Matt Prewitt: Form Without End: Aristotelian Causality and the General-Purpose Tool @ToposInstitute
Matt Prewitt: Form Without End: Aristotelian Causality and the General-Purpose Tool  @ToposInstitute
Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Topos Institute Colloquium, 2nd of July 2026.
———
Modern thought recognizes only two of Aristotle’s four causes. Efficient and material causation survived the scientific revolution, but formal and final causation were exiled as “metaphysics”. This simplified model of causality has proven useful for accelerating scientific and technical understanding. At the same time it has been disabling for orienting technology toward the human good. The reason is that it erases the distinction between a thing whose end is intrinsic — an organism, for example — and a thing whose end is extrinsic, like a tool.

This is not a mere history of ideas. I defend formal and final causation as serious, useful categories that physicists and mathematicians, not just poets and philosophers, need to take seriously. I then turn to a a distinction between limited-purpose tools (like houses, shoes, and shovels); and general purpose tools (like money, writing, and AI). General purpose tools, in proportion to their generality, do not stay at arm’s length, but become part of the formal cause of the user, eg, the human person. This introduces noise or randomness into the relationship between users and their ultimate goals and ends. I argue this is the central risk of general-purpose technology and that this is the essence of all critiques of technology. That it remains obscure and poorly understood is a major stumbling block to better and safer technology. But it requires an Aristotelian or closely equivalent vocabulary to articulate it unambiguously.
Matt Prewitt: Form Without End: Aristotelian Causality and the General-Purpose Tool[Oxford Seminar] Samuel George-White | Advancing human-machine interface systems through AI[Oxford Seminar] Q Le | Enriched Categories Applied to Qualia Spaces[Oxford Seminar] Xiaoyan Li | A novel modular and compositional framework for System Dynamics[Berkeley Seminar] William Troiani | Programs as Singularities[2-torial] David tells Joanna about algebraic patternsNathaniel Virgo: Towards a mathematical theory of intentional systems[Berkeley Seminar] Evan Patterson | How to Prove Equations Using DiagramsBenjamin Pierce: Properties for the People[Berkeley Seminar] David Jaz Myers | Categorical Algebra with Segal Conditions[Oxford Seminar] Olga Paris-Romanskevich | Gender and science: what every mathematician should know[Oxford Seminar] Owen Lynch | Markov Semigroups
Topos Institute |

Matt Prewitt: Form Without End: Aristotelian Causality and the General-Purpose Tool

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER