Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Mom packs an Uncrustable, some chips, and a cup of salsa, and she puts the chips and the salsa together in the little bento box. A friend who just learned about associativity insists she could have grouped them any way she liked. Would you eat that lunch?
Check out the channel! @polymathematic
Same three items, same lunchbox, different grouping, and a very different result. Whatever "grouping doesn't matter" means, it can't mean this.
That's the first thing worth noticing about associativity: it isn't always true, it's simply a property that some operations happen to have. When you can regroup an operation without changing its result, we call the operation associative. But there is no reason to assume any particular operation works this way, and if anything, the lunchbox suggests it would be a little strange to expect regrouping to leave things unchanged in general.
It's also worth being careful about the phrasing. People like to say that commutativity means order doesn't matter and associativity means grouping doesn't matter, but that's not quite what either property says. What they say is that the order or the grouping doesn't change the result. The grouping can matter a great deal, even when the answer comes out identical.
Say you're adding 95 + 13 + 87. One perfectly reasonable approach is to group the first two: (95 + 13) + 87. Now 95 + 13 is 108, and 108 + 87 is 195. Fine. But addition is associative, so you're allowed to regroup: 95 + (13 + 87). And suddenly the problem is suspiciously easy, because 13 + 87 is exactly 100, and 95 + 100 is 195. Same answer, of course, but one path was quite a bit easier.
Which operations get this privilege? Addition and multiplication do. Subtraction and division don't: (8 − 4) − 2 is 2, but 8 − (4 − 2) is 6, and (8 ÷ 4) ÷ 2 is 1 while 8 ÷ (4 ÷ 2) is 4. Exponentiation doesn't either, and there the gap is dramatic: (2³)² is 64, but 2^(3²) is 512. Once you start looking, the operations that let you regroup freely turn out to be the exception rather than the rule. Addition and multiplication just happen to be the ones we meet first, so they feel like the default.
#associativity #mentalmath #numbersense
Watch more Math Videos:
Math Minis: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jkQynJ5heNvSs72gCPj_hwj
Math Minutes: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jmVFYwHiuMzCYJ0y_yiwUge
Number Sense: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jksKkY_oarNFEFAHjrIV97U
MATHCOUNTS: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jlqDkZXtby9lnEaOBy7-ZY0
Follow Tim Ricchuiti:
TikTok: tiktok.com/@polymathematic
Mathstodon: https://mathstodon.xyz/@polymathematic
Instagram: instagram.com/polymathematicnet
Reddit: reddit.com/user/polymath-matic
Facebook: facebook.com/polymathematic
Mom packs an Uncrustable, some chips, and a cup of salsa, and she puts the chips and the salsa together in the little bento box. A friend who just learned about associativity insists she could have grouped them any way she liked. Would you eat that lunch?
Check out the channel! @polymathematic
Same three items, same lunchbox, different grouping, and a very different result. Whatever "grouping doesn't matter" means, it can't mean this.
That's the first thing worth noticing about associativity: it isn't always true, it's simply a property that some operations happen to have. When you can regroup an operation without changing its result, we call the operation associative. But there is no reason to assume any particular operation works this way, and if anything, the lunchbox suggests it would be a little strange to expect regrouping to leave things unchanged in general.
It's also worth being careful about the phrasing. People like to say that commutativity means order doesn't matter and associativity means grouping doesn't matter, but that's not quite what either property says. What they say is that the order or the grouping doesn't change the result. The grouping can matter a great deal, even when the answer comes out identical.
Say you're adding 95 + 13 + 87. One perfectly reasonable approach is to group the first two: (95 + 13) + 87. Now 95 + 13 is 108, and 108 + 87 is 195. Fine. But addition is associative, so you're allowed to regroup: 95 + (13 + 87). And suddenly the problem is suspiciously easy, because 13 + 87 is exactly 100, and 95 + 100 is 195. Same answer, of course, but one path was quite a bit easier.
Which operations get this privilege? Addition and multiplication do. Subtraction and division don't: (8 − 4) − 2 is 2, but 8 − (4 − 2) is 6, and (8 ÷ 4) ÷ 2 is 1 while 8 ÷ (4 ÷ 2) is 4. Exponentiation doesn't either, and there the gap is dramatic: (2³)² is 64, but 2^(3²) is 512. Once you start looking, the operations that let you regroup freely turn out to be the exception rather than the rule. Addition and multiplication just happen to be the ones we meet first, so they feel like the default.
#associativity #mentalmath #numbersense
Watch more Math Videos:
Math Minis: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jkQynJ5heNvSs72gCPj_hwj
Math Minutes: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jmVFYwHiuMzCYJ0y_yiwUge
Number Sense: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jksKkY_oarNFEFAHjrIV97U
MATHCOUNTS: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jlqDkZXtby9lnEaOBy7-ZY0
Follow Tim Ricchuiti:
TikTok: tiktok.com/@polymathematic
Mathstodon: https://mathstodon.xyz/@polymathematic
Instagram: instagram.com/polymathematicnet
Reddit: reddit.com/user/polymath-matic
Facebook: facebook.com/polymathematic










