Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 10 hours ago
A scenario is not a prediction. Yet an extreme vision of the future was widely presented as the world we were heading towards without additional climate policy. In his second lecture for Clintel, Roger Pielke Jr. explains how that happened—and why it matters for climate research, media coverage and policy.
At the centre of the story is RCP8.5, a scenario built around an enormous expansion of global coal consumption. Pielke argues that its assumptions do not match developments in the real world. Nevertheless, it became a dominant reference point in studies of future climate impacts and alarming headlines.
Tracing the history of climate scenarios, Pielke explains how exploratory scenarios, baseline assumptions and policy goals became confused. He discusses the retirement of the highest scenarios and asks whether their replacements adequately address the underlying problems.
Topics include:
• Why a scenario is not a prediction.
• How RCP8.5 became known as “business as usual”.
• How assumptions about population, economic growth and energy shape the results.
• Why scenarios need to be plausible and regularly checked against observations.
• What this means for projected warming and energy policy.
His message: taking climate risks seriously also means examining the assumptions behind the calculations. Model results can only inform decisions when we understand the futures on which they depend.
Roger Pielke Jr. is a science and technology policy scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and a former professor at the University of Colorado Boulder. He writes The Honest Broker on Substack.
Recorded on 11 October 2026 at Antropia in Driebergen, the Netherlands. This is the second of two lectures delivered at the invitation of the Clintel Foundation, including audience questions.
ALSO WATCH
First lecture — What Climate Science Actually Says About Extreme Weather:
youtu.be/VeELhhtzzqY
Interview with Marcel Crok — Scrap the Paris Climate Targets:
youtu.be/QFrAGK_OEXk
ROGER PIELKE JR.
Website:
thehonestbroker.org
The Honest Broker on Substack:
rogerpielkejr.substack.com
American Enterprise Institute profile:
aei.org/profile/roger-pielke-jr
Books:
thehonestbroker.org/books
X:
https://x.com/RogerPielkeJr
DATA AND INTERACTIVE TOOLS
Build Your Own Climate Scenario:
scenarios.thehonestbroker.org
Decarbonization Around the World:
decarbonization.thehonestbroker.org
Global Extreme Weather and Climate Change Dashboard:
globalextremeweather.thehonestbroker.org
US Extreme Weather and Climate Change Dashboard:
extremeweather.thehonestbroker.org
Global Tropical Cyclones:
global-tropical-cyclones.com
CLINTEL
Website:
clintel.org
Subscribe to our newsletter:
clintel.org/newsletter
Support our work or become a Friend of Clintel:
donate.clintel.org
World Climate Declaration:
clintel.org/world-climate-declaration
Publications:
clintel.org/publications
Books and reports:
https://clintel.shop/
Follow Clintel on X:
https://x.com/ClintelOrg
Subscribe to this channel for more lectures and interviews on climate science and energy policy.
#RogerPielkeJr #Clintel #ClimateScenarios
A scenario is not a prediction. Yet an extreme vision of the future was widely presented as the world we were heading towards without additional climate policy. In his second lecture for Clintel, Roger Pielke Jr. explains how that happened—and why it matters for climate research, media coverage and policy.
At the centre of the story is RCP8.5, a scenario built around an enormous expansion of global coal consumption. Pielke argues that its assumptions do not match developments in the real world. Nevertheless, it became a dominant reference point in studies of future climate impacts and alarming headlines.
Tracing the history of climate scenarios, Pielke explains how exploratory scenarios, baseline assumptions and policy goals became confused. He discusses the retirement of the highest scenarios and asks whether their replacements adequately address the underlying problems.
Topics include:
• Why a scenario is not a prediction.
• How RCP8.5 became known as “business as usual”.
• How assumptions about population, economic growth and energy shape the results.
• Why scenarios need to be plausible and regularly checked against observations.
• What this means for projected warming and energy policy.
His message: taking climate risks seriously also means examining the assumptions behind the calculations. Model results can only inform decisions when we understand the futures on which they depend.
Roger Pielke Jr. is a science and technology policy scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and a former professor at the University of Colorado Boulder. He writes The Honest Broker on Substack.
Recorded on 11 October 2026 at Antropia in Driebergen, the Netherlands. This is the second of two lectures delivered at the invitation of the Clintel Foundation, including audience questions.
ALSO WATCH
First lecture — What Climate Science Actually Says About Extreme Weather:
youtu.be/VeELhhtzzqY
Interview with Marcel Crok — Scrap the Paris Climate Targets:
youtu.be/QFrAGK_OEXk
ROGER PIELKE JR.
Website:
thehonestbroker.org
The Honest Broker on Substack:
rogerpielkejr.substack.com
American Enterprise Institute profile:
aei.org/profile/roger-pielke-jr
Books:
thehonestbroker.org/books
X:
https://x.com/RogerPielkeJr
DATA AND INTERACTIVE TOOLS
Build Your Own Climate Scenario:
scenarios.thehonestbroker.org
Decarbonization Around the World:
decarbonization.thehonestbroker.org
Global Extreme Weather and Climate Change Dashboard:
globalextremeweather.thehonestbroker.org
US Extreme Weather and Climate Change Dashboard:
extremeweather.thehonestbroker.org
Global Tropical Cyclones:
global-tropical-cyclones.com
CLINTEL
Website:
clintel.org
Subscribe to our newsletter:
clintel.org/newsletter
Support our work or become a Friend of Clintel:
donate.clintel.org
World Climate Declaration:
clintel.org/world-climate-declaration
Publications:
clintel.org/publications
Books and reports:
https://clintel.shop/
Follow Clintel on X:
https://x.com/ClintelOrg
Subscribe to this channel for more lectures and interviews on climate science and energy policy.
#RogerPielkeJr #Clintel #ClimateScenarios










