no reason to believe that the resulting systems would be the same — one may choose to make the springs share a common mass, while another may decide to leave them separate. While the components remain the same, the resulting system does not. Mathematically, where exactly should the choice of how to put things together live?
Baez, Weisbart and Yassine think about this by modelling open classical systems as augmented spans and composing compatible systems using pullbacks. Their construction keeps track of Lagrangian and Hamiltonian descriptions of mechanics — the former using positions and velocities, the latter positions and momenta — but doing so requires a fair amount of machinery, including separate Riemannian and Poisson settings and a generalized F-pullback construction. I’ll reorganise this picture by working with smooth spaces carrying closed 2-forms, where ordinary pullbacks are available. These 2-forms encode the geometry of position–momentum phase space, and our systems are required to respect that geometry. For the spring examples, differentiating the potential picks out a half-dimensional subspace on which the 2-form vanishes — called a Lagrangian submanifold. The resulting span theory then keeps the systems themselves separate from the ways of assembling them. So we can fix two springs once and vary only the instruction for how they should be combined.
Most of the talk will involve seeing this in action through examples involving springs. Tensoring two spring systems simply places them side by side, without yet deciding how they are connected. That extra choice lives in a loose span, whose action by pullback performs the assembly. Changing the span while keeping the springs fixed can therefore produce different mechanical systems. We’ll work this out explicitly for two springs sharing a mass, and end by asking whether the same mechanism can also compose Hamiltonian evolution through time.
Date: 8/25/26 [Berkeley Seminar] Khyathi Komalan (Topos Institute) | Organising Compositionality in Mechanics](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ibb_7VEOVjw/mqdefault.jpg)

