Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Welcome to Fault Lines, a new debate series from the Intercollegiate Studies Institute bringing serious thinkers together to debate the political, cultural, and intellectual questions dividing the American right.
In our first debate, Christopher Caldwell and Dan McCarthy take on the resolution: “Trump Killed Trumpism.” Moderated by Leah Libresco, the conversation asks what Trumpism actually is, whether Donald Trump has advanced or undermined the movement he created, and what will remain of it after he leaves office.
Caldwell argues that Trumpism was built around controlled borders, dignified work, opposition to unnecessary foreign wars, and a promise to “drain the swamp.” McCarthy challenges the idea that Trumpism is an ideology at all, arguing instead that it is a response to declining trust in American institutions and a political force likely to outlast Trump himself.
Their debate ranges from immigration, tariffs, corruption, and the Iran war to the future of conservative institutions, the changing Republican coalition, AI, and the prospects of JD Vance and Marco Rubio in 2028.
Chapters:
0:00 – Opening Highlights
1:09 – Introduction
1:50 – Caldwell: What Is Trumpism?
6:14 – McCarthy: Trumpism & Institutional Decline
13:04 – Trump, Crypto & Corruption
33:06 – Trump’s Durable Wins
46:30 – Building Conservative Institutions
54:10 – Trumpism & the Three-Legged Stool
1:14:54 – 2028: Vance vs. Rubio
1:29:53 – Trumpism’s Legacy
About the Speakers
Christopher Caldwell is a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute and contributing editor of the Claremont Review of Books. He is the author of The Age of Entitlement: America Since the Sixties and Reflections on the Revolution in Europe.
Dan McCarthy is Distinguished Fellow in Conservative Thought at The Heritage Foundation and editor-in-chief of ISI’s Modern Age. A longtime writer and editor, he previously served as editor of The American Conservative and ISI’s vice president of publications.
Leah Libresco is a writer and author whose work has appeared in The New York Times, First Things, The Dispatch, and The New Atlantis. She is the author of The Dignity of Dependence, Arriving at Amen, and Building the Benedict Option.
About Fault Lines:
Fault Lines is an ISI debate series exploring the arguments and disagreements shaping the future of conservatism and American public life.
Subscribe to ISI for future debates, conversations, and lectures.
isi.org/join
Welcome to Fault Lines, a new debate series from the Intercollegiate Studies Institute bringing serious thinkers together to debate the political, cultural, and intellectual questions dividing the American right.
In our first debate, Christopher Caldwell and Dan McCarthy take on the resolution: “Trump Killed Trumpism.” Moderated by Leah Libresco, the conversation asks what Trumpism actually is, whether Donald Trump has advanced or undermined the movement he created, and what will remain of it after he leaves office.
Caldwell argues that Trumpism was built around controlled borders, dignified work, opposition to unnecessary foreign wars, and a promise to “drain the swamp.” McCarthy challenges the idea that Trumpism is an ideology at all, arguing instead that it is a response to declining trust in American institutions and a political force likely to outlast Trump himself.
Their debate ranges from immigration, tariffs, corruption, and the Iran war to the future of conservative institutions, the changing Republican coalition, AI, and the prospects of JD Vance and Marco Rubio in 2028.
Chapters:
0:00 – Opening Highlights
1:09 – Introduction
1:50 – Caldwell: What Is Trumpism?
6:14 – McCarthy: Trumpism & Institutional Decline
13:04 – Trump, Crypto & Corruption
33:06 – Trump’s Durable Wins
46:30 – Building Conservative Institutions
54:10 – Trumpism & the Three-Legged Stool
1:14:54 – 2028: Vance vs. Rubio
1:29:53 – Trumpism’s Legacy
About the Speakers
Christopher Caldwell is a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute and contributing editor of the Claremont Review of Books. He is the author of The Age of Entitlement: America Since the Sixties and Reflections on the Revolution in Europe.
Dan McCarthy is Distinguished Fellow in Conservative Thought at The Heritage Foundation and editor-in-chief of ISI’s Modern Age. A longtime writer and editor, he previously served as editor of The American Conservative and ISI’s vice president of publications.
Leah Libresco is a writer and author whose work has appeared in The New York Times, First Things, The Dispatch, and The New Atlantis. She is the author of The Dignity of Dependence, Arriving at Amen, and Building the Benedict Option.
About Fault Lines:
Fault Lines is an ISI debate series exploring the arguments and disagreements shaping the future of conservatism and American public life.
Subscribe to ISI for future debates, conversations, and lectures.
isi.org/join










