The Rights New Argument Against Empathy | Alison Cook | Ep 740 @HolyPostMedia
The Rights New Argument Against Empathy | Alison Cook | Ep 740  @HolyPostMedia
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
This week, Phil, Kaitlyn, and Mike Erre dig into the growing "anti-empathy" movement taking hold on the right, from Allie Beth Stuckey's Toxic Empathy to a book literally titled Suicidal Empathy, and ask whether declaring empathy dangerous is really about protecting Western civilization, or just clearing the way to ignore people's suffering. Then Kaitlyn sits down one-on-one with therapist and author Alison Cook to talk about her new book The Secure Soul, attachment theory, and why no human relationship, however good, can fully know you the way God does. And yes, there's also a segment about mercury, Lewis and Clark, and 19th-century laxatives.

Holy Post Plus:
Ad-Free Version of this Episode - holypost.substack.com/publish/post/218066312?r=35kf51&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web

πŸ’¬ Kaitlyn argues that good political decisions come less from having all the right ideas figured out and more from being in real community with people whose experiences differ from your own, a teacher, a doctor, a neighbor who's navigated something you haven't. Who plays that role in your life? Let us know in the comments.

Watch Kaitlyn's interview with Matthew Loftus πŸ‘‰ youtube.com/watch?v=hlJ83oOXoec

Books Mentioned in this Episode:
- The Secure Soul: Finding Inner Strength and Connection When Trust Doesn't Come Easy by Alison Cook: amzn.to/3VjvuXi

Articles Mentioned in this Episode:

Toxic Empathy:
theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/09/maga-right-christianity-empathy-toxic/688755

The Fear-Driven Church:
christianitytoday.com/2026/09/fear-churches-christians-spiritual-abuse

Lewis and Clark’s Mercury Latrines:
smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-reconstruct-lewis-and-clark-journey-follow-mercury-laden-latrine-pits-180956518


0:00 – Intro: Experience the Holy Post Podcast in person πŸ‘‰ holypost.com/events
1:58 – Theme Song
2:20 – Sponsor: PolicyGenius - Secure your family’s tomorrow so you have peace of mind today. Go to policygenius.com/HOLYPOST to find the right life insurance for you
3:24 – Sponsor: Sundays Dog Food - Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to SundaysForDogs.com/HOLYPOST or use code HOLYPOST at checkout.
4:33 – Catching Up: Halloween, Epcot, and Books
12:39 – The "Antipathy Movement" and Suicidal Empathy
20:18 – Is Western Civilization Worth Saving?
22:44 – Deportations and the Cost of "Saving the West"
24:14 – Empathy, Politics, and Talking Past Each Other
27:22 – Mike's Story: Empathy, Disability, and Changed Convictions
30:12 – Scot McKnight on "Truthing in Love"
32:20 – Revival Meetings and the Roots of Evangelicalism
33:35 – Kaitlyn's Case for Community-Rooted Politics
36:51 – Russell Moore on the Fear-Driven Church
40:31 – Fear, Bounded Sets, and 11-Page Statements of Faith
45:02 – Fear-Mongering, Safety, and "Protecting Our Kids"
48:57 – Basil on Storehouses and Trusting God With Your Kids
51:36 – Interview Intro: Alison Cook on The Secure Soul
52:03 – Why Alison Wrote The Secure Soul
54:47 – Beyond "Therapy vs. Faith"
59:24 – What Is Attachment Theory?
1:04:42 – Attachment Theory and Our Relationship With God
1:10:49 – Talking to Your Younger Self, Explained
1:18:31 – Rethinking How We Picture God

Resources and Links:
⭐ Join Holy Post Plus for bonus content, extended interviews, and much more! Sign up today at holypost.com/plus
🧑 Support us on Patreon: patreon.com/holypost
πŸ“° Join the Holy Post Substack: holypost.substack.com
🌐 Holy Post Website: holypost.com
πŸ‘• Holy Post Merch Store: holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
πŸ”” Like & subscribe for more conversations on faith, culture, politics, and more!

Follow & Connect with Holy Post:
Instagram: instagram.com/holypostpod
TikTok: tiktok.com/@holypostmedia
X / Twitter: https://x.com/holypostpod
Facebook: facebook.com/holypostpod
#Empathy #AttachmentTheory #ToxicEmpathy #AlisonCook #HolyPostMedia #HPM
The Rights New Argument Against Empathy | Alison Cook | Ep 740Outraged Over a Lion, Silent on ScripturePhones Aren’t the Only Reason We Avoid Silence | John Mark Comer545: What Story is the Bible Telling?  with Timothy GombisJesus, Paul, and the Law: Friends or Foes?Why Tech Billionaires Abandoned Local PhilanthropyPART 2 A Pumpkin Spice Skeptic Admits It’s Actually Good πŸ‘All 4 Holy Post Hosts Debate Evangelicalism | Ep. 739Why Elon Musk’s Election Spending Is a Christian Issue | Sharon MillerFaithful Christians Disagree About GLP-1sThe β€œAnti-Empathy” Movement Is Really About Political TribalismWhy Conservative Media Is Turning on Christian Nationalism
Holy Post Media |

The Right's New Argument Against Empathy | Alison Cook | Ep 740

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER