Uploaded April 2025 | Updated November 2026, 18 hours ago
You’ve probably heard that every fake proof of “0 = 1” involves dividing by 0. But here’s another twist.
Let’s start with something totally true: -6 = -6. On the left, I’ll write that as 4 minus 10. On the right, I’ll write it as 9 minus 15. Why? Doesn’t matter yet. Just go with it.
Next, I’ll rewrite 4 as 2 squared and 9 as 3 squared. That’s still fair. And I’ll rewrite 10 as 2 times 5, and 15 as 3 times 5. Still equal. Just different versions of the same numbers.
Now I’m going to add (5 over 2) squared to both sides. That’s allowed. I’m adding the same thing to both sides of the equation.
Now, on the left side, I’ve got 2 squared minus 2 times 5 plus (5 over 2) squared. That’s a perfect square trinomial. It collapses to (2 minus 5 over 2) squared. Same thing happens on the right with the 3. I get (3 minus 5 over 2) squared.
And since these two squared expressions are equal, I might be tempted to say the expressions inside are equal. So I say 2 minus 5 over 2 equals 3 minus 5 over 2. Which tells me 2 = 3.
The problem isn’t dividing by zero. The problem is assuming that if a squared expression equals another squared expression, then the things being squared must be equal. That’s not always true. Taking square roots is sneaky like that.
#BadProof #MathMistakes #SquareRoots
Follow Tim Ricchuiti:
TikTok: tiktok.com/@polymathematic
Instagram: instagram.com/polymathematicnet
Mathstodon: https://mathstodon.xyz/@polymathematic
Reddit: reddit.com/user/polymath-matic
Facebook: facebook.com/polymathematic
Watch more Math Videos:
Math Minis: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jkQynJ5heNvSs72gCPj_hwj
Math Minutes: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jmVFYwHiuMzCYJ0y_yiwUge
Number Sense: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jksKkY_oarNFEFAHjrIV97U
MATHCOUNTS: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jlqDkZXtby9lnEaOBy7-ZY0
You’ve probably heard that every fake proof of “0 = 1” involves dividing by 0. But here’s another twist.
Let’s start with something totally true: -6 = -6. On the left, I’ll write that as 4 minus 10. On the right, I’ll write it as 9 minus 15. Why? Doesn’t matter yet. Just go with it.
Next, I’ll rewrite 4 as 2 squared and 9 as 3 squared. That’s still fair. And I’ll rewrite 10 as 2 times 5, and 15 as 3 times 5. Still equal. Just different versions of the same numbers.
Now I’m going to add (5 over 2) squared to both sides. That’s allowed. I’m adding the same thing to both sides of the equation.
Now, on the left side, I’ve got 2 squared minus 2 times 5 plus (5 over 2) squared. That’s a perfect square trinomial. It collapses to (2 minus 5 over 2) squared. Same thing happens on the right with the 3. I get (3 minus 5 over 2) squared.
And since these two squared expressions are equal, I might be tempted to say the expressions inside are equal. So I say 2 minus 5 over 2 equals 3 minus 5 over 2. Which tells me 2 = 3.
The problem isn’t dividing by zero. The problem is assuming that if a squared expression equals another squared expression, then the things being squared must be equal. That’s not always true. Taking square roots is sneaky like that.
#BadProof #MathMistakes #SquareRoots
Follow Tim Ricchuiti:
TikTok: tiktok.com/@polymathematic
Instagram: instagram.com/polymathematicnet
Mathstodon: https://mathstodon.xyz/@polymathematic
Reddit: reddit.com/user/polymath-matic
Facebook: facebook.com/polymathematic
Watch more Math Videos:
Math Minis: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jkQynJ5heNvSs72gCPj_hwj
Math Minutes: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jmVFYwHiuMzCYJ0y_yiwUge
Number Sense: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jksKkY_oarNFEFAHjrIV97U
MATHCOUNTS: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrc8spN1b3jlqDkZXtby9lnEaOBy7-ZY0










