Empire vs. Restraint: Whats Best for America? | Fault Lines @EducatingForLiberty
Empire vs. Restraint: Whats Best for America? | Fault Lines  @EducatingForLiberty
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 15 hours ago
Welcome to "Fault Lines," a debate series from the Intercollegiate Studies Institute bringing serious thinkers together to debate the political, cultural, and intellectual questions shaping our world.

In this installment, Curt Mills and Phillip Blond debate the resolution: "Empire Is Bad for America." At stake is whether America's global power and network of alliances protect the country's prosperity and security or entangle Americans in costly wars, commitments, and institutions that no longer serve their interests.

Mills argues that America's imperial turn has weakened the country's republican traditions, drawn it into unnecessary conflicts, and diverted attention and resources away from the interests of ordinary Americans. Blond counters that empire is not an aberration but a recurring feature of political organization and argues that American power, properly ordered around shared Western values and alliances rather than liberal hegemony, can preserve peace and counter rival powers.

The debate ranges across American history, nationalism and liberalism, Iran and Ukraine, China and Taiwan, NATO and America's allies, Greenland, the postwar international order, and whether the United States can or should retreat from its role as a global hegemon.

Timestamps:

0:00 Opening Highlights
0:37 Opening Remarks
1:07 Curt Mills: The Case Against Empire
4:16 Phillip Blond: The Case for Empire
7:01 Is American Empire Bad for Americans?
11:58 Liberal Hegemony vs. Empire
15:06 Does Empire Preserve Peace?
20:46 Isolationism, Autarky & Christianity
25:19 Can America Opt Out of Empire?
30:58 Pax Americana & the Power of Allies
35:25 Nationalism vs. Empire
40:30 Do Alliances Make America Stronger?
46:03 Greenland & American Hegemony
49:16 China, Taiwan & a Multipolar World
55:23 Venezuela, China & American Power
1:01:20 Can America Confront China Without Allies?
1:05:32 Should America Leave Russia & Iran Alone?
1:10:39 Ukraine, Iran & the Politics of Intervention
1:13:02 Is Taking Greenland Imperialism?
1:15:37 Is Ukraine a Necessary War for the West?
1:20:45 Was America Founded as an Empire?
1:23:57 Empire, Political Liberty & the Administrative State
1:30:25 Closing Remarks

About the Speakers

Curt Mills is the Executive Director of The American Conservative in Washington, D.C. He previously served as Senior Reporter and Contributing Editor, and his work has appeared in the New York Times, Politico, UnHerd, Newsweek, and The Critic. Mills specializes in foreign policy and campaign coverage and has previously worked at The National Interest, U.S. News & World Report, Washington Examiner, and The Spectator.

Phillip Blond is an internationally recognized political thinker and social and economic commentator and the founder and Director of ResPublica. An academic, journalist, and author, he previously taught theology and philosophy at the Universities of Exeter and Cumbria. He is the author of Red Tory, which sought to redefine the center ground of British politics around civil association, mutual ownership, and shared enterprise.

Moderated by Sarah Gustafson, Assistant Professor of Politics at The Catholic University of America. Her research interests include the history of political thought, Alexis de Tocqueville, Western political philosophy, the Catholic intellectual tradition, and normative political theory.

About "Fault Lines":
"Fault Lines" is an ISI debate series exploring the arguments and disagreements shaping the future of conservatism and American public life.

Go deeper with ISI:
isi.org/join
Empire vs. Restraint: Whats Best for America? | Fault LinesMaster Sculptor: Art Represents Who We AreWas Machiavelli Evil?$40 Trillion in Debt: Whos to Blame? | Fault Lines DebateWhy AI Cannot Replace JournalistsA Master Sculptors Take on Modern ArtThe Need for Silence in a World of DistractionJulius Krein: The Hidden Cost of Neoliberal EconomicsTim Carneys Best Advice for Young JournalistsHow can Christians navigate technology?The AI Demand for ElectricityThe Western Canon
Intercollegiate Studies Institute |

Empire vs. Restraint: What's Best for America? | Fault Lines

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER