I Said Don’t Change the Old Fashioned. Then I Made THIS. @TheMoodyBartender
I Said Don’t Change the Old Fashioned. Then I Made THIS.  @TheMoodyBartender
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
I said the classic Old Fashioned doesn’t need fixing. I still believe that. But apparently, I also enjoy arguing with myself.

👉 Support The Moody Bartender on Patreon: patreon.com/moodybartender

This time, I’m making something completely different: the Pistola Soy Old Fashioned, a spirit-forward cocktail combining Maya Pistola Agavepura Reposado with the newly released Umami Syrup from Bristol Syrup Co.

And yes, we’re bringing soy-inspired savoury flavours into an Old Fashioned.

Maya Pistola is a remarkable Indian agave spirit made from Agave Americana and aged in bourbon and American oak barrels. It’s rich, warming and full of character, with notes of butternut squash, marshmallow, caramel and gentle spice.

The Umami Syrup brings something entirely different. Savoury depth, a distinctive soy character and a subtle saltiness that develops beautifully alongside the aged agave spirit.

The result? An unusual Old Fashioned that balances warmth, sweetness, spice and savoury flavours without losing the character of the base spirit.

It’s certainly not for everyone. But if you enjoy exploring savoury flavours in cocktails, this might surprise you.

THE PISTOLA SOY OLD FASHIONED

60 ml / 2 oz Maya Pistola Agavepura Reposado
5 ml / bar spoon Bristol Syrup Co. Umami Syrup
2 Dashes Steve the Bartender Orange Bitters
Orange Peel, for garnish

Method:

Add the agave spirit, Umami Syrup and orange bitters to a mixing glass with ice. Stir for approximately 20–30 seconds to chill, dilute and integrate the flavours. Strain into a rocks glass over a large ice cube.

Express fresh orange peel over the cocktail, rub it around the rim and garnish.

A little about the ingredients:

Bristol Syrup Co. kindly sent me a selection of their syrups to experiment with, including their new Umami Syrup. This bottle immediately caught my attention, and I wanted to explore what it could bring to a spirit-forward cocktail.

Maya Pistola Agavepura Reposado is another spirit I genuinely enjoy and believe deserves more attention.

Thanks for watching, and let me know whether you’d try a savoury Old Fashioned.

The syrups were gifted by Bristol Syrup Co. Opinions and the cocktail recipe are my own.

VIDEO CHAPTERS:
00:00 Bristol Syrup Co. & Their New Umami Syrup
00:38 Why Umami in an Old Fashioned?
01:50 Introducing the Pistola Soy Old Fashioned
02:40 Building the Cocktail
03:51 Stirring & Dilution
05:20 Tasting the Pistola Soy Old Fashioned
06:32 Final Thoughts

MY BAR TOOLS
🔶 Multi Measurement Jigger [UK] - amzn.to/3kLKwib (paid link)
🔶 Multi Measurement Jigger [US] - amzn.to/3bhAfa8 (paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Boston Shaker: amzn.to/3az52hm (paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Jigger: amzn.to/2O5eLo1(paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Bar Spoon: amzn.to/36JgeXE (paid link)
🔶 Tattoo Strainer: amzn.to/3tnTVQR (paid link)

DISCLAIMER:
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases and get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

#OldFashioned #UmamiCocktail #TheMoodyBartender
I Said Don’t Change the Old Fashioned. Then I Made THIS.Cane & Tables Miami Vice Cocktail Recipe ! my version !Winter Fizz vs Triple Cherry Fizz - Which Will You Make?My Most Popular Gin Cocktail Recipe - The NorthsideWhat is a Cocogroni? A Coconut Negroni Recipe to TryConfession! I didnt want to share this.Six Drambuie Cocktails with special guests | Just Shake or StirAn Excellent Vodka Cocktail 👌😉Rhubarb Liqueur Cocktail: The Perfect Summer DrinkBlood Orange Season? Make These 3 Cocktails NowBehind the Scenes of Just Shake or Stir | The £300 Bar BuildIs Blackberry Syrup the SECRET to The BEST Coffee Rum Drink?
The Moody Bartender |

I Said Don’t Change the Old Fashioned. Then I Made THIS.

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER