This Is Your Brain on Yahweh @Skepticus.Channel
This Is Your Brain on Yahweh  @Skepticus.Channel
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Join the livestream every Tuesday night starting at 5PM CST.

Joe Schmid is back—this time with Matt Fradd of Pints With Aquinas—to answer seven arguments for atheism.

Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=rJDW7MiC57s

And apparently the answer to almost all of them is: *maybe.*

Maybe suffering creates greater goods. Maybe divine hiddenness gives Christians the opportunity to evangelize. Maybe religious diversity serves some larger purpose. Maybe animals participate in the eschaton. Maybe God exists outside of time in exactly the way necessary to preserve human freedom.

In this episode of *Breakdowns & Beatdowns*, I react to Joe’s responses to the problem of evil, divine hiddenness, religious diversity, the alleged incoherence of God’s attributes, Occam’s Razor, fine-tuning, the apparent indifference of the universe, and more.

What fascinates me isn't simply that Joe is now Catholic. It’s how dramatically his standards of reasoning appear to have changed. The same skeptical thinker who once examined theological claims with extraordinary care now repeatedly seems willing to construct speculative possibilities, invoke Catholic miracle claims, and treat those possibilities as sufficient answers to some of the hardest objections to theism.

We’ll talk about:

• The problem of evil and animal suffering
• “God’s ways are higher” as an explanation
• Divine hiddenness
• Religious diversity and geography
• Fine-tuning and the anthropic principle
• Miracles, Fatima, Guadalupe, Padre Pio, and Eucharistic miracles
• Omnipotence, timelessness, foreknowledge, and free will
• Occam’s Razor and the “argument from stuff”
• Whether apologetics has become an exercise in making the story fit the conclusion

Joe is obviously an intelligent guy. That’s precisely why I find these arguments so fascinating—and so frustrating.

Watch the original conversation for yourself, hear Joe’s arguments in context, and decide whether these responses actually answer the objections…or merely demonstrate how much you can explain once **“maybe God has a reason”** becomes an acceptable answer.

And remember: **stay skeptical.**

#Atheism #Christianity #Catholicism #JoeSchmid #PintsWithAquinas #Apologetics #Skepticus #ProblemOfEvil #DivineHiddenness #Religion
This Is Your Brain on YahwehThe Invisible Filter  Why We All Read Different StoriesJoe Schmid. Ohhhhhhh, man... 🙄 #christianity #atheism #debate #livestream #deconstructionThere Is Not A Single Fulfilled Prophecy Of Jesus In Psalms - LIVE! (2026-04-21)Kirk Cameron Accidentally DESTROYS ChristianityBe Kind to Yourself After Leaving the Cult
Skepticus |

This Is Your Brain on Yahweh

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER