Uploaded October 2023 | Updated November 2026, 6 hours ago
"Material Control and Accountancy for US NRC License Applications for a Liquid-Fueled Molten Salt Reactor" presented by Nicholas Luciano of ORNL at ORNL MSRW 2023. (Oak Ridge National Laboratory Molten-Salt Reactor Workshop 2023.)
NRC Licensing for Conventional LWRs
• License applicants for conventional LWRs do not submit a Fundamental Nuclear Material Control (FNMC) plan
• Exclusion in 10 CFR part 74 for Utilization Facilities licensed under 10 CFR part 50.
• LWR assemblies are large, heavy, items with incapacitating dose rates (post-irradiation)
• Many theft scenarios are not highly credible
• Fresh fuel assemblies are inventoried, loaded into the reactor, and sealed for years, then offloaded to a pool.
• Used fuel assemblies are inventoried (counted).
• Once offloaded, SNM is "put on the books" using quantities using computational models.
NRC Licensing Context for MSRs
• Fuel fabrication and enrichment facilities do submit FNMC plans
• Bulk facilities with SNM in powder or gaseous form.
• No transmutation, depletion, and only limited losses due to decay
• MSRs are bulk facilities and will very likely need to develop, submit, and implement FNMC plans
• No current plans for NRC to develop a modified approach for MSRS
• No current FNMC template for MSRs
Process Monitoring Would Be Difficult
• Alternative Approach: treat a liquid-fueled MSR like any other bulk facility and apply 10 CFR Part 74 requirements
• MSs aren't the same as fuel fab or enrichment facilities;
• SNM in process is highly radioactive material and not accessible
• Inconsistent with NRC's approach for other reactors
• Likely not attainable with current technologies
• Thought experiment - consider all parameters necessary to monitor
• Uncertainties (measurement precision, nuclear data,...) and biases (sensor drift, hold-up,...)
• If expected and measured don't agree for inventory, NRC notified of "loss or theft"
• Full process monitoring would be expensive to implement, even if possible
• High level of resources devoted to MC&A is not necessary to prevent or detect diversion
Measuring Inputs & Outputs are not enough
• Alternative Option: Only look at material transferred between MBAs (inputs & outputs)
• SNM in MSRs is not in large, heavy countable items
• Fuel is not stationary and sealed in one location
• Sampling ports, etc. are possible pathways for material diversion
• Timely detection of material loss or theft unlikely
• Would not achieve the purpose of MC&A
Performance-Based Regulation
"A regulatory approach that focuses on desired, measurable outcomes, rather than prescriptive processes, techniques, or procedures. Performance-based regulation leads to defined results without specific direction regarding how those results are to be obtained. At the NRC, performance-based regulatory actions focus on identifying performance measures that ensure an adequate safety margin and offer incentives for licensees to improve safety without formal regulatory intervention by the agency."
ThoriumRemix.com Thorium & MSR & Nuclear assets used in Thorium Remix project.
"Material Control and Accountancy for US NRC License Applications for a Liquid-Fueled Molten Salt Reactor" presented by Nicholas Luciano of ORNL at ORNL MSRW 2023. (Oak Ridge National Laboratory Molten-Salt Reactor Workshop 2023.)
NRC Licensing for Conventional LWRs
• License applicants for conventional LWRs do not submit a Fundamental Nuclear Material Control (FNMC) plan
• Exclusion in 10 CFR part 74 for Utilization Facilities licensed under 10 CFR part 50.
• LWR assemblies are large, heavy, items with incapacitating dose rates (post-irradiation)
• Many theft scenarios are not highly credible
• Fresh fuel assemblies are inventoried, loaded into the reactor, and sealed for years, then offloaded to a pool.
• Used fuel assemblies are inventoried (counted).
• Once offloaded, SNM is "put on the books" using quantities using computational models.
NRC Licensing Context for MSRs
• Fuel fabrication and enrichment facilities do submit FNMC plans
• Bulk facilities with SNM in powder or gaseous form.
• No transmutation, depletion, and only limited losses due to decay
• MSRs are bulk facilities and will very likely need to develop, submit, and implement FNMC plans
• No current plans for NRC to develop a modified approach for MSRS
• No current FNMC template for MSRs
Process Monitoring Would Be Difficult
• Alternative Approach: treat a liquid-fueled MSR like any other bulk facility and apply 10 CFR Part 74 requirements
• MSs aren't the same as fuel fab or enrichment facilities;
• SNM in process is highly radioactive material and not accessible
• Inconsistent with NRC's approach for other reactors
• Likely not attainable with current technologies
• Thought experiment - consider all parameters necessary to monitor
• Uncertainties (measurement precision, nuclear data,...) and biases (sensor drift, hold-up,...)
• If expected and measured don't agree for inventory, NRC notified of "loss or theft"
• Full process monitoring would be expensive to implement, even if possible
• High level of resources devoted to MC&A is not necessary to prevent or detect diversion
Measuring Inputs & Outputs are not enough
• Alternative Option: Only look at material transferred between MBAs (inputs & outputs)
• SNM in MSRs is not in large, heavy countable items
• Fuel is not stationary and sealed in one location
• Sampling ports, etc. are possible pathways for material diversion
• Timely detection of material loss or theft unlikely
• Would not achieve the purpose of MC&A
Performance-Based Regulation
"A regulatory approach that focuses on desired, measurable outcomes, rather than prescriptive processes, techniques, or procedures. Performance-based regulation leads to defined results without specific direction regarding how those results are to be obtained. At the NRC, performance-based regulatory actions focus on identifying performance measures that ensure an adequate safety margin and offer incentives for licensees to improve safety without formal regulatory intervention by the agency."
ThoriumRemix.com Thorium & MSR & Nuclear assets used in Thorium Remix project.










![Kirk Sorensen of Flibe Energy: Thorium Fuel Cycle @ Mississippi PSC Nuclear Summit
2024-10-22 Kirk Sorensen attended Mississippi Public Service Commission Nuclear Summit to present for Flibe Energy.
Kirk summarizes the experience here:
https://energyfromthorium.com/2024/10/25/ms-psc-nuclear-summit/
Copy/paste from the blog post follows...
I [Kirk] traveled to Jackson to speak to the three members of the Mississippi Public Service Commission on Tuesday, October 22. They had assembled a “2024 Nuclear Summit” and were gracious enough to allow me to present our technological approach to them.
It’s now gone from a time where thorium is a compelling option to a time where thorium (used efficiently in our lithium-fluoride reactor designs) might be the only way to produce economically competitive nuclear energy.
...and some news coverage...
https://magnoliatribune.com/2024/10/24/nuclear-power-generation-seeing-a-resurgence-mississippi-could-benefit/
https://apnews.com/us-news/mississippi-green-technology-general-news-4f2d8fad36ce69b4748c3bd26e361400 [Note: AP should read Flibe has been leasing the site for the last five years and has spent a quarter of a MILLION dollars on improvements]
My own [Gord] notes on the video [editing] are: Despite the sound levels fluctuating, this is actually much more balanced than the original stream: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJ0kAXkjTCk&t=2483s ...which is really the most loud-quiet-loud-quiet audio Ive ever heard.
http://ThoriumRemix.com/ Thorium & MSR & Nuclear assets used in Thorium Remix project. Kirk Sorensen of Flibe Energy: Thorium Fuel Cycle @ Mississippi PSC Nuclear Summit](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/CYfzqRU3SRs/mqdefault.jpg)