The Marketplace of Ideas: A Critique @ThenNow
The Marketplace of Ideas: A Critique  @ThenNow
Uploaded August 2019 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
According to scholar of the first amendment C. Edwin Baker, the marketplace ideas metaphor is the dominant rationale given for freedom of speech.

Although not as old as the bill of rights itself, its been used for over a 100 years, since Justice Oliver Wendel Holmes Jr used it Abrams V. United States in 1919.

He said that ‘the ultimate good desired is better reached by free trade in ideas—that the best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market.”

There are many critiques that could be made of the marketplace metaphor, and what’s presented here will be necessarily limited, but taking a look at the concept philosophically while exploring some pivotal moments in the history of the press should serve to highlight where the metaphor fails, and what a more accurate metaphor might look like.


Then & Now is FAN-FUNDED! Support me on Patreon and pledge as little as $1 per video: patreon.com/user?u=3517018

Or send me a one-off tip of any amount and help me make more videos:

paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=JJ76W4CZ2A8J2

Buy on Amazon through this link to support the channel:

amzn.to/2ykJe6L

Follow me on:

Facebook: fb.me/thethenandnow
Instagram: instagram.com/thethenandnow
Twitter: twitter.com/lewlewwaller

Credits:

Stock footage provided by Videvo, downloaded from videvo.net

The Gentleman's Magazine: Photograph by MichaelMaggs; original author "SYLVANUS URBAN, Gent". [Public domain]

Sources:

Martin Conboy, Journalism: A Critical History

John Nerone, The Media and Public Life: A History

Ralph Negrine, Politics and Mass Media in Britain

Jared Schroeder (2018): Toward a discursive marketplace of ideas: Reimaging the marketplace metaphor in the era of social media, fake news, and artificial intelligence, First Amendment Studies, DOI: 10.1080/21689725.2018.1460215

Robert L. Kerr, IMPARTIAL SPECTATOR IN THE MARKETPLACE OF IDEAS: THE PRINCIPLES OF ADAM SMITH AS AN ETHICAL BASIS FOR REGULATION OF CORPORATE SPEECH
The Marketplace of Ideas: A CritiqueWilliam Reddy: The Navigation of FeelingRomantics in the Lake District: The Roots of RomanticismHow Game of Thrones is of our Moment: Philosophy, Politics & WesterosWhy Jordan Peterson is Wrong About ResponsibilityNeuropolitics of Liberals & Conservatives (& why its fMRI Trash)Dialectic of Enlightenment: The Culture Industry - Part IIMonopoly World: Oligarchy & AuthoritarianismDetachment, Objectivity, Imagination: A CritiqueTrue Crime: An AnalysisBeing Us: Communities, Organisations, & Politics of AuthenticityIntroduction to Stoicism
Then & Now |

The Marketplace of Ideas: A Critique

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER