Uploaded August 2024 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
This is the fourth of eight videos on the "best interest of the child" in family law.
On Monday, August 26, 2024, the Texas Juvenile Justice and Family Issues Committee heard an interim charge on "the best interest of the child" in family law. Invited testimony included a former district judge and family law attorney, as well as an individual from the Texas Public Policy Foundation. It appears a future subsequent hearing on the topic will be held for the public to testify on the topic.
In this fourth video, Chairman Harold Dutton asks if defining "the best interest of the child" will help or hurt the situation. Andrew Brown argues that having at least a minimal definition will help bring about some kind of predictability and consistency in family law, whereas former family law attorney and Judge Judy Warne muddies the waters and says it won't make a difference. Judge Judy Warne just trusts judges to know what the best interest of the child is and to get it right.
Currently, there is no definition of what the best interest of the child means, in part because no one knows what the best interest of any child actually is. Anyone who has been through family court understands that the best interest is argued or advocated for by people who barely know and may never even have met the child. A judge's determination of the "best interest of the child" ranges from incomplete to faulty to biased to retaliatory and punitive. What is worse is that a judge's ruling will about a "best interest" determination can never be challenged, and judges have immunity even if they make a horrible decision.
This is the fourth of eight videos on the "best interest of the child" in family law.
On Monday, August 26, 2024, the Texas Juvenile Justice and Family Issues Committee heard an interim charge on "the best interest of the child" in family law. Invited testimony included a former district judge and family law attorney, as well as an individual from the Texas Public Policy Foundation. It appears a future subsequent hearing on the topic will be held for the public to testify on the topic.
In this fourth video, Chairman Harold Dutton asks if defining "the best interest of the child" will help or hurt the situation. Andrew Brown argues that having at least a minimal definition will help bring about some kind of predictability and consistency in family law, whereas former family law attorney and Judge Judy Warne muddies the waters and says it won't make a difference. Judge Judy Warne just trusts judges to know what the best interest of the child is and to get it right.
Currently, there is no definition of what the best interest of the child means, in part because no one knows what the best interest of any child actually is. Anyone who has been through family court understands that the best interest is argued or advocated for by people who barely know and may never even have met the child. A judge's determination of the "best interest of the child" ranges from incomplete to faulty to biased to retaliatory and punitive. What is worse is that a judge's ruling will about a "best interest" determination can never be challenged, and judges have immunity even if they make a horrible decision.










