DEBATE: Free Trade Has Destroyed America | Fault Lines @EducatingForLiberty
DEBATE: Free Trade Has Destroyed America | Fault Lines  @EducatingForLiberty
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Has free trade weakened America?

In this episode of "Fault Lines," Julius Krein and Phillip Magness debate whether neoliberalism, free trade, and decades of economic liberalization have undermined American prosperity and national security.

Krein argues that globalization has hollowed out critical industries, weakened domestic manufacturing, and left America dangerously dependent on China. He contends that targeted tariffs and strategic government investment are necessary to rebuild the nation's industrial strength. Magness challenges that diagnosis, arguing that free trade has delivered substantial economic benefits while government intervention, excessive regulation, and protectionist policies have often done more harm than good. He warns that tariffs and industrial subsidies invite political favoritism, raise consumer costs, and undermine economic competitiveness.

Their debate ranges from China's economic rise and Trump's tariffs to trade deficits, government spending, higher education, and the defense industrial base. Along the way, they confront a deeper question: can free markets restore American industry, or does competition with China demand a more active role for government?

The debate is moderated by Sarah Gustafson.

Timestamps:

0:00 Opening Remarks
0:58 Debate Introduction & Resolution
1:19 Julius Krein: Neoliberalism's Policy Mistakes
6:53 Financial Markets & Chronic Trade Deficits
9:47 Phil Magness: Reagan Tax Cuts & the Inequality Myth
12:46 Deficits: Reagan, Bush, and the Clinton Exception
14:43 The $40 Trillion Debt Problem
20:52 The China Shock & Rust Belt Labor Shifts
34:41 Tariffs: Trump's Liberation Day & Historical Echoes
49:08 Reindustrialization & the Post-COVID Economy
1:05:36 Culture, Commerce, and Morality
1:11:43 Closing Statements

**About the speakers:**

Julius Krein is the founder and editor of *American Affairs*, a journal of political and economic thought. His writing focuses on industrial policy, political economy, national security, and American economic competitiveness.

Phillip W. Magness is the David J. Theroux Chair in Political Economy at the Independent Institute. An economic historian, his research examines taxation, inequality, trade, government intervention, and the history of economic thought.

**Go deeper with ISI:**
isi.org/join

Subscribe to ISI for more debates, conversations, and lectures.
DEBATE: Free Trade Has Destroyed America | Fault LinesHow the Iran War Could Define Trump’s Presidency | Christopher CaldwellEnchanting the Machine: Liturgy, Technology, & WonderWhat Inspires Men to Greatness?The Original Purpose of UniversityHow Russell Kirk Met His Wife Through ISIOpenAI Strategists Response to Pope LeoAre Podcasts Sufficient For Deep Learning?What Can Tocqueville Teach Us Today?Do America’s Allies Actually Make It Stronger? | Fault LinesTeachers Need to Maintain Standards, Not Lower ThemGraduating Soon? This Fellowship Pays $75K to Work in a Real Newsroom
Intercollegiate Studies Institute |

DEBATE: Free Trade Has Destroyed America | Fault Lines

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER