Uploaded October 2018 | Updated November 2026, 12 hours ago
Dr. David Holcomb is the Senior Technical Advisor to the DOE-MSR campaign. He took questions on 2018-10-05, the day after ORNL's 2018 Molten Salt Workshop.
00:49 What changed over the past 5 years?
02:13 Conference changed over years?
03:55 Your work changed over years?
04:31 Current challenges of commercialization?
06:14 What licensing has changed?
08:24 Knock-on effects from licencing changes?
10:41 Fluid Fuel Reactors 1958?
13:11 How to learn about MSR today?
14:14 How original researchers holding up?
16:09 You researcher or manager?
17:01 Corrosion problem?
19:48 MSR design choices?
21:51 How became interested in nuclear?
22:32 Fictional work explaining energy perspective?
24:25 Public misconception about nuclear?
25:46 Funding changes?
28:50 How has funding changed since 2012?
29:48 MSRE documentaries and how found?
35:35 Ongoing research video capture?
37:31 Video not photos and reports?
38:33 Opinions on Alvin Weinberg?
39:55 Positive direction. Early phase. Hope 2030.
41:48 Educational recommendation for MSR work?
ornl.gov/staff-profile/david-eugene-holcomb
Dr. David Holcomb is the Senior Technical Advisor to the DOE-MSR campaign. He took questions on 2018-10-05, the day after ORNL's 2018 Molten Salt Workshop.
00:49 What changed over the past 5 years?
02:13 Conference changed over years?
03:55 Your work changed over years?
04:31 Current challenges of commercialization?
06:14 What licensing has changed?
08:24 Knock-on effects from licencing changes?
10:41 Fluid Fuel Reactors 1958?
13:11 How to learn about MSR today?
14:14 How original researchers holding up?
16:09 You researcher or manager?
17:01 Corrosion problem?
19:48 MSR design choices?
21:51 How became interested in nuclear?
22:32 Fictional work explaining energy perspective?
24:25 Public misconception about nuclear?
25:46 Funding changes?
28:50 How has funding changed since 2012?
29:48 MSRE documentaries and how found?
35:35 Ongoing research video capture?
37:31 Video not photos and reports?
38:33 Opinions on Alvin Weinberg?
39:55 Positive direction. Early phase. Hope 2030.
41:48 Educational recommendation for MSR work?
ornl.gov/staff-profile/david-eugene-holcomb








![Thorium 2017
Thorium is an abundant material currently disposed of as waste. It is found in coal ash piles and mine tailings. A single Rare Earths mine could produce enough Thorium byproduct to power the entire planet.
To do so requires a very different nuclear reactor than the kinds we use today. Not one that uses solid fuel rods, but a reactor in which the fuel is kept in a liquid state. Not one that uses pressurized water as a coolant, but a reactor that uses extremely stable molten salts.
The full description of one such reactor is: 2-Fluid, Thermal-Spectrum, Molten-Salt Breeder Reactor equipped with a chemical fuel salt treatment module. Such a reactor was conceived of decades ago, as documented in the book Fluid Fuel Reactors [1958].
Or, simply LFTR (Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor) as proposed by Flibe Energys Kirk Sorensen... a modern redesign of the 2-Fluid, thermal-spectrum, MSBR concept.
http://Flibe-Energy.com/
Since 2011 (the year Flibe Energy was founded), legislators asking questions about Thorium have had their queries answered as if such a reactor design did not exist.
NNL [UK] and OECD [NEA] reports on the Thorium Fuel Cycle did not explore the implications of this reactor, and dismiss thorium based on challenges and mediocre performance found in other reactor designs.
For example, other options include a Fast-Spectrum Molten-Salt Reactor. Worth pursuing, certainly, but requires more fissile inventory than LFTR... approximately 5x as much. (Fissile inventory is specifically mentioned as a concern by OECDs thorium report.) And assuming the challenges of a fast-spectrum MSR can be met... both natural Uranium and natural Thorium can both be fully consumed as fuel in a fast-spectrum reactor. That is where Thorium is dismissed as only 4x as common as Uranium (fast-spectrum usage) rather than 400x as common as U-235 (thermal-spectrum usage).
Thoriums advantages: both thermal-spectrum breeding and unique chemical properties, are taken full advantage of only by LFTR style reactors.
When evaluated in any other reactor, depending on that reactor, Uranium can be as attractive, more attractive, or Uranium can be the only viable option.
For example: Shippingport. Cited as an example of a Thorium Reactor by Dr. Lyons, it was NEVER intended to be economical, and features no advantages of LFTR. It was a solid-fuel reactor, and so operated at low-temperature, had no on-line chemical reprocessing, used high-pressure water coolant, used fuel as inefficiently as every other solid-fuel reactor, and had to be shut down every time it was refueled. 2 of its 3 fuel loads were Enriched Uranium. It was -a- Reactor capable of consuming Thorium and demonstrated only that it was possible... it was not -THE- Thorium Reactor.
If youd like to watch a mini-series length (6.5h) documentary on this topic, please check out Thorium. https://youtu.be/2oK6Rs6yFsM ...it goes into some technical detail on Thorium and Molten Salt Reactors, as well as nuclear power itself.
This video exists thanks to support pledged via Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thorium
Other videos Ive edited on Thorium & Molten Salt Reactors can be found here: http://ThoriumRemix.com/
Music (at 28:29) created by Kilowatts: http://kilowattsmusic.com/
00:00 LWR: 0.05% of Uraniums Energy Potential
00:54 LWR: Chemical Instability
01:38 LWR: High Pressure
02:48 Alvin Weinberg
03:05 High Temperature not High Pressure
03:40 MSRE Achievement
03:51 Graphite
04:08 Move Heat No Pressure
04:45 Salt: Ionic Bonds
05:33 Fluoride vs Fluorine
06:16 Cesium & Iodine
06:33 Drain Tank
07:53 Disperse Heat
08:36 Solid Fuel: Candles
09:24 Online Chemical Reprocessing
10:15 Legislators ask about Thorium
10:46 OECD NEA Thorium Report
11:23 Fast-Spectrum Dodge
12:08 Spent Fuel
12:34 Efficient
13:49 Concentrated
14:10 Rare Earth Elements
15:41 Chinas Academy of Science
16:34 CO2 Raw Material
17:07 Recycling
18:05 Sorting
18:52 NASA, Recycling & Energy
20:57 Molten Salt Research Halted
21:28 World Set Free
21:55 Documents
22:28 CD-ROMs and Internet
23:15 Obama Administration
24:33 Regulations vs Liquid Fuel
25:12 Stymied in USA
26:08 Flibe Energy
26:41 MSRE Researchers
27:14 Export of MSR Expertise
27:41 China vs Global Warming
28:29 1969-2017 Timeline
33:08 Thousands of years of Slavery
33:32 Energy Density of Thorium
Other Video Sources
02:46 https://youtu.be/EviEN0ScOwg Pandoras Box
03:08 https://youtu.be/ofs6-K7UCSU Weinberg 2011
03:41 https://youtu.be/pGzKuhY50v4 Weinberg 2004
03:41 https://youtu.be/tyDbq5HRs0o Found MSRE Doc
05:34 https://youtu.be/vtWp45Eewtw Fluorine (PToV)
05:54 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoK41_2JS4E_ZZyJSH7g-AhiiwMoCoFCB (MSBR3.0-ORNL-4528)
30:51 http://www.citizen-films.fr/en/thorium/ (T:TFSoN) Thorium 2017](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/c7baTdyHv8g/mqdefault.jpg)

