Has Physics Debunked Panpsychism? Answering Sabine Hossenfelder @EmersonGreen
Has Physics Debunked Panpsychism? Answering Sabine Hossenfelder  @EmersonGreen
Uploaded April 2020 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Theoretical physicist Sabine Hossenfelder recently published a widely-cited critique of panpsychism. Hossenfelder argues that physics has ruled out panpsychism. However, her article is mired in confusion, and one doesn’t need to be a panpsychist to notice.

Read her criticism, Electrons Don’t Think, here: backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/01/electrons-dont-think.html

“Why do the Deniers ignore a long line of distinguished materialist predecessors and ally themselves with Descartes, their sworn enemy, in holding that experience can’t possibly be physical—thereby obliging themselves to endorse the Denial? The answer appears to be that they share with Descartes one very large assumption: that we know enough about the physical to be certain that experience can’t be physical.”
- Galen Strawson

“What a physiologist sees when he examines a brain is in the physiologist, not in the brain he is examining.”
- Bertrand Russell

“[M]aterialism ... is the philosophy of the subject who forgets himself in his calculation.”
- Schopenhauer

Transcript: emersongreenblog.wordpress.com/2020/03/30/has-physics-debunked-panpsychism-answering-sabine-hossenfelder

Listen to Walden Pod: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/walden-pod/id1474408172

Follow on Twitter @waldenpod

Support the podcast at Patreon.com/waldenpod

https://linktr.ee/emersongreen

/ timestamps /

00:00 Introduction

01:47 Hossenfelder's critique

04:12 Two interpretations of her critique

09:47 Unfalsifiable or falsified?

11:29 Further points of confusion evident in Hossenfelder's critique
Has Physics Debunked Panpsychism? Answering Sabine HossenfelderMeager Moral Fruits w/ @RealAtheology11 Objections to Panpsychism - AnsweredThe Meager Moral Fruits Argument w/ @CadeAlveyGoodLogicLuke Roelofs, Author of Combining Minds: How to Think About Composite SubjectivityResponding to Trent Horns 5 Atheist Double Standards @TheCounselofTrentDebate Review: James Fodor vs. David Pallmann on DualismAyaan Hirsi Alis Conversion - An Atheist ReactsSlavery in the BibleFive Arguments Against God w/ Jonathan MS PearceAtheism, Hell, Mormonism, Aliens, & Simulations w/ @WorldviewsD-JPsychophysical Harmony in a Nutshell
Emerson Green |

Has Physics Debunked Panpsychism? Answering Sabine Hossenfelder

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER