Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In this episode of "Fault Lines," Jacob Imam and James Patterson debate whether post-liberalism offers a viable alternative to modern liberalism or whether its political and historical foundations have already proven unsuccessful.
Patterson argues that post-liberal political movements have repeatedly compromised religious freedom, individual rights, and the independence of the Church. Drawing on historical examples of Catholic authoritarian regimes, he warns that concentrating political power in the name of the common good risks repeating the failures of the past. Imam challenges that understanding of post-liberalism, arguing that its true foundation lies not in state power but in Christian tradition, virtue, and the cultivation of strong families and local communities. He contends that modern liberalism has weakened these natural institutions by expanding state sovereignty at their expense.
Their debate ranges from Catholic integralism, the French Revolution, and the American founding to religious liberty, the separation of church and state, local self-government, and the relationship between law and virtue. Along the way, they confront a deeper question: can a political order rooted in Christian tradition flourish within modern liberal institutions, or must society move beyond liberalism altogether?
The debate is moderated by Sarah Gustafson, assistant professor of politics at the Catholic University of America.
About the speakers:
Jacob Imam is the president of the College of St. Joseph the Worker and a scholar associated with the New Polity school of post-liberal thought. His work explores Catholic social teaching, political theology, economics, and the role of Christian communities in cultivating virtue and the common good.
James Patterson is an assistant professor of public affairs at the Institute of American Civics at the University of Tennessee's Baker School and co-author of "Why Postliberalism Failed." His scholarship focuses on political theory, American political thought, religion, and the historical relationship between Christianity and political institutions.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
1:01 The Debate: Has Post-Liberalism Failed?
1:40 James Patterson: The Failure of Post-Liberalism
4:16 Jacob Imam: The Case for Post-Liberalism
9:18 Are All Post-Liberals Integralists?
10:36 Can Christian Tradition Be Revived?
21:04 Why Liberals Struggle to Govern
25:27 How the Modern State Replaced Tradition
35:31 Has Liberalism Lost Its Legitimacy?
58:46 Can the State Make Us Virtuous?
1:20:20 Does America Have a Future?
1:27:22 Closing Statements
Go deeper with ISI:
isi.org/join
Subscribe to ISI for more debates, conversations, and lectures.
In this episode of "Fault Lines," Jacob Imam and James Patterson debate whether post-liberalism offers a viable alternative to modern liberalism or whether its political and historical foundations have already proven unsuccessful.
Patterson argues that post-liberal political movements have repeatedly compromised religious freedom, individual rights, and the independence of the Church. Drawing on historical examples of Catholic authoritarian regimes, he warns that concentrating political power in the name of the common good risks repeating the failures of the past. Imam challenges that understanding of post-liberalism, arguing that its true foundation lies not in state power but in Christian tradition, virtue, and the cultivation of strong families and local communities. He contends that modern liberalism has weakened these natural institutions by expanding state sovereignty at their expense.
Their debate ranges from Catholic integralism, the French Revolution, and the American founding to religious liberty, the separation of church and state, local self-government, and the relationship between law and virtue. Along the way, they confront a deeper question: can a political order rooted in Christian tradition flourish within modern liberal institutions, or must society move beyond liberalism altogether?
The debate is moderated by Sarah Gustafson, assistant professor of politics at the Catholic University of America.
About the speakers:
Jacob Imam is the president of the College of St. Joseph the Worker and a scholar associated with the New Polity school of post-liberal thought. His work explores Catholic social teaching, political theology, economics, and the role of Christian communities in cultivating virtue and the common good.
James Patterson is an assistant professor of public affairs at the Institute of American Civics at the University of Tennessee's Baker School and co-author of "Why Postliberalism Failed." His scholarship focuses on political theory, American political thought, religion, and the historical relationship between Christianity and political institutions.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
1:01 The Debate: Has Post-Liberalism Failed?
1:40 James Patterson: The Failure of Post-Liberalism
4:16 Jacob Imam: The Case for Post-Liberalism
9:18 Are All Post-Liberals Integralists?
10:36 Can Christian Tradition Be Revived?
21:04 Why Liberals Struggle to Govern
25:27 How the Modern State Replaced Tradition
35:31 Has Liberalism Lost Its Legitimacy?
58:46 Can the State Make Us Virtuous?
1:20:20 Does America Have a Future?
1:27:22 Closing Statements
Go deeper with ISI:
isi.org/join
Subscribe to ISI for more debates, conversations, and lectures.










