Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
The New 52 has been called one of DC Comics’ biggest mistakes for years. But buried beneath the failures was an idea that is currently making DC the market leader.
Nearly 15 years later, Wes and Jim revisit DC’s controversial New 52 relaunch and ask whether its reputation is actually deserved. The initiative erased decades of continuity, eliminated Wally West, mangled Superman and eventually collapsed under 52 monthly titles, constant gimmicks and a lack of any real long-term plan. But it also made DC Comics accessible to completely new readers, briefly put DC ahead of Marvel and produced major successes including Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo’s Batman and Geoff Johns’ Aquaman.
Jim actually became a comic reader because of the New 52, and he argues that dismissing the entire era ignores what DC accomplished. From Demon Knights and Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E. to Forever Evil, Grayson and Darkseid War, there were plenty of worthwhile comics buried among the disasters. Wes and Jim discuss what worked, what failed, why DC eventually needed Rebirth to repair the damage and whether today’s industry could learn something from the New 52 experiment.
🎧 Want the FULL, unedited conversation?
Listen to the entire Dok Unfiltered Podcast right now on Thinking Critical Patreon and Channel Memberships.
Support the Channel / Join the Community
Become a Channel Member for exclusive content
🔗 youtube.com/@Wes_From_TC/join
Support Thinking Critical on Patreon for Exclusive Content
🔗 patreon.com/thinkingcritical
🛒 Official Thinking Critical Merch
🔗 redbubble.com/people/T-Critical/shop?asc=u
Covered in this Video
* Was DC’s New 52 actually a failure?
* Why DC Comics launched the New 52
* How the New 52 attracted new comic readers
* Batman by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo
* Geoff Johns’ New 52 Aquaman
* Wally West being erased from DC continuity
* What went wrong with New 52 Superman
* The best and worst New 52 comics
* Why publishing 52 monthly comics became a problem
* DC YOU and the collapse of the New 52
* How DC Rebirth attempted to fix the damage
* What Marvel’s Midnight Universe can learn from the New 52
Follow the Channel
📱 TikTok: tiktok.com/@thinking_critical
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/thinkingcrit
📘 Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/1368359010382132
💬 Discord: discord.gg/uHM3Z68
🎮 Twitch: twitch.tv/thinking_critical_yt
Contact Wes
🐦 Twitter: twitter.com/Wes_from_TC
📧 Email: wesdigscomic@gmail.com
🔊 Automatic Dubbing Disclaimer
This video includes YouTube’s automatic dubbing feature for non-English speakers. Translations may contain minor errors and do not always reflect tone or expression. You can switch back to the original English track in the settings if needed.
The New 52 has been called one of DC Comics’ biggest mistakes for years. But buried beneath the failures was an idea that is currently making DC the market leader.
Nearly 15 years later, Wes and Jim revisit DC’s controversial New 52 relaunch and ask whether its reputation is actually deserved. The initiative erased decades of continuity, eliminated Wally West, mangled Superman and eventually collapsed under 52 monthly titles, constant gimmicks and a lack of any real long-term plan. But it also made DC Comics accessible to completely new readers, briefly put DC ahead of Marvel and produced major successes including Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo’s Batman and Geoff Johns’ Aquaman.
Jim actually became a comic reader because of the New 52, and he argues that dismissing the entire era ignores what DC accomplished. From Demon Knights and Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E. to Forever Evil, Grayson and Darkseid War, there were plenty of worthwhile comics buried among the disasters. Wes and Jim discuss what worked, what failed, why DC eventually needed Rebirth to repair the damage and whether today’s industry could learn something from the New 52 experiment.
🎧 Want the FULL, unedited conversation?
Listen to the entire Dok Unfiltered Podcast right now on Thinking Critical Patreon and Channel Memberships.
Support the Channel / Join the Community
Become a Channel Member for exclusive content
🔗 youtube.com/@Wes_From_TC/join
Support Thinking Critical on Patreon for Exclusive Content
🔗 patreon.com/thinkingcritical
🛒 Official Thinking Critical Merch
🔗 redbubble.com/people/T-Critical/shop?asc=u
Covered in this Video
* Was DC’s New 52 actually a failure?
* Why DC Comics launched the New 52
* How the New 52 attracted new comic readers
* Batman by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo
* Geoff Johns’ New 52 Aquaman
* Wally West being erased from DC continuity
* What went wrong with New 52 Superman
* The best and worst New 52 comics
* Why publishing 52 monthly comics became a problem
* DC YOU and the collapse of the New 52
* How DC Rebirth attempted to fix the damage
* What Marvel’s Midnight Universe can learn from the New 52
Follow the Channel
📱 TikTok: tiktok.com/@thinking_critical
📸 Instagram: instagram.com/thinkingcrit
📘 Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/1368359010382132
💬 Discord: discord.gg/uHM3Z68
🎮 Twitch: twitch.tv/thinking_critical_yt
Contact Wes
🐦 Twitter: twitter.com/Wes_from_TC
📧 Email: wesdigscomic@gmail.com
🔊 Automatic Dubbing Disclaimer
This video includes YouTube’s automatic dubbing feature for non-English speakers. Translations may contain minor errors and do not always reflect tone or expression. You can switch back to the original English track in the settings if needed.










