Uploaded November 2018 | Updated September 2026, 1 week ago

---

It's big, it's bonkers - it's the Red Dead Redemption 2 review from Caddy! Is it buggy? Is it boring? Is it brilliant? Actually, don't answer them. That's what this video is for. Get your complete hair kit for just $5: forhims.com/caddy While supplies lasts. See website for full details. ▼ MORE LINKS BELOW ▼

DON'T FORGET - the outtakes are on at the end of the video! :D
Special thanks to twitter.com/JetpackBraggin for the incredible thumbnail art!
Please consider supporting the channel here and check out the little rewards (including credit mentions and 24-hour early access to every Caddicarus ep AD-FREE)!! patreon.com/caddicarus
Don't forget to join the channel right here = youtube.com/user/Caddicarus?sub_confirmation=1

Red Dead Redemption 2 is the 2018 sequel on PS4 and Xbox One to the original Red Dead Redemption for PS3 and Xbox 360. Why weren't any of them on PC? No idea. And actually, Red Dead 2 is more accurately a prequel to the original. The original, by the way, was one of the most critically acclaimed games of all time when it came out - with Caddicarus being right behind the critics on that opinion. Caddy loves Red Dead, and was immensely excited for the next game in the lineup, even though it came as a surprise being 8 years later. Instead of controlling John Marston as you ride around the wild west via a trusty horse and shooting up outlaws eventually leading to a heartbreaking ending, however - you're instead Arthur Morgan.....doing basically the same thing, I suppose - but it's a slightly different time period, and with much more of a focus on camp building and gang relationships than about a single man's government-enforced hunt to save his own family. Caddy also seems to love Red Dead 2 a fair amount, which you will be able to see in this review! The game does have problems, though - and despite the love, we aren't going to ignore the bugs, glitches, confusing mechanics and weird controls that are here - I mean why do you think this video is so long?! Everything you see here was recorded at 1080p 60fps (despite the game only running at 30fps but what can ya do, eh?) with an Elgato HD60 via PS4 Pro. No idea if it runs a little better on Xbox One X or something - please let me know in the comments!

CADDICARUS MERCHANDISE, GAMING POSTERS, and the 15% off with the coupon code 'CADDY'! = pixelempire.com
CHEAP GAMES (sometimes less than $1!) EVERY 24 HOURS! = chrono.gg/caddy
HIDDEN BLOCK! = hiddenblock.com
TWITTER! = twitter.com/Caddicarus
TUMBLR! = thecaddicarus.tumblr.com
FACEBOOK! = facebook.com/Caddicarus
INSTAGRAM! = instagram.com/caddicarus

Caddicarus 8bit themes by Endigo = youtube.com/user/Endigo
Caddicarus logo by Jan Animation = youtube.com/user/jananimationstudios/videos
Kevin MacLeod's royalty free music! = incompetech.com
OLLY'S CAMERA WORK! = vimeo.com/ollyross

QUESTION OF THE DAY: This is a big one. JOHN MARSTON, or ARTHUR MORGAN?!

Watch more comedy game reviews like my Red Dead Redemption 2 review on my channel below! | Caddicarus
youtube.com/user/Caddicarus