Uploaded September 2016 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Professor L. Randall Wray explaining why governments must run deficits nearly all the time. Here's why:
Imagine the entire economy is just 3 people, named G, D, and F. If D spends some money, it must be going to G or F or both. If D is receiving money, it must have come from G or F or both.
If D spends less than he receives, then either G or F or both must have spent more than they received. If you spend less than you receive, that's called a surplus, and if you spend more than you receive, that's called a deficit. So, if D has a surplus, then either G or F or both must have had a deficit. There is no way for all of them to have a deficit, because there's nowhere else for the money to go. There's no way for all of them to have a surplus, because there's nowhere else for the money to come from.
If D runs a surplus, then he's receiving more than he's spending, so his bank account must be increasing. If D runs a deficit, so that he's receiving less than he's spending, then his bank account must be decreasing. Same for F and G. So between the 3 of them, the question becomes: whose bank account do we want to increase, and whose bank account do we want to decrease? They can't all go up, because they can't all run a surplus.
Scaling up to the real world, G is the government, D is the domestic private sector, and F is the foreign sector (the rest of the world). Between the sectors, there is no way for them all to be in surplus, and no way for them all to be in deficit. If one sector is in in surplus, with its bank accounts rising, then one or both of the remaining sectors must be in deficit.
For the economy to grow, we usually want the private sector to be in surplus. If the private sector were in deficit, it would mean that private bank accounts were decreasing, and more people were going into debt. How can you have a growing economy if on average people are losing their savings and going into debt? The the domestic private sector is usually in surplus when things are going well, meaning average savings are growing and more people are able to pay back debt. This means that either the government or the foreign sector MUST be in deficit, in order to supply this money (or any financial assets) to the private sector.
We usually refer to the foreign sector by talking about the "balance of trade" or the "current account," which is confusing because the terminology switches: a foreign sector deficit is called a "trade surplus," or a "current account surplus," because even though money is flowing FROM the foreign sector, goods and services are flowing TO the foreign sector. Likewise, a foreign sector surplus is called a "trade deficit" or a "current account deficit," where money is flowing TO the foreign sector and goods/services are flowing FROM the foreign sector.
So, to put the private sector into surplus it must get the money either from a government deficit or a current account surplus or both. The problem with relying on the current account surplus is that it's very difficult to affect with policy, since it depends on how much your citizens want to import and what the rest of the world is doing. So most of the time, unless there is a large enough current account surplus, it will be necessary for the government to run deficits. This is especially true if there is a current account deficit, meaning the government will have to run even larger deficits to make up for the money leaking out into the rest of the world.
Luckily, this is perfectly sustainable for a government that issues its own currency, and allows the exchange rate to float, like the US, Britain, Australia, and Japan. Since the government issues the currency, it can always afford any size deficit necessary to fulfill the savings desires of the domestic private sector. The government deficit spending will allow private bank accounts to increase.
See the sectoral balance for the US: thinkleftdotorg.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/picture-35.png
See the Wall Street Journal cover he refers to: neweconomicperspectives.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/untitled-161.png
See the whole video here: youtube.com/watch?v=YxGGR62fh3k
Follow Deficit Owls on Facebook and Twitter:
facebook.com/DeficitOwls
twitter.com/DeficitOwls
Professor L. Randall Wray explaining why governments must run deficits nearly all the time. Here's why:
Imagine the entire economy is just 3 people, named G, D, and F. If D spends some money, it must be going to G or F or both. If D is receiving money, it must have come from G or F or both.
If D spends less than he receives, then either G or F or both must have spent more than they received. If you spend less than you receive, that's called a surplus, and if you spend more than you receive, that's called a deficit. So, if D has a surplus, then either G or F or both must have had a deficit. There is no way for all of them to have a deficit, because there's nowhere else for the money to go. There's no way for all of them to have a surplus, because there's nowhere else for the money to come from.
If D runs a surplus, then he's receiving more than he's spending, so his bank account must be increasing. If D runs a deficit, so that he's receiving less than he's spending, then his bank account must be decreasing. Same for F and G. So between the 3 of them, the question becomes: whose bank account do we want to increase, and whose bank account do we want to decrease? They can't all go up, because they can't all run a surplus.
Scaling up to the real world, G is the government, D is the domestic private sector, and F is the foreign sector (the rest of the world). Between the sectors, there is no way for them all to be in surplus, and no way for them all to be in deficit. If one sector is in in surplus, with its bank accounts rising, then one or both of the remaining sectors must be in deficit.
For the economy to grow, we usually want the private sector to be in surplus. If the private sector were in deficit, it would mean that private bank accounts were decreasing, and more people were going into debt. How can you have a growing economy if on average people are losing their savings and going into debt? The the domestic private sector is usually in surplus when things are going well, meaning average savings are growing and more people are able to pay back debt. This means that either the government or the foreign sector MUST be in deficit, in order to supply this money (or any financial assets) to the private sector.
We usually refer to the foreign sector by talking about the "balance of trade" or the "current account," which is confusing because the terminology switches: a foreign sector deficit is called a "trade surplus," or a "current account surplus," because even though money is flowing FROM the foreign sector, goods and services are flowing TO the foreign sector. Likewise, a foreign sector surplus is called a "trade deficit" or a "current account deficit," where money is flowing TO the foreign sector and goods/services are flowing FROM the foreign sector.
So, to put the private sector into surplus it must get the money either from a government deficit or a current account surplus or both. The problem with relying on the current account surplus is that it's very difficult to affect with policy, since it depends on how much your citizens want to import and what the rest of the world is doing. So most of the time, unless there is a large enough current account surplus, it will be necessary for the government to run deficits. This is especially true if there is a current account deficit, meaning the government will have to run even larger deficits to make up for the money leaking out into the rest of the world.
Luckily, this is perfectly sustainable for a government that issues its own currency, and allows the exchange rate to float, like the US, Britain, Australia, and Japan. Since the government issues the currency, it can always afford any size deficit necessary to fulfill the savings desires of the domestic private sector. The government deficit spending will allow private bank accounts to increase.
See the sectoral balance for the US: thinkleftdotorg.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/picture-35.png
See the Wall Street Journal cover he refers to: neweconomicperspectives.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/untitled-161.png
See the whole video here: youtube.com/watch?v=YxGGR62fh3k
Follow Deficit Owls on Facebook and Twitter:
facebook.com/DeficitOwls
twitter.com/DeficitOwls










