Uploaded October 2024 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
Dr. Phil testified before the Texas House Committee on Criminal Justice.
In this segment, Dr. Phil was asked whether the Robert Roberson death-penalty case that the committee was asking questions about was really not a "shaken baby" case, but an "ineffective-assistance-of-counsel" case. In his response, Dr. Phil mentioned that a lot of people in prison were among the minority and lower socioeconomic class. Rich people don't get the death penalty because they can afford better lawyers - they can "afford" more justice. And when it comes to the death penalty, which he believes in, you should not sentence someone to death because of ineffective assistance of counsel.
The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees a criminal defendant the right to effective assistance of counsel - yet often the justice you receive depends on the effectiveness of your counsel, which depends on how much money you have to spend. Even in cases in which money does not seem to be an issue, some attorneys still provide ineffective assistance of counsel out of laziness, incompetence, or declining mental faculties.
I've been personally involved as a witness in an ineffective-assistance-of-counsel case that led to a person getting sentenced to 12 years in prison and losing her ability to practice as a nurse practitioner. I knew her attorney, who was in his 70's and appeared to be suffering from dementia. When I and others were called as witnesses, we all shocked and complained at how ineffective he was as her counsel. He didn't ask effective questions; he didn't cross-examine well; and he didn't vigorously object to questions by the prosecutors. He simply wasn't altogether there. He was relying on his friendship with the judge instead of aggressively defending her. When his client was found guilty and sentenced to 12 years in prison, he blamed the reason for his failure to a well-spoken witness from the other side and to the jury.
Though he may have been good at one point in his career, I believe he was suffering some dementia. If not, he had definitely slipped - dramatically - from his peak. I thought that I as a non-attorney could have done a better job than he did. I believed he stopped practicing as an attorney after losing this case. In a follow-up ineffective-assistance-of-counsel hearing, I was willing to testify to that end, but I was not called as a witness.
The local district attorney and those under her had put a notch on their belt through their successful prosecution of the case. They slander the individual to the public to make themselves look better. Their ill-gotten reputation of being no-nonsense aggressive prosecutors increased not because they executed justice, but because they imposed an outrageous sentence on a professional, hard-working, compassionate, attractive white lady. The prosecutors spread were willing to inflict injustice and ruin a person's life to increase their reputations. I had already lost all confidence in the so-called "family" courts, but after this charade, I lost confidence in the criminal courts as well.
I mentioned this case to Representative Leach a two to three years ago. He gave me his cell phone number, but when I attempted to contact him multiple times about this matter a few years ago, he didn't respond to me. When I later testified against one of his bills that he proposed, he got mad at me, so it I think it is unlikely that he will be of any help - so the lady remains in prison 4 years later.
I was encouraged to see Representative Brian Harrison question the judicial practices and imposition of a death sentence based on "junk science" and the district attorney's lack of knowledge of this case, even though she had signed Roberson's scheduled death penalty execution date. I am in contact with his office and will be contacting him further after the elections in a few weeks.
Dr. Phil testified before the Texas House Committee on Criminal Justice.
In this segment, Dr. Phil was asked whether the Robert Roberson death-penalty case that the committee was asking questions about was really not a "shaken baby" case, but an "ineffective-assistance-of-counsel" case. In his response, Dr. Phil mentioned that a lot of people in prison were among the minority and lower socioeconomic class. Rich people don't get the death penalty because they can afford better lawyers - they can "afford" more justice. And when it comes to the death penalty, which he believes in, you should not sentence someone to death because of ineffective assistance of counsel.
The Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees a criminal defendant the right to effective assistance of counsel - yet often the justice you receive depends on the effectiveness of your counsel, which depends on how much money you have to spend. Even in cases in which money does not seem to be an issue, some attorneys still provide ineffective assistance of counsel out of laziness, incompetence, or declining mental faculties.
I've been personally involved as a witness in an ineffective-assistance-of-counsel case that led to a person getting sentenced to 12 years in prison and losing her ability to practice as a nurse practitioner. I knew her attorney, who was in his 70's and appeared to be suffering from dementia. When I and others were called as witnesses, we all shocked and complained at how ineffective he was as her counsel. He didn't ask effective questions; he didn't cross-examine well; and he didn't vigorously object to questions by the prosecutors. He simply wasn't altogether there. He was relying on his friendship with the judge instead of aggressively defending her. When his client was found guilty and sentenced to 12 years in prison, he blamed the reason for his failure to a well-spoken witness from the other side and to the jury.
Though he may have been good at one point in his career, I believe he was suffering some dementia. If not, he had definitely slipped - dramatically - from his peak. I thought that I as a non-attorney could have done a better job than he did. I believed he stopped practicing as an attorney after losing this case. In a follow-up ineffective-assistance-of-counsel hearing, I was willing to testify to that end, but I was not called as a witness.
The local district attorney and those under her had put a notch on their belt through their successful prosecution of the case. They slander the individual to the public to make themselves look better. Their ill-gotten reputation of being no-nonsense aggressive prosecutors increased not because they executed justice, but because they imposed an outrageous sentence on a professional, hard-working, compassionate, attractive white lady. The prosecutors spread were willing to inflict injustice and ruin a person's life to increase their reputations. I had already lost all confidence in the so-called "family" courts, but after this charade, I lost confidence in the criminal courts as well.
I mentioned this case to Representative Leach a two to three years ago. He gave me his cell phone number, but when I attempted to contact him multiple times about this matter a few years ago, he didn't respond to me. When I later testified against one of his bills that he proposed, he got mad at me, so it I think it is unlikely that he will be of any help - so the lady remains in prison 4 years later.
I was encouraged to see Representative Brian Harrison question the judicial practices and imposition of a death sentence based on "junk science" and the district attorney's lack of knowledge of this case, even though she had signed Roberson's scheduled death penalty execution date. I am in contact with his office and will be contacting him further after the elections in a few weeks.