How Judges Become Vulnerable to Populist Attack @UCLLaws
How Judges Become Vulnerable to Populist Attack  @UCLLaws
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
This seminar was part of the Public Law Seminar Series, organised by the UCL Global Centre for Democratic Constitutionalism.

29.10.26

Speaker: Dr Alex Schwartz (University of Glasgow, School of Law)
Commentators: Dr Luis Soto Tamayo (UCL Laws, GCDC), Prof Erin Delaney (UCL GCDC Director)
Chair: Prof Rick Rawlings (UCL Laws, GCDC)

About the talk

One reason populism is widely thought to pose a threat to constitutional democracy is its apparent association with radical court curbing; policies intended to limit or eliminate independent judicial power are often accompanied by populist rhetoric attacking the integrity of judges. With a view to advancing our understanding of why some courts or judges become especially vulnerable to these attacks, this seminar presents the results of empirical research (drawn from a forthcoming monograph) examining how governments use populist rhetoric to frame court-curbing policies. Based on a computational analysis of massive corpora of politicians’ social media communications, I identify the themes most associated with criticism of courts and judges in two paradigmatic cases of populist court curbing: Türkiye under Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi (AKP) governments and Poland under Prawo i Sprawiedliwość (PiS) governments. The findings suggest that the discourse associated with populist court curbing is far less ideological than might be thought. These governments advanced genealogical critiques of their respective constitutional orders and systematically drew on local histories of judicial empowerment to portray courts as bastions of malevolent elite factions. In this way, they could construct resonant frames for their respective court-curbing policies. I contrast this evidence with findings from the recent Conservative era of government in the United Kingdom; there, government criticism of domestic courts was not systematically nested within a deeper historical narrative or broader critique of the institutional status quo and tended instead to frame court curbing in less antagonistic terms, as a means of restoring the proper separation of powers.

About the Speaker

Dr Alex Schwartz is Senior Lecturer in Public Law in the School of Law at the University of Glasgow. His research focuses on comparative constitutional law, judicial politics, and constitutional design, with a broader interest in empirical and computational legal studies. He has published widely on judicial behaviour, constitutionalism, and courts in divided societies, including in journals such as Law & Society Review. He is co-editor, with David S. Law and Holning Lau, of the Oxford Handbook on Constitutional Law in Asia and the author of a forthcoming book on populism and court curbing. Before joining the University of Glasgow, he was Associate Professor at the University of Hong Kong, Lecturer in Law at Queen’s University Belfast, and a Banting Fellow with the Department of Political Studies at Queen’s University (Canada).
How Judges Become Vulnerable to Populist AttackJustice Driven Insolvency Law: A Normative TheoryFamily Law As Social Policy: Taking Family Problems UpstreamA New Dawn for UK Design Law?LAWS0309: The Role of Economics in Competition Law and PracticeDebating Digital Constitutionalism: A Benthamian PerspectiveLAWS0369 – Social Welfare Law2026 Bentham Association Presidential Address: Sovereignty of Parliament and Legal HistoryBentham Association Presidential Address 2025Copyright Law and AI: Time to Revisit Copyright Registration?PLSS: The Life and Death of Freedom of ExpressionIndependent Expert Panel on Corporate Re-domiciliation
UCL Laws |

How Judges Become Vulnerable to Populist Attack

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER