Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Are oligarchs running America?
In this episode of "Fault Lines," Sohrab Ahmari and Robby Soave debate whether concentrated wealth and corporate power have undermined American democracy.
Ahmari argues that America increasingly suffers from electoral, market, and informational oligarchy, with wealthy donors, powerful corporations, and technology platforms exercising influence that ordinary citizens cannot match. Soave challenges that diagnosis, arguing that many of America's supposed oligarchs gained their wealth by building companies that people voluntarily use, face vigorous competition from one another, and wield far less control over government than the term "oligarchy" suggests.
Their debate ranges from Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg to Citizens United, Big Tech, corporate consolidation, labor unions, cryptocurrency, AI, campaign spending, and the influence of billionaires on American politics. Along the way, they confront a deeper question: when does economic power become political power, and how much concentrated wealth can a healthy democracy withstand?
The debate is moderated by Leah Libresco-Sargeant, author of The Dignity of Dependence.
About the speakers:
Sohrab Ahmari is the U.S. editor of UnHerd and the author of Tyranny, Inc.: How Private Power Crushed American Liberty and What to Do About It, a critique of concentrated private economic power and its effects on workers and American society. His writing focuses on politics, economics, religion, and the changing American right.
Robby Soave is a senior editor at Reason and host of Rising on Hill TV. He writes on politics, culture, education, civil liberties, and technology and is the author of Tech Panic: Why We Shouldn't Fear Facebook and the Future and Panic Attack: Young Radicals in the Age of Trump. His work frequently examines free speech, technology, government regulation, and individual liberty.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:45 Has Oligarchy Destroyed American Democracy?
1:32 Sohrab Ahmari: The Case Against Oligarchy
7:23 Robby Soave: The Case Against the Oligarchy Thesis
11:33 Are Oligarchs Running America?
37:28 Corporate Power & Market Oligopolies
56:54 Crypto, Money & Elections
1:06:54 AI & the Concentration of Power
1:16:28 Closing Statements
1:27:24 End
Go deeper with ISI:
isi.org/join
Subscribe to ISI for more debates, conversations, and lectures.
Are oligarchs running America?
In this episode of "Fault Lines," Sohrab Ahmari and Robby Soave debate whether concentrated wealth and corporate power have undermined American democracy.
Ahmari argues that America increasingly suffers from electoral, market, and informational oligarchy, with wealthy donors, powerful corporations, and technology platforms exercising influence that ordinary citizens cannot match. Soave challenges that diagnosis, arguing that many of America's supposed oligarchs gained their wealth by building companies that people voluntarily use, face vigorous competition from one another, and wield far less control over government than the term "oligarchy" suggests.
Their debate ranges from Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg to Citizens United, Big Tech, corporate consolidation, labor unions, cryptocurrency, AI, campaign spending, and the influence of billionaires on American politics. Along the way, they confront a deeper question: when does economic power become political power, and how much concentrated wealth can a healthy democracy withstand?
The debate is moderated by Leah Libresco-Sargeant, author of The Dignity of Dependence.
About the speakers:
Sohrab Ahmari is the U.S. editor of UnHerd and the author of Tyranny, Inc.: How Private Power Crushed American Liberty and What to Do About It, a critique of concentrated private economic power and its effects on workers and American society. His writing focuses on politics, economics, religion, and the changing American right.
Robby Soave is a senior editor at Reason and host of Rising on Hill TV. He writes on politics, culture, education, civil liberties, and technology and is the author of Tech Panic: Why We Shouldn't Fear Facebook and the Future and Panic Attack: Young Radicals in the Age of Trump. His work frequently examines free speech, technology, government regulation, and individual liberty.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:45 Has Oligarchy Destroyed American Democracy?
1:32 Sohrab Ahmari: The Case Against Oligarchy
7:23 Robby Soave: The Case Against the Oligarchy Thesis
11:33 Are Oligarchs Running America?
37:28 Corporate Power & Market Oligopolies
56:54 Crypto, Money & Elections
1:06:54 AI & the Concentration of Power
1:16:28 Closing Statements
1:27:24 End
Go deeper with ISI:
isi.org/join
Subscribe to ISI for more debates, conversations, and lectures.










