Uploaded February 2021 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In this video I attempt to answer the question "Is belief in God properly basic?" and go on to offer an explanation and criticism of reformed epistemology.
A properly basic belief is a belief that is not based on evidence or argument (aka it is not a product of inference) but is still a rational thing to believe.
Reformed epistemology suggests that belief in God is not necessarily a product of inference, and because of our divine sense (called a sensus divinitatus) we can have non-inferentially justified belief in God.
I argue that our "sensus divinitatus" is not a sense that provides us with non-inferentially justified beliefs, but instead a description of how we make subconscious inferences about God.
When you see something that looks designed and you end up thinking a designer exists, you are subconsciously appealing to a teleological argument.
When you see a tree and immediately recognize it as a hickory tree, you are making a subconscious inference in order to correctly identify it.
These beliefs people are calling "properly basic" are actually a result of (potentially subconscious) inferences.
In short, a lot of philosophers use the term "basic" to describe things that I don't think actually qualify as "basic" beliefs.
In this video I attempt to answer the question "Is belief in God properly basic?" and go on to offer an explanation and criticism of reformed epistemology.
A properly basic belief is a belief that is not based on evidence or argument (aka it is not a product of inference) but is still a rational thing to believe.
Reformed epistemology suggests that belief in God is not necessarily a product of inference, and because of our divine sense (called a sensus divinitatus) we can have non-inferentially justified belief in God.
I argue that our "sensus divinitatus" is not a sense that provides us with non-inferentially justified beliefs, but instead a description of how we make subconscious inferences about God.
When you see something that looks designed and you end up thinking a designer exists, you are subconsciously appealing to a teleological argument.
When you see a tree and immediately recognize it as a hickory tree, you are making a subconscious inference in order to correctly identify it.
These beliefs people are calling "properly basic" are actually a result of (potentially subconscious) inferences.
In short, a lot of philosophers use the term "basic" to describe things that I don't think actually qualify as "basic" beliefs.










