Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 9 hours ago
Who is really responsible for censorship on social media: powerful tech companies or the government officials pressuring them?
Sohrab Ahmari recounts his experience as opinion editor of the New York Post during the Hunter Biden laptop controversy, when Facebook restricted circulation of the newspaper's reporting and Twitter suspended its account. He argues that private platforms have become our de facto public square, exercising enormous power over political speech with little accountability.
Robby Soave acknowledges the seriousness of these censorship decisions but pushes back on their underlying cause. He argues that government pressure, including threats of regulation and punishment, has driven many of Big Tech's most consequential moderation decisions, making government power the greater threat to free expression.
Moderated by Leah Libresco-Sargeant, this exchange comes from ISI's Fault Lines debate, “Oligarchy Has Destroyed American Democracy.”
Watch the full debate: youtu.be/VN-E95rT9lE
Go deeper with ISI: isi.org/join
Subscribe for more debates from Fault Lines on the biggest political, cultural, and philosophical questions dividing America.
Who is really responsible for censorship on social media: powerful tech companies or the government officials pressuring them?
Sohrab Ahmari recounts his experience as opinion editor of the New York Post during the Hunter Biden laptop controversy, when Facebook restricted circulation of the newspaper's reporting and Twitter suspended its account. He argues that private platforms have become our de facto public square, exercising enormous power over political speech with little accountability.
Robby Soave acknowledges the seriousness of these censorship decisions but pushes back on their underlying cause. He argues that government pressure, including threats of regulation and punishment, has driven many of Big Tech's most consequential moderation decisions, making government power the greater threat to free expression.
Moderated by Leah Libresco-Sargeant, this exchange comes from ISI's Fault Lines debate, “Oligarchy Has Destroyed American Democracy.”
Watch the full debate: youtu.be/VN-E95rT9lE
Go deeper with ISI: isi.org/join
Subscribe for more debates from Fault Lines on the biggest political, cultural, and philosophical questions dividing America.










