Uploaded November 2022 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Techniques for Having Productive Lobby Meetings by James Hopf of Generation Atomic Government Team. Presented at Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #11.
Always respectful, friendly and appreciative of their work.
Never argue or try to change their views/values.
It’s not a debate – it’s a sales pitch.
Find common values.
Tailor message.
Find/give reasons why THEY would want to do what your proposing.
Avoid lecturing (one-way communication).
Engage in 2-way conversation.
It can be more about building a relationship (especially in initial meetings).
Tailor your message:
Research before meeting: Committee assignments, positions on past bills, personal background, press releases, social media posts.
Use open-ended questions in meeting: What are your thoughts or concerns about nuclear, etc?
Legislator Meeting Setup:
Contact legislative office, via phone or email (may want to ask to speak with key staff).
May require several tries to get a meeting.
Gather/bring supporting materials (to leave behind or refer to at appropriate times in meeting).
You will usually meet with key staff (vs. legislator), meeting with key staff can be more effective!
Roles in the Meeting:
Leader: Does main intro & appreciation, states purpose, thank you.
Storyteller: Has best personal story and can fold it into responses to objections.
Notetaker/timekeeper: Monitors the clock and ensures group is transitioning through different phases in a timely fashion.
Meeting BEGINNING:
Thank them for meeting you, establish how much time they can give you (leader)... “Thank you for meeting with us today-- how much time do you have to meet?”
Express Appreciation for something they’ve done in the past (leader)... “We wanted to thank you for supporting (X) and really being a leader for (Y).”
Best if you can find an action that is somewhat related to meeting’s purpose (something nuclear related, or more generally a pro-environment action for a Dem, or a pro-energy/jobs action for GOP). Keep it brief (a sentence or two).
Introduce yourselves and tell your story (all participants - story teller given more time)...
“I’m NAME from ORG, and this is NAME.
Give brief background then “I’m here because I’m concerned about… This is NAME, I’ll let them introduce themselves.”
“The reason I came to talk to you today is because I’m concerned about (X)” (e.g., climate change, or the reliable, affordable electricity – tailor expressed concern to legislator).
State the purpose of the meeting, i.e., the main ask (leader)
“Our purpose today is to ask that you support Bill XYZ, which would facilitate construction of new nuclear plants”
Meeting MIDDLE:
Opening Statement (leader)... “Can we answer any questions you have about the bill or discuss any concerns that you have, that might prevent voting for it?”
Main Discussion (all participants). Listen first, and listen a lot. Don’t lecture. Identify their concerns, values and point of view. Try to find shared values, and reasons why THEY would want to support the bill. After each response: “Does that answer your question or concern?”
Closing Statement (leader)... “Do you have any more questions or concerns that we could address?” “Do you think it would be possible for you to support the bill?”
Anticipated QUESTIONS:
Renewables enthusiast -- “Wouldn’t we want to use something a bit more sustainable, like RE?” ...
Renewables must be used to replace fossil fuels, not nuclear.
Most analysts, as well as the IPCC agree that nuclear (both new and existing) will need grow and play a significant role (as a non-intermittent, clean source).
Climate skeptic -- “Considering the polar vortex, I think we should be more concerned about Global Cooling.” ...
Emphasize jobs, tax base, reliability, and power costs.
Concerned about cost-- “Nuclear is fine, but it’s just too expensive.” ...
Give renewables and nuclear similar support (e.g., subsidy) and let the market decide.
Inclusion of nuclear will reduce the cost of a carbon-free grid by greatly reducing storage costs.
Meeting ENDING:
Make secondary ask (leader)...
Ask if they could support any kind of nuclear support bill, and if so, what kind of changes they would want. Ask if they would be willing to meet or discuss the issue further in the future.
Follow Up...
Offer to do research to address any unanswered questions or requests of additional information. Respond within a week or so.
Leave Behind...
Articles, op-eds, info sheets, reports, expressions of support by leaders or organizations, etc. Take photo (if they want to).
Thank them for taking the time to meet...
Send a thank you card/email, the key is to establish a connection and maintain it.
Techniques for Having Productive Lobby Meetings by James Hopf of Generation Atomic Government Team. Presented at Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #11.
Always respectful, friendly and appreciative of their work.
Never argue or try to change their views/values.
It’s not a debate – it’s a sales pitch.
Find common values.
Tailor message.
Find/give reasons why THEY would want to do what your proposing.
Avoid lecturing (one-way communication).
Engage in 2-way conversation.
It can be more about building a relationship (especially in initial meetings).
Tailor your message:
Research before meeting: Committee assignments, positions on past bills, personal background, press releases, social media posts.
Use open-ended questions in meeting: What are your thoughts or concerns about nuclear, etc?
Legislator Meeting Setup:
Contact legislative office, via phone or email (may want to ask to speak with key staff).
May require several tries to get a meeting.
Gather/bring supporting materials (to leave behind or refer to at appropriate times in meeting).
You will usually meet with key staff (vs. legislator), meeting with key staff can be more effective!
Roles in the Meeting:
Leader: Does main intro & appreciation, states purpose, thank you.
Storyteller: Has best personal story and can fold it into responses to objections.
Notetaker/timekeeper: Monitors the clock and ensures group is transitioning through different phases in a timely fashion.
Meeting BEGINNING:
Thank them for meeting you, establish how much time they can give you (leader)... “Thank you for meeting with us today-- how much time do you have to meet?”
Express Appreciation for something they’ve done in the past (leader)... “We wanted to thank you for supporting (X) and really being a leader for (Y).”
Best if you can find an action that is somewhat related to meeting’s purpose (something nuclear related, or more generally a pro-environment action for a Dem, or a pro-energy/jobs action for GOP). Keep it brief (a sentence or two).
Introduce yourselves and tell your story (all participants - story teller given more time)...
“I’m NAME from ORG, and this is NAME.
Give brief background then “I’m here because I’m concerned about… This is NAME, I’ll let them introduce themselves.”
“The reason I came to talk to you today is because I’m concerned about (X)” (e.g., climate change, or the reliable, affordable electricity – tailor expressed concern to legislator).
State the purpose of the meeting, i.e., the main ask (leader)
“Our purpose today is to ask that you support Bill XYZ, which would facilitate construction of new nuclear plants”
Meeting MIDDLE:
Opening Statement (leader)... “Can we answer any questions you have about the bill or discuss any concerns that you have, that might prevent voting for it?”
Main Discussion (all participants). Listen first, and listen a lot. Don’t lecture. Identify their concerns, values and point of view. Try to find shared values, and reasons why THEY would want to support the bill. After each response: “Does that answer your question or concern?”
Closing Statement (leader)... “Do you have any more questions or concerns that we could address?” “Do you think it would be possible for you to support the bill?”
Anticipated QUESTIONS:
Renewables enthusiast -- “Wouldn’t we want to use something a bit more sustainable, like RE?” ...
Renewables must be used to replace fossil fuels, not nuclear.
Most analysts, as well as the IPCC agree that nuclear (both new and existing) will need grow and play a significant role (as a non-intermittent, clean source).
Climate skeptic -- “Considering the polar vortex, I think we should be more concerned about Global Cooling.” ...
Emphasize jobs, tax base, reliability, and power costs.
Concerned about cost-- “Nuclear is fine, but it’s just too expensive.” ...
Give renewables and nuclear similar support (e.g., subsidy) and let the market decide.
Inclusion of nuclear will reduce the cost of a carbon-free grid by greatly reducing storage costs.
Meeting ENDING:
Make secondary ask (leader)...
Ask if they could support any kind of nuclear support bill, and if so, what kind of changes they would want. Ask if they would be willing to meet or discuss the issue further in the future.
Follow Up...
Offer to do research to address any unanswered questions or requests of additional information. Respond within a week or so.
Leave Behind...
Articles, op-eds, info sheets, reports, expressions of support by leaders or organizations, etc. Take photo (if they want to).
Thank them for taking the time to meet...
Send a thank you card/email, the key is to establish a connection and maintain it.








![NNSA (National Nuclear Security Administration) on Proliferation, Safeguards, PRO-X @ ORNL MSRW 2021
NNSA talks delivered at Oak Ridge National Laboratorys 2021 Molten-Salt Reactor Workshop are presented here as a single video. This was the final session on 2021-10-12 (day-1 of a 2 day conference).
DOE National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) Resources Session:
00:30 Office of Defence Nuclear Nonproliferation, Office Structure [NNSAs Jeff Chamberlin]
05:03 U.S. Nuclear Nexus [NNSAs Jeff Chamberlin continues]
09:00 ARISE (Advanced Reactor International Safeguards Engagement) [NNSA NPACs Anagha Iyengar]
19:58 International Nuclear Security Resources for the U.S. Advanced Reactor Industry [NNSAs Katherine Holt]
29:41 PRO-X (Proliferation Resistance Optimization) [NNSAs Brian Waud]
36:07 Q&A: What is coming next Fiscal Year?
37:42 Q&A: Any comments on running a Pure U-233 System? (Thorium Pure Cycle.)
DOE National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) Resources Session:
00:30 Office of Defence Nuclear Nonproliferation, Office Structure [NNSAs Jeff Chamberlin]
05:03 U.S. Nuclear Nexus [NNSAs Jeff Chamberlin continues]
09:00 ARISE (Advanced Reactor International Safeguards Engagement) [NNSA NPACs Anagha Iyengar]
19:58 International Nuclear Security Resources for the U.S. Advanced Reactor Industry [NNSAs Katherine Holt]
29:41 PRO-X (Proliferation Resistance Optimization) [NNSAs Brian Waud]
36:07 Q&A: What is coming next Fiscal Year?
37:42 Q&A: Any comments on running a Pure U-233 System? (Thorium Pure Cycle.)
U.S. NUCLEAR NEXUS
Your Resource to Engage with NNSA on Global Deployment of U.S. Civilian Nuclear Technology Tool to provide a dynamic means for U.S. industry to interact with NNSA
OFFICE OF NONPROLIFERATION AND ARMS CONTROL (NPAC)
INTERNATIONAL NUCLEAR SAFEGUARDS: Build capacity of the international atomic energy agency and partner countries to implement international safeguards obligations.
NUCLEAR EXPORT CONTROLS: Build domestic and international capacity to implement export control obligations,
NUCLEAR VERIFICATION: Support negotiation of and implement agreements and associated monitoring regimes to verifiably reduce nuclear weapons and nuclear programs.
NONPROLIFERATION POLICY: Develops approaches and strategies to address emerging nonproliferation and arms control challenges and opportunities.
What are IAEA Safeguards?
- Safeguards are measures applied by the IAEA to ensure a countrys exclusively peaceful use
of nuclear material and facilities.
- Prevent state-sponsored proliferation
- Nuclear facilities exported internationally will likely be subject to IAEA verification
- Reactors and associated fuel cycle facilities may be subject to U.S. treaty and statutory obligations even if built in the U.S.
- NRC licensing requirements were not designed to address all aspects of IAEA safeguards
- IAEA safeguards is a treaty requirement undertaken by countries that enables the IAEA to independently verify that a country is not diverting nuclear material from declared activities.
What are the Benefits to U.S Vendors Considering International Safeguards?
- Observing the legal requirement that exported materials and facilities are safeguarded by the IAEA
- Making the job of IAEA inspector and operator / owner easier, thereby reducing safeguards burden
- Better positioning U.S. advanced reactor vendors in the global market
- Demonstrating corporate social responsibility / environmental, social, and governance criteria
- Reducing need for potentially costly retrofits and redesigns
- Reducing risk to scope, schedule, budget, and licensing
Policy Drivers:
- American leadership in nuclear technology + nonproliferation standards
- Enabling peaceful uses
- Meeting climate change goals
- INS AR Nuclear Security Program
- Partnering with U.S. nuclear reactor industry & embarking countries on nuclear security topics to:
Improve security of future US exports
Build nuclear security capacity in Newcomer countries
Advance the global nuclear security regime
To develop a partnership with industry, the DOE National Labs can enter:
- Nondisclosure Agreements (NDAs) to have detailed discussions of technologies that can include proprietary information.
- Cooperative Research and Development Agreements (CRADAs) to expand a companys proprietary capabilities or knowledge-set.
Proliferation Resistance Optimization (PRO-X) - Program Mission The Proliferation Resistance Optimization program maximizes proliferation resistance while optimizing performance for stated peaceful uses in nuclear facility and technology designs.
Program Targets:
• Limit the production and/or extraction of weapons useable nuclear material (WUNM)
• Reduce attractiveness of all applicable nuclear material
• Ensure that whole facility and capability is scaled to meet mission objectives
• Coordinate measures with facility operations, security, safety, safeguards and forensics to ensure compatibility and effectiveness NNSA (National Nuclear Security Administration) on Proliferation, Safeguards, PRO-X @ ORNL MSRW 2021](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/KnrXWYFNG6Q/mqdefault.jpg)

