Why Going All In on Spiritual Disciplines Is β€œDoomed to Fail” @HolyPostMedia
Why Going All In on Spiritual Disciplines Is β€œDoomed to Fail”  @HolyPostMedia
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Skye Jethani asks author and pastor John Mark Comer why so much of the American church is reluctant to deal with the problem of noise, even as the wider culture admits it has one. John Mark tells a story about a group of evangelicals who turned a silent monastery retreat into a dinner party, and explains why he sees the Western church adopting the noise of the modern world without question. Skye adds that much of evangelicalism has abandoned its prophetic role. Then, for people who don't have years of Christian formation, John Mark explains why going all in on spiritual disciplines is doomed to fail, why he almost cut his 21-day silent retreat story from the book, and how to start small with an alarm clock, your phone in another room, and one Psalm. He also describes how his church uses Sunday gatherings as training grounds for silence.

Mentioned in this Clip:
"Into the Quiet: Following Jesus in a World of Noise" by John Mark Comer: amzn.to/3VOepF6

πŸ’¬ Does your church make any room for silence on Sundays? Share with us in the comments.

Watch the full episode here πŸ‘‰youtu.be/tP7f1yf3b6w

0:00 – Why Churches Embrace the Noise
0:39 – The Silent Monastery Dinner Party
2:53 – Uncritical Adoption of Noise
3:06 – Evangelicalism's Lost Prophetic Role
3:31 – Silence Without Years of Formation
4:55 – Start Small, Start Where You Are
5:08 – First Day of Lent Syndrome
5:41 – The 21-Day Silent Retreat Problem
6:01 – Alarm Clock, Phone, and One Psalm
6:39 – Sunday Gatherings as Silence Training

Resources and Links:
⭐ Join Holy Post Plus for bonus content, extended interviews, and much more! Sign up today at holypost.com/plus
🧑 Support us on Patreon: patreon.com/holypost
πŸ“° Join the Holy Post Substack: holypost.substack.com
🌐 Holy Post Website: holypost.com
πŸ‘• Holy Post Merch Store: holypost.com/shop

The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

πŸ”” Like & subscribe for more conversations on faith, culture, politics, and more!

Follow & Connect with Holy Post:
Instagram: instagram.com/holypostpod
TikTok: tiktok.com/@holypostmedia
X / Twitter: https://x.com/holypostpod
Facebook: facebook.com/holypostpod

#JohnMarkComer #IntoTheQuiet #Silence #SpiritualFormation #Church #HolyPostPodcast #HolyPostMedia #HPM
Why Going All In on Spiritual Disciplines Is β€œDoomed to Fail”The Rights New Argument Against Empathy | Alison Cook | Ep 740Outraged Over a Lion, Silent on ScripturePhones Aren’t the Only Reason We Avoid Silence | John Mark Comer545: What Story is the Bible Telling?  with Timothy GombisJesus, Paul, and the Law: Friends or Foes?Why Tech Billionaires Abandoned Local PhilanthropyPART 2 A Pumpkin Spice Skeptic Admits It’s Actually Good πŸ‘All 4 Holy Post Hosts Debate Evangelicalism | Ep. 739Why Elon Musk’s Election Spending Is a Christian Issue | Sharon MillerFaithful Christians Disagree About GLP-1sThe β€œAnti-Empathy” Movement Is Really About Political Tribalism
Holy Post Media |

Why Going All In on Spiritual Disciplines Is β€œDoomed to Fail”

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER