One Control Plane Away: Are Cloud Providers Critical Infrastructure @TeamNANOG
One Control Plane Away: Are Cloud Providers Critical Infrastructure  @TeamNANOG
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Recent incidents — most visibly the December 2025 Cloudflare outage — show that a single provider's control-plane failure can take a measurable fraction of the web offline at once. We present a measurement study of provider concentration across the Tranco top 10,000 domains that separates three dependency layers usually conflated: who fronts a site's traffic (CDN/edge), who hosts its origin, and who serves its authoritative DNS.
Using layered evidence — CNAME chains for apex and www, provider-published service ranges (e.g., AWS's CLOUDFRONT vs EC2 tags), HTTP and TLS fingerprints, and BGP origin data — we first show that naive IP-to-ASN attribution, still common in public statistics, undercounts CNAME-deployed CDNs by up to 2.7x (Akamai) while overcounting cloud providers by conflating hosting with fronting.
Findings: concentration increases down-rank. Cloudflare fronts 28.5% of classified top-1,000 domains but 45.7% of the top-10,000 — the biggest properties diversify (13% of strongly-fronted domains are demonstrably multi-CDN) while the mid-tail single-homes. Authoritative DNS is separately concentrated: Route 53 serves 22% and Cloudflare 26% of live domains; only 14% self-host DNS. Combining layers, 21.9% of live top-10k domains depend on Cloudflare for both DNS and delivery — one control-plane event from total unavailability — and 37.9% are double-dependent on some single organization.
We close with week-over-week change data from our ongoing weekly measurement pipeline (running since August 2026) and a practical exposure-assessment recipe operators can apply to their own dependency chains. The measurement tool and dataset will be released at publication
One Control Plane Away: Are Cloud Providers Critical InfrastructureLightning Talk: Cattledog Method - A compromise for CLIs in the Automation and Platform EraEnergy Efficient RoutingMonitoring Root DNS PrefixesStop Using 100GBASE-LR4Network OS Upgrades at HyperscaleA Journey of Accelerating and Offloading OVS with a DPUAffogatos: Navigating Intergenerational Working RelationshipsInside the Hidden World of the Pluggable TransceiverKeynote: Beyond the Chip: The Unprecedented Infrastructure Demands of AI and HPCLightning Talk: Practical Ways to Reduce IPv4 UsageEnd-System Controlled, Dynamic Multihoming and Multipath Transport
NANOG |

One Control Plane Away: Are Cloud Providers Critical Infrastructure

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER