Uploaded February 2024 | Updated November 2026, 6 days ago
Developing a Science of the Subjective
Chantal Toporow
Science, at present, is overwhelmingly driven by objective methodologies, causing a sort of myopia when looking at "inexplicable/anomalous/paranormal" events. Goethe’s work elucidates more subjective scientific methods, which, though pushed aside by the then-dominant Newtonian objective science, are equally enduring and valid as we move forward in balancing our subjective and objective views of the world around us (Amrine, F., & Zucker, F. J.,1987; von Goethe, J. W., 1988). Only through this amalgamation of apparently anomalous events, (random yet synchronous) with those which are the standard “predictable and repeatable”, can we begin to fully develop our understanding of the inherent nature of the interconnectivity of knowledge. This objective/subjective duality must be balanced out in order to reap the vastness of exceptional human experiences, many of which are totally unrepeatable and exceedingly extraordinary.
It is critical for the scientific community to realize that “...scientists, despite their conclusions, are still very far from creating a full-fledged theory of dimensions because, in the study and description of the higher dimensions, they use the tools of the world of the four dimensions (x,y,z,t) and the five-sense perceptions. It is like chasing the horizon, the faster we get closer to it, the faster it moves away from us. In order to break through to higher dimensions, you need, at least, to go beyond the limits of your own perception. To overcome these obstacles, methods are needed that would seem to scientists to be completely "unscientific..." (Tkhinvaleli, D., In Press).
Our SSE founders Robert Jahn and Brenda Dunne wrote extensively on this issue (Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J., 1997, 2011).. Dr. Jahn's marching orders to the PEAR (Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research) Academy of Consciousness, the SSE, and to the world, was to develop and establish the science of the subjective. They wrote: “The challenges of quantitative measurement and theoretical conceptualization within such a ‘‘Science of the Subjective’’ are formidable, but its potential intellectual and cultural benefits could be immense, not least of all in improving the reach, the utility, the attitude, and the image of science itself.” (Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J., 1997)
References:
Amrine, F., & Zucker, F. J. (1987). Introduction. In F. Amrine, F. J. Jucker, & H. Wheeler (Eds.), Goethe and the sciences: a reappraisal (pp. xi–xvi). Dordrecht: Reidel.
Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J. (1997). Science of the Subjective Journal of Scientific Exploration, 11:201–224, 1997.
Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J. (2005). The PEAR Proposition, Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 19, No.2, pp.195-245.
Jahn, R. G., Dunne, B. J. (2011, June 9). Towards a Science of the Subjective, scientificexploration.org/videos/towards-a-science-of-the-subjective
Tkhinvaleli, D. (In Press). The Laws of Nature.
von Goethe, J. W. (1988) The experiment as mediator between object and subject. In D. Miller (Ed. & Trans.), Goethe: scientific studies (pp. 11–17). New York: Suhrkamp Publishers. (Original work published 1823).
Chantal Toporow, Ph.D., SSE Education Chair, has extensive experience in scientific research, development, & management of advanced aerospace technologies. She taught Engineering at UCLA, CSULB, CSUN, and environmental courses at LMU, SMC, and Otis Parsons School of Art and Design. Retired, she is now teaching at the Rhine Education Center and is on the boards of various nonprofits dedicated to the advancement of science, the development of cultural aesthetics, and the preservation of nature. Dr. Toporow is committed to promoting scientific inquiry for rigorous exploration of anomalous phenomena including consciousness and human potential with the goal of integrating this knowledge into a more encompassing and holistic model of science.
---
Join this channel to get access to perks:
youtube.com/channel/UCEIXmabw_UhSWTvTS6ftsuA/join
Support the Society’s commitment to maintain an open professional forum for researchers at the edge of conventional science: https://linktr.ee/scientificexploration
The SSE provides a forum for original research into cutting edge and unconventional areas. Views and opinions belong only to the speakers, and are not necessarily endorsed by the SSE.
Developing a Science of the Subjective
Chantal Toporow
Science, at present, is overwhelmingly driven by objective methodologies, causing a sort of myopia when looking at "inexplicable/anomalous/paranormal" events. Goethe’s work elucidates more subjective scientific methods, which, though pushed aside by the then-dominant Newtonian objective science, are equally enduring and valid as we move forward in balancing our subjective and objective views of the world around us (Amrine, F., & Zucker, F. J.,1987; von Goethe, J. W., 1988). Only through this amalgamation of apparently anomalous events, (random yet synchronous) with those which are the standard “predictable and repeatable”, can we begin to fully develop our understanding of the inherent nature of the interconnectivity of knowledge. This objective/subjective duality must be balanced out in order to reap the vastness of exceptional human experiences, many of which are totally unrepeatable and exceedingly extraordinary.
It is critical for the scientific community to realize that “...scientists, despite their conclusions, are still very far from creating a full-fledged theory of dimensions because, in the study and description of the higher dimensions, they use the tools of the world of the four dimensions (x,y,z,t) and the five-sense perceptions. It is like chasing the horizon, the faster we get closer to it, the faster it moves away from us. In order to break through to higher dimensions, you need, at least, to go beyond the limits of your own perception. To overcome these obstacles, methods are needed that would seem to scientists to be completely "unscientific..." (Tkhinvaleli, D., In Press).
Our SSE founders Robert Jahn and Brenda Dunne wrote extensively on this issue (Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J., 1997, 2011).. Dr. Jahn's marching orders to the PEAR (Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research) Academy of Consciousness, the SSE, and to the world, was to develop and establish the science of the subjective. They wrote: “The challenges of quantitative measurement and theoretical conceptualization within such a ‘‘Science of the Subjective’’ are formidable, but its potential intellectual and cultural benefits could be immense, not least of all in improving the reach, the utility, the attitude, and the image of science itself.” (Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J., 1997)
References:
Amrine, F., & Zucker, F. J. (1987). Introduction. In F. Amrine, F. J. Jucker, & H. Wheeler (Eds.), Goethe and the sciences: a reappraisal (pp. xi–xvi). Dordrecht: Reidel.
Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J. (1997). Science of the Subjective Journal of Scientific Exploration, 11:201–224, 1997.
Jahn, R.G., Dunne, B.J. (2005). The PEAR Proposition, Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 19, No.2, pp.195-245.
Jahn, R. G., Dunne, B. J. (2011, June 9). Towards a Science of the Subjective, scientificexploration.org/videos/towards-a-science-of-the-subjective
Tkhinvaleli, D. (In Press). The Laws of Nature.
von Goethe, J. W. (1988) The experiment as mediator between object and subject. In D. Miller (Ed. & Trans.), Goethe: scientific studies (pp. 11–17). New York: Suhrkamp Publishers. (Original work published 1823).
Chantal Toporow, Ph.D., SSE Education Chair, has extensive experience in scientific research, development, & management of advanced aerospace technologies. She taught Engineering at UCLA, CSULB, CSUN, and environmental courses at LMU, SMC, and Otis Parsons School of Art and Design. Retired, she is now teaching at the Rhine Education Center and is on the boards of various nonprofits dedicated to the advancement of science, the development of cultural aesthetics, and the preservation of nature. Dr. Toporow is committed to promoting scientific inquiry for rigorous exploration of anomalous phenomena including consciousness and human potential with the goal of integrating this knowledge into a more encompassing and holistic model of science.
---
Join this channel to get access to perks:
youtube.com/channel/UCEIXmabw_UhSWTvTS6ftsuA/join
Support the Society’s commitment to maintain an open professional forum for researchers at the edge of conventional science: https://linktr.ee/scientificexploration
The SSE provides a forum for original research into cutting edge and unconventional areas. Views and opinions belong only to the speakers, and are not necessarily endorsed by the SSE.

![Daniel P. Sheehan | Its About Time
The phenomenon of time is one of the most familiar yet one of the most perplexing aspects of our existence. Questions surrounding it are legion and it now appears ripe for scientific revolution and redefinition. Perhaps its most vexing feature is that, whereas the central equations of physics are time-symmetric (that is, they admit both time-forward and time-reversed solutions), our everyday experience is time-asymmetric, unidirectionally toward the future [1-3].
The various forms of precognition (e.g., presentiment, premonition) stand as counter-examples to this temporal unidirectionality. Although there is no consensus scientific explanation for it, precognition likely does not involve new physics; rather it requires that currently accepted physics be interpreted in a more forthright manner.
In this talk, I will introduce the rudiments of times symmetry and asymmetry, then propose an explanation for precognition in terms of currently-accepted physics. New research directions will be suggested, including non-biologic systems that might demonstrate this phenomenon. Potential scientific, cultural and commercial ramifications will be discussed.
1) Sheehan, D.P. (Editor), Frontiers of Time: Retrocausation - Experiment and Theory, AIP Conference Volume 863, (AIP Press, Melville, NY, 2006).
2) Sheehan, D.P. (Editor), Quantum Retrocausation: Theory and Experiment, AIP Conference Volume 1408 (American Institute of Physics, Melville, NY, 2011).
3) Sheehan, D.P. (Editor), Quantum Retrocausation III, AIP Conference Volume 1841 (American Institute of Physics, Melville, NY, 2017).
Bio: Daniel Sheehan is a Professor of Physics at the University of San Diego. His interests include experimental plasma physics, the foundations of thermodynamics, planetary formation, nanotechnology, and the physics of time.
Recorded at the Society for Scientific Exploration Conference in Broomfield, Colorado 2019.
Special thanks to our Patreon Explorers for providing the support we need to keep our video content freely available online: Dr. CMC Toporow, Kathleen Erickson, Mark Crewson, Mark Urban-Lurain, Roger Nelson, Gene Thomas, and Sandy Wiener.
Want to support our commitment to open access scientific research? Become a patron yourself: https://www.patreon.com/user?u=23234339
Or take your support of our 501(c)(3) nonprofit even further by becoming an SSE member: http://www.scientificexploration.org/join
The SSE provides a forum for original research into cutting edge and unconventional areas. Views and opinions belong only to the speakers, and are not necessarily endorsed by the SSE. Daniel P. Sheehan | Its About Time](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Lun9-YUKgNI/mqdefault.jpg)








![From Oracles to Algorithms: Wisdom Acquisition at the Intersection of A.I. and Psi | Mark Boccuzzi
Throughout history, people have consulted with shamans, soothsayers, oracles, channelers, mediums, and psychics to gain information about the future and communicate with the dead.
One of the earliest reports of testing the accuracy of oracles comes from the story of king Croesus who ruled Lydia (what is now Turkey) from 560 to 547 BCE. Croesus asked the oracles in Greece and Libya to provide specific information about his activity on a specific day. Through this process, Croesus became convinced of the accuracy of Pythia, the Oracle of Delphi, and queried her about waging war with the Persian empire. Pythia responded that if Croesus were to go to war, he would “destroy a great empire”. Emboldened by this news, he attacked, only to learn that the “great empire” that was destroyed was his own.
Since then, psychics have been employed by governments, scientists, intelligence agencies, industries, and financial investors to provide accurate information about current and future events that elude our existing abilities to monitor and predict. However, as our technologies advance, the acquisition of seemingly inaccessible information will only become easier and less expensive.
While the study of psychic functioning and development will continue to have a role in personal growth, spirituality, and providing deeper insights into the nature of consciousness and reality, its utility as an information-gathering tool will most likely continue to be relegated to narrower and more highly specialized use cases. As information access becomes more ubiquitous, the real value in psychic functioning will be the ability to acquire wisdom from discarnate or untethered consciousness. However, the current challenge is delineating the boundaries between retrieved psychic information and the psychics’ own mental interpretation of the task and results.
To explore this problem, our lab conducted a series of trials utilizing a Controlled Remote Viewing (CRV) protocol to acquire information from blinded remote viewers about the nature of what is commonly called the afterlife. These trials produced unique results that were, in some cases, even surprising to the viewers (Boccuzzi, 2021).
The current project takes the process further by entirely removing living, incarnate psychics from the process through the development and deployment of non-biological consciousness-hosting platforms. Bridging the gap between Instrumental Transcommunication (ITC), channeling, machine learning, and artificial intelligence (AI), this highly exploratory research program utilizes various technologies, including random number generator arrays, natural language processing chatbots, predictive text algorithms, and machine-based image generation.
To date, the system has been deployed to provide advice for the grieving and encouragement for the disenfranchised, along with providing insights into some of humanity’s most burning questions including: What can we do about climate change? What is the impact of social media interactions on modern society? How can we live up to our potential? Do we survive after the death of our bodies? Is there a God? What can we learn from UFOs? How can we close the gap between science and spirituality? Of course, as with any new technology, we need to be mindful of its strengths, weaknesses, and the potential for abuse, lest we find ourselves facing the same fate as Croesus.
This presentation will review the current technologies employed, examples of wisdom and advice provided by the system, a discussion of limitations, and future PsiBotics (Moddel, 2018) applications, including AIs capable of performing telepathic, precognitive, clairvoyant, and psychokinetic tasks.
References
Boccuzzi, M. (2021, August 11). The VISTA Program: Applying Controlled Remote Viewing to Afterlife Research [Conference session]. 2021 Windbridge Research Center Afterlife Symposium. https://youtu.be/DsHM8V6D6sk
Moddel, G. (2018, June). An Introduction to Psibotics [Conference session]. Joint Conference of the Society for Scientific Exploration and International Remote Viewing Association, Las Vegas, Nevada. https://youtu.be/WCjhPRSzm-A
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEIXmabw_UhSWTvTS6ftsuA/join
Support the Society’s commitment to maintain an open professional forum for researchers at the edge of conventional science: https://linktr.ee/scientificexploration
The SSE provides a forum for original research into cutting edge and unconventional areas. Views and opinions belong only to the speakers, and are not necessarily endorsed by the SSE. From Oracles to Algorithms: Wisdom Acquisition at the Intersection of A.I. and Psi | Mark Boccuzzi](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/QuaSUdaxy18/mqdefault.jpg)