How to Tell When its Demonic @BrianHoldsworth
How to Tell When its Demonic  @BrianHoldsworth
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
“We can’t just say, ‘It must have been demonic.’ We have to satisfy the burden of proof that comes with that claim.”

Support the channel by visiting: brianholdsworth.ca/help

If miracles can support a religious claim, what are we to make of reports of supernatural events in other religions? Can we simply call the ones we dislike demonic?
This video looks at how Catholic theology distinguishes divine miracles from demonic activity: what demons can do through nature, what they cannot do, why healings and apparitions require careful scrutiny, and how to assess the lasting effects of a reported wonder. I also consider the claim that Fatima’s “miracle of the sun” was demonic—and why dismissing it on those grounds can become circular reasoning.

Timestamps
- 0:00 What would prove that someone was sent by God?
- 1:03 Miracles in other religions—and the demonic explanation
- 3:54 What Catholic theology means by a miracle
- 4:27 What demons can do through nature
- 6:53 Artificial sensations, drugs, and screens
- 8:25 Apparent healings and the need for verification
- 10:30 The miracle of the sun at Fatima
- 12:03 Judging a wonder by its lasting effects
- 13:06 When “it was demonic” becomes circular reasoning

Music written and generously provided by Paul Jernberg. Find out more about his work as a composer here: pauljernberg.com

Podcast Version: brianholdsworth.libsyn.com
How to Tell When its DemonicCatholics Earn Their SalvationThe Doctrine Nobody Wants to Talk AboutWhy Islam is Collapsing w/ David WoodThe Murder Button vs Just WarThis War Feels DifferentSurprised By Controversy, with Dr. Taylor MarshallSeal of Confession is Under Threat... AgainThe Day Conservatives Turned on the PopeWes Huff Didn’t Answer the Question Bartlett AskedSecret Catholic Teaching: UsuryThe Hidden Beliefs of Powerful Monsters
Brian Holdsworth |

How to Tell When it's Demonic

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER